- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Judiciary and constitutional bodies: who appoints, who decides
Separate the High Court, the Public Service Commission, the Election Commission of the state and the Lokayukta, and match each to its Article and appointing authority.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Beyond the executive and the legislature, the state has courts and independent bodies. Exam questions on them ask who appoints, who removes, and which Article applies. The table below packs most of it, and the traps follow.
The Articles to learn
| Article | Subject |
|---|---|
| 214 | High Court for each state |
| 216 | A High Court consists of a Chief Justice and other judges |
| 217 | Appointment and conditions of a High Court judge |
| 226 | High Court's power to issue writs |
| 227 | High Court's superintendence over courts in its area |
| 233 | Appointment of district judges (Governor, with High Court) |
| 235 | High Court's control over subordinate courts |
| 315 | Public Service Commission for the state |
| 316 | Appointment and term of members |
| 317 | Removal and suspension of a member |
| 243K | State Election Commission for local bodies |
Two writ powers
-
Article 32
- Supreme Court
- Only for fundamental rights
- A fundamental right itself
-
Article 226
- High Court
- For fundamental rights and other legal rights
- Wider in scope
The five writs
Both courts can issue the five writs: habeas corpus (produce the detained person), mandamus (a command to do a public duty), prohibition (stop a lower court acting beyond its power), certiorari (quash a lower court's order) and quo warranto (by what authority do you hold this post). Because the High Court's power under Article 226 covers 'any other purpose' as well, it is wider than the Supreme Court's under Article 32.
The Public Service Commission
The Karnataka Public Service Commission conducts the recruitment examinations for state services. Its Chairman and members are appointed by the Governor. A member holds office for six years or until the age of 62 (65 for the Union Commission), whichever is earlier. A member may be removed only by the President, after the Supreme Court has held an inquiry and reported that there is a ground for it. The point is that the Governor appoints but the President removes.
The State Election Commission
A State Election Commission, headed by a State Election Commissioner appointed by the Governor, conducts Panchayat and municipal elections under Article 243K. It is separate from the Election Commission of India, which runs elections to Parliament and the state legislature.
The Lokayukta
The Lokayukta of Karnataka is an ombudsman for complaints of corruption by public servants. It is created by a state law, not by an Article of the Constitution, so do not give it an Article number.
Worked example 1: appoints or removes
Question: who removes a member of the Karnataka Public Service Commission? Working: the President removes, and only after an inquiry by the Supreme Court. The Governor only appoints. So the answer is the President, not the Governor.
Worked example 2: which election?
Question: who conducts the election of a Zilla Panchayat? Working: it is a local body, so the State Election Commission acts under Article 243K. The Election Commission of India conducts elections to the Vidhan Sabha.
Worked example 3: one-letter trap
Question: Article 226 or Article 32 for a High Court writ? Working: a High Court writ is Article 226. Article 32 is the Supreme Court's. The extra clue is 'High Court', so choose 226.
Governor appoints PSC and district judges; President appoints High Court judges and removes PSC members. 226 High Court; 32 Supreme Court; 243K State Election Commission.
Key takeaways: Article 214 sets up the High Court; 226 gives it writ power wider than Article 32. District judges come under Article 233. PSC members are appointed by the Governor and removed by the President after a Supreme Court inquiry. Local body elections are conducted by the State Election Commission.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which Article empowers a High Court to issue writs?
- Article 32
- Article 214
- Article 233
- Article 226
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 226 gives the High Court its writ power. Article 32 is for the Supreme Court.
-
2. A member of the state Public Service Commission can be removed by the:
- Governor alone
- Chief Minister
- President, after a Supreme Court inquiry
- Speaker
Show answer
Answer: C. The Governor appoints but only the President can remove, following an inquiry by the Supreme Court.
-
3. Elections to Panchayats and municipalities are conducted by the:
- State Election Commission
- Election Commission of India
- Public Service Commission
- Lokayukta
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 243K provides the State Election Commission for local body polls.
-
4. The writ of mandamus is:
- An order to produce a detained person
- An order asking by what authority a post is held
- An order to quash a lower court's decision
- A command to a public authority to perform its duty
Show answer
Answer: D. Mandamus compels the performance of a public duty. The other options describe habeas corpus, quo warranto and certiorari.
-
5. Which body has no Article in the Constitution creating it?
- The High Court
- The Lokayukta of Karnataka
- The Public Service Commission
- The State Election Commission
Show answer
Answer: B. The Lokayukta is set up by a state law.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.