• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Introductions that loop back to the speaker

Solve 'pointing to a person' questions in which phrases such as 'my father's only son' turn out to be the speaker, and decide the final relation.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Many pointing questions are built around a loop: a phrase that starts at the speaker and ends at the speaker. 'My father's only son' is the speaker if the speaker is a man. 'My mother's only daughter' is the speaker if the speaker is a woman. Recognising these loops removes two or three links at once, and it is the quickest way into the harder questions.

Loops to memorise

Phrases that can return to the speaker
PhraseIs the speaker if...Is someone else if...
My father's only sonthe speaker is a manthe speaker is a woman (then it is her brother)
My mother's only daughterthe speaker is a womanthe speaker is a man (then it is his sister)
My son's fatherthe speaker is a manthe speaker is a woman (then it is her husband)
My daughter's motherthe speaker is a womanthe speaker is a man (then it is his wife)

The loop works because the speaker is one of the children of the speaker's own parents. If the speaker's gender is given, each row is decided at once. If it is not given, the phrase may be the speaker or a sibling, and a well-set question will state the gender or use a phrase such as 'only child'. Remember that 'only' means that no other person has the same description, so the person described must be the speaker whenever the speaker fits it.

Worked examples

Example 1. Pointing to a man, Kavita (a woman) says, 'He is the son of my mother's only daughter.' Working: Kavita's mother's only daughter is Kavita herself. The man is Kavita's son. Answer: son.

Example 2. Pointing to a girl, Raj (a man) says, 'She is the daughter of my mother's only daughter.' Working: Raj's mother's only daughter is Raj's sister, since Raj is a man. The girl is his sister's daughter, so she is Raj's niece.

Example 3. Pointing to a woman, Anil (a man) says, 'She is the mother of the only son of my father.' Working: Anil's father's only son is Anil himself. The woman is Anil's mother.

Example 4. Pointing to a man, Leela (a woman) says, 'His father is the only son of my father's father.' Working: Leela's father's father's only son is Leela's father. So the man's father is Leela's father, which makes the man Leela's brother.

Example 5. Pointing to a girl, Sumit (a man) says, 'She is the sister of the only son of my father.' Working: Sumit's father's only son is Sumit himself. The girl is the sister of Sumit, so she is Sumit's sister. Notice that the question looks long, but the loop reduces it to one link.

Look for a loop first: if a phrase returns to the speaker, replace it by 'me' and shorten the chain.

— Rule to remember

Method

  • Find the speaker and mark the gender.
  • Resolve the innermost phrase and replace it with a person, noticing loops.
  • Work outwards to the final link.
  • State the relation from the speaker's point of view.

Traps

  • Assuming the speaker's gender when it has not been given; if the loop depends on it, the question normally supplies it.
  • Forgetting the word 'only', which lets you collapse to a single person.
  • Answering from the pointed-at person's point of view instead of the speaker's.

Key takeaways

  • Phrases such as 'my father's only son' and 'my mother's only daughter' often mean the speaker or a sibling.
  • Collapse loops first.
  • The answer is always from the speaker's side.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Pointing to a man, Kavita (a woman) says, 'He is the son of my mother's only daughter.' The man is Kavita's

    1. Brother
    2. Nephew
    3. Son
    4. Cousin
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Kavita's mother's only daughter is Kavita herself, so the man is her son.

  2. 2. Pointing to a woman, Rohan (a man) says, 'She is the wife of my father's only son.' The woman is Rohan's

    1. Sister-in-law
    2. Wife
    3. Sister
    4. Mother
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Rohan's father's only son is Rohan, and the woman is his wife.

  3. 3. Pointing to a girl, Raj (a man) says, 'She is the daughter of my mother's only daughter.' The girl is Raj's

    1. Niece
    2. Cousin
    3. Daughter
    4. Sister
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Raj's mother's only daughter is his sister, so her daughter is his niece.

  4. 4. Pointing to a man, Meena (a woman) says, 'He is the brother of my mother's only daughter.' The man is Meena's

    1. Cousin
    2. Uncle
    3. Brother
    4. Nephew
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Meena's mother's only daughter is Meena herself, so the man is Meena's brother.

  5. 5. Pointing to a man, Leela (a woman) says, 'His father is the only son of my father's father.' The man is Leela's

    1. Cousin
    2. Uncle
    3. Nephew
    4. Brother
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The only son of Leela's father's father is Leela's father. The man's father is Leela's father, so he is her brother.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery