- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Mixed puzzles and a method for any puzzle
Combine grids, ordering and elimination in a mixed four-person puzzle, and review a general method that works for any puzzle.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Every puzzle gives clues that can be turned into ticks, crosses, positions or equations. The skill is to organise them, not to guess. This final lesson gives a general method and a mixed puzzle.
General method
A method for any puzzle
- Read and list The people and the attributes.
- Draw a grid or line A grid or a numbered line.
- Direct clues is, lives in, takes
- Negative clues is not, does not
- Comparisons and positions
- Re-read every clue Against your answer.
- Read the whole puzzle once and list the people and the attributes.
- Draw a grid or a numbered line.
- Use direct clues first (is, lives in, takes).
- Use negative clues next (is not, does not).
- Use comparisons and positions last.
- Re-read every clue against your answer.
Worked example
Four students A, B, C, D each take a different subject among Maths, Physics, Chemistry and Biology. A takes neither Maths, Biology nor Physics. B does not take Physics. C takes Maths. The student who takes Biology is not D. Who takes what?
Step 1. A takes neither Maths, Biology nor Physics, so A takes Chemistry. Step 2. C takes Maths. Step 3. B and D share Physics and Biology. B does not take Physics, so B takes Biology and D takes Physics. Step 4. Check the clue that the Biology student is not D: Biology is B's, so it holds.
| Student | Subject |
|---|---|
| A | Chemistry |
| B | Biology |
| C | Maths |
| D | Physics |
A second puzzle. Three boxes hold different objects: a pen, a ball and a cup. The box with the pen is to the left of the box with the ball. The cup is not in the middle. Where is each? There are six possible orders. Pen left of ball rules out those where the ball comes before the pen. The cup is not in the middle, so it is at an end. Options: cup, pen, ball (cup is left; pen left of ball holds; the cup is not in the middle: valid); pen, ball, cup (valid); pen, cup, ball (cup is in the middle: invalid). So there are two possible arrangements: cup-pen-ball or pen-ball-cup. The clues are not enough to give one answer.
Work from certain facts to uncertain ones, and say so honestly when the clues leave more than one answer.
Key takeaways
- Organise first, deduce second.
- Direct clues before negative clues, then comparisons.
- Re-check every clue against the final answer.
Check your understanding
-
1. Four students A, B, C and D each take a different subject: Hindi, English, Maths and Science. B takes Maths. A takes neither Hindi nor Science. C does not take Hindi. Who takes Hindi?
- D
- A
- B
- C
Show answer
Answer: A. B has Maths. A has neither Hindi nor Science, so A has English. C has neither Hindi, Maths nor English, so C has Science. Hindi is left for D.
-
2. Four students A, B, C and D each take a different subject: Hindi, English, Maths and Science. B takes Maths. A takes neither Hindi nor Science. C does not take Hindi. Which subject does C take?
- English
- Hindi
- Science
- Maths
Show answer
Answer: C. Maths is B's and English is A's. C does not take Hindi, so C takes Science.
-
3. X, Y and Z live on floors 1, 2 and 3, one on each. Z does not live on floor 3. X lives below Z. Who lives on floor 3?
- X
- Y
- Z
- It cannot be said
Show answer
Answer: B. Z is on floor 1 or 2. X is below Z, so Z cannot be on floor 1; Z is on 2 and X on 1. Y is on floor 3.
-
4. According to the general method, which clues should you use first?
- Negative clues such as 'B does not take Physics'
- Comparisons and positions
- Whichever clue is longest
- Direct clues such as 'C takes Maths'
Show answer
Answer: D. Direct clues first, negative clues next, comparisons and positions last; then re-check every clue against the answer.
-
5. A cup, a ball and a pen are put in a row of three boxes. The cup is somewhere to the left of the pen. The ball is not at the right end. How many arrangements fit these clues?
- 1
- 3
- 2
- 6
Show answer
Answer: C. With the cup left of the pen, the orders are cup-pen-ball, cup-ball-pen and ball-cup-pen. The first puts the ball at the right end, so it fails. Two arrangements remain, so the clues do not give a single answer.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.