• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Making laws: bills, money bills and ordinances

Trace how an ordinary bill, a money bill and an ordinance are handled in Karnataka's legislature, with the time limits examiners like.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

How a law is made in the state is a favourite area for statement-type questions, because it is full of small numbers: days, weeks and months. This lesson sets the numbers beside each step so that you can recall them under pressure.

Ordinary bills

An ordinary bill can start in either House. After it passes one House it goes to the other. If the Vidhan Parishad rejects it, or amends it in a way the Assembly does not accept, or does not pass it within three months, the Assembly may pass it again and send it a second time. The Council can then delay it for at most one month. After that the bill is deemed passed in the form the Assembly wants. The Council can therefore delay an ordinary bill but cannot kill it.

Money bills

A money bill, which deals with taxes and spending, can start only in the Vidhan Sabha. Once the Assembly passes it, it goes to the Council, which must return it within 14 days with any recommendations. The Assembly may accept or reject them. If the Council does not return it within 14 days, the bill is deemed passed. The Speaker decides whether a bill is a money bill, and that decision is final.

Ordinary bill compared with money bill
StepOrdinary billMoney bill
Where it startsEither HouseVidhan Sabha only
Council's powerMay delay (three months first time, one month second time)Recommend only; 14 days
Who certifies the typeNo special certificateSpeaker of the Assembly
Final sayThe AssemblyThe Assembly

A bill becomes law

  1. Introduced and passed by the House of origin
  2. Passed by the other House (or the Assembly's will prevails)
  3. Sent to the Governor for assent
  4. Becomes an Act
The Governor's assent completes the process

The Governor's choices on a bill

Under Article 200 the Governor may give assent, withhold assent, return the bill (other than a money bill) for reconsideration, or reserve it for the President. If the Houses pass a returned bill again, with or without changes, the Governor cannot refuse assent a second time, unless the Governor reserves it for the President. A bill that is reserved goes to the President.

Ordinances

When the legislature is not in session and urgent action is needed, the Governor can promulgate an ordinance under Article 213. It has the force of law but is temporary. It must be placed before the Assembly when it meets, and it lapses six weeks after the Assembly reassembles, or earlier if the Assembly disapproves it. The Governor cannot issue an ordinance while the House is sitting.

Worked example 1: the Council's delay

Question: the Council receives an ordinary bill on 1 January and takes no action; can the Assembly pass it again? Working: if the Council has not passed it within three months, the Assembly may pass it again after those three months, that is, from about 1 April. The Council then has one month. The Council's delay can total at most about four months.

Worked example 2: money bill time

Question: the Assembly passes a money bill and sends it to the Council on 10 June. By what date must the Council return it? Working: 14 days from 10 June is 24 June. If it does not return the bill by then, the bill is deemed passed.

Worked example 3: ordinance lapse

Question: the Assembly meets on 1 July after an ordinance. When does the ordinance lapse if the Assembly does not disapprove it? Working: six weeks after reassembly, which is 42 days; 1 July plus 42 days is 12 August.

Ordinary bill: Council delays 3 months + 1 month. Money bill: Assembly only, Council 14 days, Speaker certifies. Ordinance: lapses 6 weeks after reassembly.

Key takeaways: the Council can delay an ordinary bill but cannot stop it, and can only recommend on a money bill within 14 days. The Governor may assent, withhold, return or reserve a bill. An ordinance is made when the legislature is not sitting and lapses six weeks after the Assembly reassembles.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Within how many days must the Legislative Council return a money bill?

    1. 7 days
    2. 14 days
    3. 30 days
    4. 3 months
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Council has 14 days to return a money bill with recommendations. After that the bill is deemed passed.

  2. 2. A money bill can be introduced in the:

    1. Vidhan Parishad only
    2. Either House
    3. Vidhan Sabha only
    4. Neither House
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Money bills start only in the Legislative Assembly.

  3. 3. An ordinance made under Article 213 lapses how long after the Assembly reassembles?

    1. Six weeks
    2. Six months
    3. One week
    4. Two years
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 213 provides that it ceases six weeks after reassembly unless disapproved earlier.

  4. 4. Who decides whether a bill is a money bill?

    1. The Governor
    2. The Chairman of the Council
    3. The Speaker of the Assembly
    4. The High Court
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Speaker's certificate is final.

  5. 5. Which action is NOT open to the Governor on an ordinary bill?

    1. Giving assent
    2. Amending the bill in the Governor's own words
    3. Withholding assent
    4. Reserving it for the President
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Governor can assent, withhold, return for reconsideration, or reserve the bill. The Governor does not rewrite it.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery