- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Demerits of Mendeleev's table and the modern periodic law
List the problems in Mendeleev's table (cobalt and nickel, isotopes, uneven mass gaps, hydrogen), and see how Moseley's work on atomic number led to the modern periodic law.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State four demerits of Mendeleev's periodic table.
- Explain why atomic number is more fundamental than atomic mass.
- State the modern periodic law and show how it removes most of the problems.
Mendeleev's table was a huge success, but it was built when nothing was known about the inside of an atom. As atomic structure was discovered, some puzzles in the table could finally be explained.
Demerits of Mendeleev's periodic table
- Cobalt and nickel: both have the same whole-number atomic mass (59), so it was not clear which should come first.
- Isotopes: isotopes were discovered long after Mendeleev's table. Isotopes of an element have the same chemical properties but different atomic masses (for example chlorine-35 and chlorine-37). Arranged by mass, they would need different places, which makes no sense chemically.
- Uneven rise in atomic mass: the increase in atomic mass from one element to the next is not uniform, so it was impossible to predict how many elements could still be discovered between two heavy elements.
- Position of hydrogen: hydrogen resembles both the alkali metals (group I) and the halogens (group VII), so its correct position could not be decided.
Why hydrogen's place is a puzzle
-
Like alkali metals (group I)
- Has one valence electron
- Forms compounds with similar formulae: HCl and NaCl, H₂O and Na₂O, H₂S and Na₂S
-
Like halogens (group VII)
- Exists as a diatomic molecule H₂, like F₂ and Cl₂
- Combines with metals: NaH, like NaCl
- Combines with nonmetals: CH₄, like CCl₄
Moseley and atomic number
In Mendeleev's table the 'atomic number' was only the serial number of an element. In 1913 the English scientist Henry Moseley, using experiments with an X-ray tube, showed that the atomic number (Z) of an element equals the positive charge on its nucleus, that is, the number of protons. Since every atom of an element has the same number of protons, while isotopes differ in mass, atomic number is a more fundamental property than atomic mass.
Modern periodic law: the properties of elements are a periodic function of their atomic numbers.
How the modern law solves the problems
| Problem in Mendeleev's table | How atomic number settles it |
|---|---|
| Order of Co and Ni | Co has Z = 27 and Ni has Z = 28, so cobalt comes first. |
| Place of isotopes | Isotopes such as Cl-35 and Cl-37 both have Z = 17, so they share one place. |
| Unknown number of missing elements | Z rises by exactly 1 from one element to the next, so gaps can be counted. |
| Position of hydrogen | Still not fully settled; the modern table also leaves this ambiguous. |
Worked example 1: can an element fit between them?
Chromium has Z = 24 and manganese has Z = 25. Could there be an undiscovered element with atomic mass 53 or 54 placed between them? No. Atomic numbers are whole numbers that increase by one; there is no whole number between 24 and 25, so no element can lie between chromium and manganese, whatever its mass.
Worked example 2: counting the gap
Two elements have atomic numbers 30 and 34. The elements between them have Z = 31, 32 and 33, so exactly 3 elements fit between them. Using atomic masses alone, Mendeleev's table could not give such a certain answer.
Key takeaways: Mendeleev's table could not decide the order of Co and Ni, the place of isotopes, the number of missing elements or the position of hydrogen. Moseley showed that atomic number is the number of protons, a more basic property. The modern periodic law, based on atomic number, removes most of these problems, though hydrogen's place stays debatable.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why was the placing of isotopes a problem in Mendeleev's table?
- They have different chemical properties
- They have the same chemical properties but different atomic masses
- They have different atomic numbers
- They are all radioactive
Show answer
Answer: B. Isotopes behave the same chemically but differ in mass. A table ordered by atomic mass would need to put them in different places, which conflicts with their identical properties.
-
2. Who showed that the atomic number of an element equals the number of protons in its nucleus?
- Mendeleev
- Newlands
- Dobereiner
- Moseley
Show answer
Answer: D. In 1913 Henry Moseley showed, using X-ray experiments, that atomic number equals the positive charge on the nucleus, that is, the number of protons.
-
3. The modern periodic law is based on:
- Atomic number
- Atomic mass
- Number of neutrons
- Density
Show answer
Answer: A. The modern periodic law states that the properties of elements are a periodic function of their atomic numbers.
-
4. Which demerit of Mendeleev's table is NOT removed even in the modern periodic table?
- Order of cobalt and nickel
- Position of isotopes
- Position of hydrogen
- Predicting the number of missing elements
Show answer
Answer: C. Atomic number settles the order of Co and Ni, gives isotopes one place and lets us count gaps. Hydrogen still resembles both alkali metals and halogens, so its position remains ambiguous.
-
5. How many elements lie between the elements with atomic numbers 11 and 15?
- 4
- 2
- 5
- 3
Show answer
Answer: D. The elements between them have Z = 12, 13 and 14, so there are 3 of them.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.