- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
President, Vice-President and Governor: look-alike facts and a mixed set
Separate the facts that examiners place side by side for the President, Vice-President and Governor, then attempt a mixed set.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The President, the Vice-President and the Governor share many features: all are constitutional heads and all carry the age of 35. The differences are the exam's favourite. This lesson sets out the differences and ends with a mixed set to test them.
Side-by-side facts
| Point | President | Vice-President | Governor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum age | 35 | 35 | 35 |
| Chosen by | Electoral college of elected MPs and MLAs | Members of both Houses of Parliament | Appointed by the President |
| Term | Five years | Five years | Five years, at the President's pleasure |
| Removal | Impeachment (Article 61) | Rajya Sabha resolution with the Lok Sabha's agreement | At the President's pleasure |
| Pardon power | Article 72, includes death sentences | None | Article 161, not death sentences |
| Presides over | Nothing in a House | Rajya Sabha | Nothing in a House |
| Acts as President | Not applicable | Yes, in a vacancy | No |
Where examiners hide the difference
- The age is the same for the three, so a question rarely asks it as the point of difference.
- The electorate differs: only the President's includes State Assemblies.
- The ground for removal differs: only the President's is limited to violation of the Constitution.
- Pardoning power belongs only to the President and the Governor, and the Governor's is narrower.
- A Governor is not elected and cannot be impeached.
Worked example 1: mixed statements
Statements: (1) The Vice-President and the Governor both have the power to grant pardon. (2) Members of both Houses of Parliament take part in electing both the President and the Vice-President. (3) The Governor is appointed by the President. Options: (A) 1 only, (B) 2 and 3 only, (C) 3 only, (D) 1 and 3 only. Step 1: the Vice-President has no pardoning power, so statement 1 is false. Step 2: elected members of both Houses vote for the President and all members of both Houses vote for the Vice-President, so statement 2 is true. Step 3: statement 3 is true, since Article 155 provides for appointment by the President. Answer: (B).
Worked example 2: who presides?
Question: At a joint sitting of Parliament, the Speaker presides. If the Speaker is absent, who presides? The Deputy Speaker, then the Deputy Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, then such other person as the House decides. The Vice-President does not preside at a joint sitting, although he is the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha. This catches many students. At a sitting of the Rajya Sabha alone, the Vice-President (as Chairman) presides.
Same age (35) and term (5 years). Different: electorate, removal, pardon, presiding role. The Governor is appointed, not elected, and cannot be impeached.
Worked example 3: the same fact, three offices
Question: for which of the three offices is it true that the holder can be removed without a formal charge being brought? Step 1: the President can be removed only by impeachment for violation of the Constitution, which needs a charge. Step 2: the Vice-President can be removed by a resolution of the Rajya Sabha agreed by the Lok Sabha; the Constitution names no ground, so no charge of a particular kind is needed. Step 3: the Governor can be removed by the President at his pleasure. Answer: the Vice-President and the Governor. Keep the three removal methods in a row: impeachment, resolution, pleasure.
Key takeaways
Compare the three offices by the way the person is chosen, the method of removal, pardon and presiding role. Treat the shared facts (age 35, term five years) as safe and the differences as the likely test.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who among the following has the power to grant pardon?
- The Vice-President
- The Speaker
- The Governor for a death sentence
- The President for a death sentence
Show answer
Answer: D. The President can pardon a death sentence. The Governor cannot, and the Vice-President and the Speaker have no pardoning power.
-
2. Who presides over the Rajya Sabha?
- The President
- The Vice-President
- The Prime Minister
- The Speaker
Show answer
Answer: B. The Vice-President is the ex officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha.
-
3. The Governor of a State is removed by:
- impeachment by the State Legislature
- a resolution of the Rajya Sabha
- the President, at his pleasure
- the Chief Minister
Show answer
Answer: C. The Governor holds office during the pleasure of the President.
-
4. State Legislative Assemblies take part in the election of the:
- President only
- Vice-President only
- both President and Vice-President
- neither the President nor the Vice-President
Show answer
Answer: A. The President's electoral college includes the elected members of State Legislative Assemblies. The Vice-President's does not.
-
5. Which age is the minimum for all three offices: President, Vice-President and Governor?
- 25
- 30
- 35
- 40
Show answer
Answer: C. The minimum age is 35 for each.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.