- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Early attempts: Dobereiner's triads and Newlands' octaves
See why elements needed classifying, test whether three elements form a Dobereiner triad, apply Newlands' law of octaves, and list the limitations of both ideas.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why scientists looked for patterns among the elements.
- Check whether a group of three elements is a Dobereiner triad by calculating a mean.
- State Newlands' law of octaves and its limitations.
Around the year 1800 only about 30 elements were known. Today 118 elements are known. As more elements were discovered and more was learnt about their properties, remembering each one separately became impossible. Scientists began searching for patterns, so that elements with similar properties could be studied together. The first, simplest grouping was into metals and nonmetals; later a third class, the metalloids, was recognised.
Dobereiner's triads (1817)
The German scientist Dobereiner suggested that the properties of elements are related to their atomic masses. He made groups of three elements with similar chemical properties and called each group a triad. When the three are arranged in increasing order of atomic mass, the atomic mass of the middle element is approximately equal to the mean of the atomic masses of the other two.
Dobereiner's triad: atomic mass of the middle element ≈ (atomic mass of the first + atomic mass of the third) / 2.
Worked example 1: lithium, sodium and potassium
Atomic masses: Li = 6.9, Na = 23.0, K = 39.1. Mean of the first and third = (6.9 + 39.1) / 2 = 46.0 / 2 = 23.0. This equals the atomic mass of sodium, so Li, Na, K form a triad. All three are soft, reactive metals that react with water.
Worked example 2: is it a triad?
Chlorine, bromine, iodine: Cl = 35.5, Br = 79.9, I = 126.9. Mean = (35.5 + 126.9) / 2 = 162.4 / 2 = 81.2, close to 79.9, so this is a triad. Magnesium, calcium, strontium: Mg = 24.3, Ca = 40.1, Sr = 87.6. Mean = (24.3 + 87.6) / 2 = 111.9 / 2 ≈ 56.0, which is far from 40.1, so these three do not form a triad, even though their properties are similar.
Limitation: all the known elements could not be fitted into triads. Only a few such groups were found.
Newlands' law of octaves (1866)
The English scientist John Newlands arranged the elements known in his time in increasing order of atomic mass, starting with hydrogen and ending with thorium. He noticed that every eighth element had properties similar to the first, just as in music the eighth note repeats the first at a higher pitch. In Indian music the seven notes Sa, Re, Ga, Ma, Pa, Dha, Ni form a saptak, and the next Sa repeats the first at double the frequency; western music uses Do, Re, Mi, Fa, So, La, Ti. Newlands called his pattern the law of octaves.
For example, counting from lithium, sodium is the eighth element and the two are alike. Magnesium resembles beryllium in the same way, and chlorine resembles fluorine.
Limitations of Newlands' octaves
-
Worked only up to calcium
- Heavier elements did not follow the pattern
-
Two elements in one box
- He fitted all known elements into 56 boxes (7 × 8)
- Pairs such as Co and Ni, Ce and La shared a place
-
Unlike elements grouped together
- Metals Co and Ni were placed with halogens
- Iron, similar to Co and Ni, was placed with nonmetals O and S
-
No room for new elements
- Elements discovered later did not fit the law
Key takeaways: classification makes a large number of elements easier to study. Dobereiner grouped similar elements into triads in which the middle atomic mass is about the mean of the other two. Newlands found that every eighth element resembles the first. Both ideas worked for only some elements, but they showed that properties are linked to atomic mass.
Check your understanding
-
1. In a Dobereiner triad, the atomic mass of the middle element is approximately:
- The sum of the other two
- The mean of the other two
- Double the first
- Half of the third
Show answer
Answer: B. Dobereiner arranged three similar elements in order of atomic mass and found that the middle one's atomic mass is about the average (mean) of the first and third.
-
2. Calcium (40.1), strontium (87.6) and barium (137.3) form a triad. What is the mean of the atomic masses of calcium and barium?
- 97.2
- 88.7
- 177.4
- 47.5
Show answer
Answer: B. Mean = (40.1 + 137.3) / 2 = 177.4 / 2 = 88.7, close to strontium's 87.6, so these three form a triad.
-
3. Which scientist compared the repetition of properties among elements to notes in music?
- Dobereiner
- Mendeleev
- Moseley
- Newlands
Show answer
Answer: D. Newlands noticed that every eighth element resembles the first and compared it to the octave in music, calling it the law of octaves.
-
4. According to the law of octaves, which element should resemble lithium?
- Sodium, the eighth element from lithium
- Beryllium, the next element
- Carbon
- Fluorine
Show answer
Answer: A. Counting lithium as the first, sodium is the eighth element in Newlands' arrangement, and the two have similar properties.
-
5. Which is a limitation of Newlands' law of octaves?
- It used atomic numbers instead of atomic masses
- It left gaps for undiscovered elements
- It held good only up to calcium
- It had separate groups for noble gases
Show answer
Answer: C. The pattern held only for the lighter elements, up to calcium. Newlands left no gaps for new elements and knew nothing of atomic numbers or noble gases.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.