- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
What non-constitutional bodies are: statutory and executive bodies
Understand the difference between constitutional, statutory and executive bodies, and learn a simple test to classify any public body.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
India's government works through many commissions, councils and agencies. Some of them are written into the Constitution, but many important ones are not. The National Human Rights Commission, the Central Vigilance Commission, the CBI and NITI Aayog are all examples of bodies that do not appear in the Constitution. Competitive exams regularly ask which bodies are constitutional and which are not, so this first lesson gives you a clear, simple way to tell them apart.
Three ways a public body can be born
Think of every public body as having a 'birth certificate'. The question is simply: which document created it? There are three possible answers.
- The Constitution creates it. Such a body is a constitutional body, for example the Election Commission (Article 324) or the Finance Commission (Article 280). Changing its basic features needs a constitutional amendment.
- An Act passed by Parliament or a state legislature creates it. Such a body is a statutory body, for example the National Human Rights Commission, created by the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993. The legislature can change or repeal the Act.
- A decision of the government (a cabinet resolution or an executive order) creates it. Such a body is an executive body, also called a non-statutory body, for example NITI Aayog. The government that created it can change or close it.
Both statutory and executive bodies are non-constitutional, because neither is created by the Constitution itself. So 'non-constitutional' is the bigger group, and it splits into two parts: statutory (from a law) and executive (from a government decision).
| Body | Created by | Type |
|---|---|---|
| National Human Rights Commission | Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 | Statutory |
| Central Vigilance Commission | Executive resolution (1964); CVC Act, 2003 | Statutory (since 2003) |
| Lokpal | Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013 | Statutory |
| Central Information Commission | Right to Information Act, 2005 | Statutory |
| National Green Tribunal | National Green Tribunal Act, 2010 | Statutory |
| NITI Aayog | Union Cabinet resolution (2015) | Executive |
| Central Bureau of Investigation | Home Ministry resolution (1963) | Executive |
Why the difference matters
The type of a body tells you how secure it is and who can change it. A constitutional body is the most protected. A statutory body is protected by its Act: its members usually have a fixed term and can be removed only in the way the Act says. An executive body depends most directly on the government of the day. Importance is not the test. The CBI is very powerful, yet it is an executive body; it uses powers given by the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946, but it was itself set up by a resolution.
Worked example 1: classify three bodies
Classify the Finance Commission, the National Human Rights Commission and NITI Aayog. Step 1: ask what created each. The Finance Commission is created by Article 280 of the Constitution, so it is constitutional. The NHRC is created by an Act of 1993, so it is statutory. NITI Aayog was created by a Union Cabinet resolution in 2015, so it is executive. Step 2: group them. Only the Finance Commission is constitutional; the other two are non-constitutional.
Worked example 2: a body that changed type
The Central Vigilance Commission was set up in 1964 by a government resolution, so at first it was an executive body. In 2003 Parliament passed the Central Vigilance Commission Act, which made it a statutory body. Was it ever constitutional? No. So if a question asks 'What is the CVC today?', the answer is 'a statutory body', and if it asks 'How did it begin?', the answer is 'by an executive resolution'. Read the time in the question carefully.
Find the birth certificate: the Constitution makes a constitutional body, an Act makes a statutory body, and a government resolution or order makes an executive body. Statutory and executive bodies are both non-constitutional.
Key takeaways
Non-constitutional bodies are of two kinds: statutory (created by law) and executive (created by government decision). Use the birth-certificate test, not the body's importance. Remember that a body can change type over time, as the CVC did in 2003. In the next lessons we study the most important non-constitutional bodies one by one.
Check your understanding
-
1. A body created by an Act of Parliament is called a:
- Constitutional body
- Statutory body
- Executive body
- Judicial body
Show answer
Answer: B. A body created by a law passed by a legislature is a statutory body. A constitutional body is created by the Constitution, and an executive body by a government resolution or order.
-
2. Which of the following is an executive (non-statutory) body?
- National Human Rights Commission
- Lokpal
- NITI Aayog
- Central Information Commission
Show answer
Answer: C. NITI Aayog was created by a Union Cabinet resolution in 2015. The NHRC, Lokpal and Central Information Commission were created by Acts of Parliament, so they are statutory.
-
3. The National Human Rights Commission was created by:
- The Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993
- Article 324 of the Constitution
- A Union Cabinet resolution
- The Right to Information Act, 2005
Show answer
Answer: A. The NHRC is a statutory body created under the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993.
-
4. In which year did the Central Vigilance Commission become a statutory body?
- 1964
- 1993
- 2013
- 2003
Show answer
Answer: D. The CVC was set up in 1964 by an executive resolution and became statutory when Parliament passed the Central Vigilance Commission Act in 2003.
-
5. Which statement is correct?
- Every powerful body is a constitutional body
- Statutory and executive bodies are both non-constitutional
- An executive body is created by an Act of Parliament
- A statutory body can be changed only by a constitutional amendment
Show answer
Answer: B. Neither statutory bodies (created by law) nor executive bodies (created by government decision) are created by the Constitution, so both are non-constitutional. Power is not the test, and a statutory body can be changed by amending its Act.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.