- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Models of secularism, the Bommai case and remedies for communalism: revision and short answers
Compare Western and Indian secularism, revise what the S. R. Bommai judgment held, and match remedies to causes of communalism and regionalism in short-answer form.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The last revision block brings the three themes together. Examiners ask you to compare models of secularism, to state what the S. R. Bommai case decided, and to suggest remedies for communalism and negative regionalism. This lesson gives each in a table and shows how to write a crisp short answer.
Comparing models of secularism
| Feature | American model | French model (laïcité) | Indian model |
|---|---|---|---|
| Core idea | A 'wall of separation' between church and state | Strict exclusion of religion from state institutions | Equal respect for all religions; principled distance |
| Can the state reform religious practice? | Generally no | The state stays out of religious matters and keeps religion out of its own institutions | Yes, to protect equality and rights (for example Article 17, Article 25(2)) |
| Group rights | Focus on the individual | Focus on the individual citizen | Individual rights and community rights (Articles 26, 29, 30) |
The theorist Rajeev Bhargava coined principled distance for the Indian model. 'Distance' means the state does not identify with any religion; 'principled' means it engages with or keeps away from religion as values such as freedom and equality require. It is not 'equidistance': the state may treat different religions differently if that serves equality.
S. R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994): what it held
- Decided by a nine-judge bench of the Supreme Court.
- Held that secularism is part of the basic structure of the Constitution.
- Held that a proclamation of President's Rule under Article 356 is open to judicial review.
- Said that whether a state government has lost its majority should be tested on the floor of the House.
Remedies matched to causes
| Cause | Matching remedy |
|---|---|
| Stereotypes and one-sided history | Education in accurate history, critical thinking and constitutional values |
| Little contact between groups | Shared schools, workplaces, neighbourhoods, sports and festivals |
| Incitement and rumours | Impartial and prompt rule of law; responsible media |
| Use of religion or region to win votes | Enforcement of electoral law; civic awareness among voters |
| Uneven regional development | Balanced development, fair sharing of resources and cooperative federalism |
| Fear of losing identity | Protection of languages and cultures (Articles 29-30); accommodation of regional demands within the Union |
Solved short answer 1
Question: 'How is Indian secularism different from Western secularism?' (about 60 words). Model answer: Western secularism, especially the American model, builds a wall of separation between religion and state. Indian secularism instead shows equal respect for all religions and keeps a principled distance: the state may intervene to end discrimination, as in abolishing untouchability (Article 17), and protects community rights under Articles 26 and 30. The S. R. Bommai case (1994) made secularism part of the basic structure.
Solved short answer 2
Question: 'Suggest three remedies for communalism.' Working: link each remedy to a cause. (1) Education in constitutional values and accurate history, which counters stereotypes. (2) Regular contact between communities in schools, workplaces and neighbourhoods, which replaces prejudice with friendship. (3) Impartial rule of law against anyone who incites hatred, which removes the incentive to spread violence. Linking cause and remedy earns more credit than a bare list.
Write remedies as cause-remedy pairs. Bommai (1994): nine judges, secularism is basic structure, Article 356 open to judicial review, floor test.
Key takeaways: the Indian model is equal respect and principled distance, not a wall; it allows reform and protects group rights. Bommai made secularism part of the basic structure and placed limits on President's Rule. Remedies work best when matched to specific causes.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of the following was NOT held in the S. R. Bommai case (1994)?
- Secularism is part of the basic structure
- A proclamation under Article 356 is open to judicial review
- The word 'secular' must be added to the Preamble
- A government's majority should be tested on the floor of the House
Show answer
Answer: C. The word 'secular' had already been added to the Preamble by the 42nd Amendment in 1976. The other three points were held in Bommai.
-
2. 'Principled distance' means that the state:
- Keeps exactly the same distance from every religion in every matter
- Adopts one official religion
- Bans all religious activity in public
- Engages with or keeps away from religion as constitutional values of freedom and equality require
Show answer
Answer: D. Bhargava's principled distance lets the state engage or abstain depending on which better serves freedom and equality. It is not strict equidistance.
-
3. Which feature belongs to the Indian model of secularism but not to the strict American model?
- State intervention to reform discriminatory religious practices
- No official state religion
- Freedom of individual belief
- Equality of citizens before the law
Show answer
Answer: A. Both models have no state religion and protect individual belief and equality. Indian secularism additionally allows the state to intervene for reform, as in abolishing untouchability.
-
4. Which remedy best matches the cause 'little everyday contact between communities'?
- Separate schools for each community
- Shared schools, workplaces and festivals that bring communities together
- Stricter censorship of all religious books
- Separate electorates for each religion
Show answer
Answer: B. Lack of contact breeds stereotypes; shared spaces and activities replace them with familiarity and friendship.
-
5. The S. R. Bommai case was decided by a bench of:
- Five judges
- Seven judges
- Nine judges
- Thirteen judges
Show answer
Answer: C. S. R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994) was decided by a nine-judge bench of the Supreme Court.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.