- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Comparison puzzles: ages, heights and boxes
Order people from comparison clues, solve a simple two-person age puzzle, and apply the classic wrong-label boxes puzzle step by step.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Not every puzzle is a grid. Some give comparisons, some give a small equation in words, and some are a classic reasoning puzzle you can solve by thinking through what must be true. Each of these is shown below.
Puzzles without a grid
- Comparisons Chain them into one order.
- An equation in words Turn the words into a small equation.
- A classic reasoning puzzle Think through what must be true; a known-wrong label rules out a possibility.
Worked examples
Example 1 (comparisons). Amit is older than Bina. Bina is older than Chetan. Dev is younger than Chetan but older than Esha. Who is the youngest, and who is the oldest? Amit > Bina > Chetan > Dev > Esha. The oldest is Amit and the youngest is Esha.
Example 2 (age). A is twice as old as B. The sum of their ages is 36. Find each age. Let B be x. Then A is 2x, and x + 2x = 36, so 3x = 36 and x = 12. B is 12 and A is 24.
Example 3 (wrong labels). There are three boxes labelled Apples, Oranges and Mixed. Every label is wrong. You may take one fruit out of one box without looking. Which box should you pick from, so as to label all three correctly? Pick from the box labelled Mixed. Its label is wrong, so it holds only apples or only oranges. Suppose you take out an apple: that box is Apples. The box labelled Oranges cannot be oranges (its label is wrong) and cannot be apples (taken), so it is Mixed. The box labelled Apples cannot be apples, so it is Oranges. One draw settles everything.
Three wrong labels, one draw
- Draw from 'Mixed' Its label is wrong, so it holds only one kind of fruit.
- An apple: it is Apples Suppose the fruit drawn is an apple.
- 'Oranges' box is Mixed Not oranges (wrong label), not apples (taken).
- 'Apples' box is Oranges Its label cannot be right.
Example 4 (counting). A farmer has hens and cows. There are 20 heads and 56 legs in all. How many hens are there? If all 20 were hens there would be 40 legs. The extra 16 legs come from cows, who have 2 legs more than a hen each, so there are 8 cows. Then hens = 20 - 8 = 12. Check: 12 x 2 + 8 x 4 = 24 + 32 = 56.
When labels or statements are known to be wrong, use that fact: a wrong label rules out one possibility at once.
Key takeaways
- Chain comparisons into one order.
- Turn word problems into small equations.
- Use the fact that a known-wrong statement eliminates a possibility.
Check your understanding
-
1. Meena is heavier than Tina. Tina is heavier than Rita. Sona is lighter than Rita. Who is the lightest?
- Rita
- Tina
- Meena
- Sona
Show answer
Answer: D. Chaining the comparisons: Meena > Tina > Rita > Sona, so Sona is the lightest.
-
2. A is 4 times as old as B. The sum of their ages is 45 years. How old is A?
- 36 years
- 9 years
- 27 years
- 40 years
Show answer
Answer: A. Let B be x; then A is 4x and x + 4x = 45, so 5x = 45 and x = 9. A is 4 x 9 = 36 years.
-
3. A farmer has hens and cows with 25 heads and 70 legs in all. How many hens are there?
- 15
- 10
- 12
- 20
Show answer
Answer: A. If all 25 were hens there would be 50 legs. The extra 20 legs come from cows, 2 extra each, so 10 cows and 25 - 10 = 15 hens. Check: 15 x 2 + 10 x 4 = 30 + 40 = 70.
-
4. Three boxes are labelled Apples, Oranges and Mixed, and every label is wrong. You may take one fruit from one box without looking. Which box should you pick from to label all three correctly?
- The box labelled Apples
- The box labelled Mixed
- The box labelled Oranges
- Any box will do
Show answer
Answer: B. The Mixed label is wrong, so that box holds only one kind of fruit, and one fruit shows which. A box labelled Apples or Oranges could be mixed, so one fruit from it might not settle anything.
-
5. In the same box puzzle, you take an apple from the box labelled Mixed. What does the box labelled Apples contain?
- Only apples
- A mixture
- Only oranges
- It cannot be said
Show answer
Answer: C. The Mixed-labelled box holds only apples. The box labelled Oranges cannot hold oranges (wrong label) or only apples (taken), so it is the mixed box. The box labelled Apples is left with oranges.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.