- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Statement-chain problems: from clues to a relation
Solve questions that give three or four short statements and ask how the first person is related to the last, using a quick arrow notation.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A frequent exam format gives a string of short statements, such as 'A is the mother of B. B is the sister of C. C is the father of D', and asks how A is related to D. Each statement is simple, but the answer needs all of them. A neat arrow notation turns the problem into a few seconds of careful reading.
A quick notation
- Write each person as a letter and mark gender when it is known: A(F) for a woman, C(M) for a man.
- Write 'parent of' as an arrow pointing down to the child: A -> B.
- Write siblings side by side with an equals-style bar: B | C.
- Write husband and wife as H = W.
- Once the chart is drawn, read the relation from the first person to the last, one arrow at a time.
A standard convention applies in these puzzles: when a wife is said to be the mother of a child, her husband is taken to be the child's father, and the children of a couple are the children of both.
Worked examples
Example 1. A is the mother of B. B is the sister of C. C is the father of D. How is A related to D? Working: A -> B and B | C, so A is also C's mother. C -> D, so A is the mother of D's father. A is D's paternal grandmother.
Example 2. M is the father of N. N is the sister of O. O is the husband of P. How is M related to P? Working: M -> N and N | O, so M is also O's father. O = P, so P is O's wife, and M is the father of P's husband. M is P's father-in-law.
Example 3. X is the son of Y. Y is the daughter of Z. Z is the wife of W. How is W related to X? Working: Z is Y's mother and W is Z's husband, so W is Y's father. Y is the mother of X (a daughter whose son is X). W is the father of X's mother, so W is X's maternal grandfather.
Example 4. A is the sister of B. B is the father of C. C is the mother of D. How is A related to D? Working: A | B, and B is a man (a father), so A is B's sister. B -> C, so A is C's paternal aunt. C -> D, so A is the sister of D's mother's father. A is D's grand-aunt (the sister of the maternal grandfather).
Draw each statement as one arrow, join siblings under the same parent, and read the chain from the first person to the last.
Speed methods
- Read the final question first so that you know which two people matter.
- Collapse siblings: if B and C are brother and sister, a parent of B is a parent of C.
- Count generations. A chain with two arrows down is a grandparent relation; one up and one down is a sibling or cousin relation.
- Decide the side (paternal or maternal) at the first link that passes through a parent.
Traps
- Reading the question in the wrong direction. A is the mother of D asks for A to D; D to A is the reverse.
- Missing a gender clue. 'B is a father' makes B male, so A, his sister, is an aunt rather than an uncle.
- Forgetting to collapse siblings and building a chain that is too long.
Key takeaways
- An arrow chart makes every statement-chain puzzle mechanical.
- Siblings share parents; use that to shorten a chain.
- Check gender and direction before choosing an option.
Check your understanding
-
1. P is the father of Q. Q is the sister of R. R is the husband of S. How is P related to S?
- Brother-in-law
- Father-in-law
- Uncle
- Grandfather
Show answer
Answer: B. P is also R's father. R's wife S is P's daughter-in-law, and P is S's father-in-law.
-
2. A is the mother of B. B is the brother of C. C is the wife of D. How is A related to D?
- Sister-in-law
- Mother
- Mother-in-law
- Aunt
Show answer
Answer: C. A is also C's mother. C is D's wife, so A is D's mother-in-law.
-
3. X is the son of Y. Y is the sister of Z. Z is the father of W. How is X related to W?
- Cousin
- Brother
- Nephew
- Uncle
Show answer
Answer: A. X is the child of Z's sister, and W is the child of Z. They are cousins.
-
4. G is the grandfather of H. H is the sister of J. J is the father of K. How is G related to K?
- Maternal grandfather
- Great-grandfather
- Father
- Paternal grandfather
Show answer
Answer: D. G is the father of H's parent and also J's father, so G is the father of K's father: the paternal grandfather.
-
5. V and U are husband and wife, and T is their daughter. V is the brother of W. How is W related to T?
- Maternal uncle
- Paternal uncle
- Father
- Cousin
Show answer
Answer: B. W is the brother of T's father V, so W is T's paternal uncle.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.