- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Statement and assertion-reason questions on the President and Vice-President
Practise a method for 'which statements are correct' questions using the most common half-truths about the two offices.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Statement questions on the Presidency are built from small facts that are easy to twist. The commonest twists are to give the President the Vice-President's electoral college, to change the majority needed to remove someone, or to say the President can act alone. This lesson trains you to catch those twists.
Typical half-truths
- Wrong electorate: 'State legislators vote in the Vice-President's election' is false; only members of both Houses of Parliament do.
- Wrong majority: 'The President is impeached by a simple majority' is false; two-thirds of the total membership in each House.
- Wrong person: 'The Prime Minister administers the oath to the President' is false; the Chief Justice does.
- Wrong ground: 'The President can be impeached for any misconduct' is false; the only ground is violation of the Constitution.
- Too strong: 'The President is free to reject the advice of the Council of Ministers' is false; he may ask for reconsideration once and then must follow it.
- Wrong role: 'The Vice-President is the Chairman of the Lok Sabha' is false; of the Rajya Sabha.
Method
- Judge each statement alone as true, false or unsure.
- Remove options with a statement you know to be false.
- Treat an 'unsure' statement with suspicion if it uses absolute words such as 'always' or 'only'.
- Check the final option against every statement.
Worked example 1: three statements
Statements: (1) The Vice-President is elected by members of both Houses of Parliament. (2) The President is removed by a resolution of two-thirds of the total membership of either House. (3) The President must act on the advice of the Council of Ministers after one reconsideration. Options: (A) 1 and 2 only, (B) 1 and 3 only, (C) 2 and 3 only, (D) 1, 2 and 3. Step 1: statement 1 is true. Step 2: statement 2 is false in this form, because both Houses must pass it, one after the other: one House brings the charge and the other investigates. Step 3: statement 3 is true. Answer: (B).
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Assertion (A): The Vice-President does not take part in the debates of the Rajya Sabha as an ordinary member. Reason (R): He presides over it as Chairman and votes only to break a tie. A is true: he presides, he does not debate as a member. R is true and explains A. Answer: both true and R explains A. Now take Assertion: the President is elected directly by the people. Reason: the President is the head of the State. The assertion is false (the election is indirect), though the reason is true, so the answer is 'A false, R true'.
Worked example 3: counting inside a statement
Statement: 'An impeachment charge can be started by a notice signed by one-fourth of the members of a House, given 14 days before the resolution is moved, and the resolution needs a simple majority.' Check the parts one by one. One-fourth of the members: correct. Fourteen days: correct. Simple majority: wrong, because two-thirds of the total membership is needed. One wrong part makes the whole statement false. This is why a long statement is usually easier to reject than a short one: it has more places to be wrong. Read to the end before you decide, and look hardest at the last clause, where examiners often put the twist.
Ask who, what majority and what ground. Wrong electorate, wrong majority, wrong person, wrong ground: these four cover most half-truths.
Key takeaways
Hold the pairs: electorate (President: elected MPs and MLAs; Vice-President: all MPs), majority (President: two-thirds of total membership; Vice-President: effective majority of Rajya Sabha plus simple majority of Lok Sabha), role (President: head of the State; Vice-President: Chairman of the Rajya Sabha).
Check your understanding
-
1. Consider: (1) State legislators vote in the Vice-President's election. (2) The Vice-President is Chairman of the Rajya Sabha. Which is correct?
- Only 2
- Only 1
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: A. Only members of both Houses of Parliament vote for the Vice-President, so 1 is false. The Vice-President is the ex officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, so 2 is true.
-
2. Consider: (1) The President can be impeached for violation of the Constitution. (2) Impeachment needs a simple majority of members present. Which is correct?
- Only 2
- Only 1
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: B. The ground is correct, but the majority is two-thirds of the total membership, so statement 2 is false.
-
3. Assertion: The President is elected indirectly. Reason: The electoral college consists of elected members of Parliament and of State Legislative Assemblies. Choose the best answer.
- Both true but the reason does not explain it
- Assertion true, reason false
- Both true and the reason explains the assertion
- Assertion false, reason true
Show answer
Answer: C. An electoral college is exactly what makes the election indirect, so the reason explains the assertion.
-
4. Consider: (1) The President takes the oath before the Chief Justice of India. (2) The Prime Minister administers the oath. Which is correct?
- Only 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
- Both 1 and 2
- Only 1
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 60: the Chief Justice (or the senior-most judge available). The Prime Minister does not administer the oath.
-
5. Which statement about the President's relationship with the Council of Ministers is correct?
- He can ignore its advice at will
- He may ask for reconsideration once and must then follow it
- He must follow its first advice and cannot ask again
- He decides on his own what advice to ask for
Show answer
Answer: B. After the 44th Amendment the President may require reconsideration once; the advice given after reconsideration binds him.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.