- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Communalism revision map: definitions, stages and common traps
Revise the meaning, stages, causes and consequences of communalism on one map, and practise a step-by-step method for statement and classification questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on communalism are rarely about a single fact. They test whether you can tell communalism from religion, place a view in the right stage, and separate causes from consequences. Small words such as 'all', 'only' and 'always' turn true statements false. This lesson puts the topic on one revision map and then drills the traps.
Revision map: the core ideas
| Idea | What to remember | Common trap |
|---|---|---|
| Communalism | A political ideology that uses religious identity to claim shared worldly interests within a religious group, set against other groups | Equating it with being religious |
| Stage 1 | Followers of one religion share common political, economic, social and cultural interests | Thinking Stage 1 is harmless because it is not violent - it is the foundation of the later stages |
| Stage 2: liberal communalism | The interests of one religious community are dissimilar to and divergent from another's | Confusing 'liberal' with secular |
| Stage 3: extreme communalism | Interests are mutually incompatible and hostile; driven by fear and hatred; prone to violence | Thinking communalism means only violence |
| Source of the stages | The historian Bipan Chandra | Attributing them to a constitutional text or commission |
Causes and consequences
| Causes (why it arises) | Consequences (what it does) |
|---|---|
| Colonial divide and rule; separate electorates (1909) | Violence and loss of life and property |
| Competition for scarce jobs, education and political seats | Mistrust and separation of communities into different localities |
| Use of religion to mobilise votes | Voting on religious lines instead of on development |
| Rumours, stereotypes and one-sided accounts of history | Harm to trade, investment and daily life |
| Little everyday contact between communities | A threat to the unity and integrity of the nation; Partition in 1947 |
Method for statement questions
- Read each statement separately and underline the absolute words: all, only, always, never, completely.
- Ask whether the statement confuses faith (religion) with ideology (communalism).
- Check the stage: shared interests, divergent interests, or hostile interests?
- Check whether a cause is being passed off as a consequence, or the other way round.
- Only then look at the answer options.
Solved question 1
Consider: (1) Communalism is a political ideology based on religious identity. (2) Every religious person is communal. (3) Extreme communalism sees the interests of communities as hostile. Which are correct? Working: statement 1 is the standard definition - true. Statement 2 uses 'every' and confuses faith with ideology - false. Statement 3 is the description of the third stage - true. Answer: 1 and 3 only.
Solved question 2
Classify: 'Members of our religion need separate schools, banks and political parties because our needs differ from those of others, though we can share the country.' Working: it claims common interests within the group and says those interests differ from others', but does not call them hostile. That is liberal communalism (Stage 2). If it had said 'we cannot live with them', it would be Stage 3.
Faith is not communalism. Stages: common interests, then divergent interests (liberal), then hostile interests (extreme). Watch for 'all', 'only' and 'always'.
Key takeaways: learn the definition word for word, the three stages in order and the cause-consequence pairs. Most errors come from treating religion as communalism, mixing up the stages, or missing an absolute word.
Check your understanding
-
1. Consider the following statements:
1. Communalism treats a religious group as having common worldly interests.
2. Liberal communalism regards the interests of different communities as hostile.
3. Bipan Chandra described communalism as developing in stages.
Which of the statements given above are correct?- 1 and 2 only
- 2 and 3 only
- 1 and 3 only
- 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: C. Statements 1 and 3 are correct. Statement 2 is wrong: liberal communalism sees interests as divergent; it is extreme communalism that sees them as hostile.
-
2. 'Our community's needs in jobs and education differ from theirs, so we must organise separately, but we can live in one country.' This is an example of:
- Liberal communalism
- Extreme communalism
- Secularism
- Religious faith alone
Show answer
Answer: A. Divergent but not hostile interests, with acceptance of a common country, is the second stage - liberal communalism.
-
3. Which of these is a cause rather than a consequence of communalism?
- Separation of communities into different localities
- Loss of life and property
- Voting on religious lines
- Competition for scarce jobs and seats used to mobilise religious identity
Show answer
Answer: D. Competition for scarce opportunities, used to mobilise religious identity, helps produce communalism. Segregation, violence and religious voting are its results.
-
4. Which statement is a common trap in questions on communalism?
- Communalism is a political ideology
- Every religious person is communal
- Extreme communalism is based on fear and hatred
- Separate electorates were introduced in 1909
Show answer
Answer: B. 'Every religious person is communal' confuses faith with ideology and uses an absolute word. The other statements are correct.
-
5. Who described the three stages of communalism - common interests, liberal communalism and extreme communalism?
- Rajeev Bhargava
- Fazl Ali
- Bipan Chandra
- Lord Minto
Show answer
Answer: C. The historian Bipan Chandra set out these stages. Rajeev Bhargava wrote on principled distance; Fazl Ali chaired the States Reorganisation Commission.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.