- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Completing by rule: equal counts in rows and columns
Complete a grid figure by using a counting rule, such as each row and column containing the same number of filled cells.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Some completion questions give a rule rather than a symmetry: every row and every column contains the same number of shaded cells. The rule lets you work out the missing cells like a small puzzle.
Method
- Count the filled cells in each row and each column of the given part.
- Compare with the required number.
- Fill a cell only where both its row and its column still need more cells.
- Check every row and column at the end.
Worked examples
Example 1. Every row and every column of a 3 by 3 grid has exactly two filled cells. Row 1 is "# # .", row 2 is "# . ?". Row 2 needs two, so the ? is filled. Column 1 is now full with two cells, so row 3 column 1 is empty. Column 2 has one and needs another, so row 3 column 2 is filled. Column 3 has one (row 2) and needs another, so row 3 column 3 is filled. Row 3 is ". # #", which has two cells, as required.
Example 2. A 4 by 4 grid has exactly one filled cell in every row and column. Rows 1 to 3 are "# . . .", ". . # ." and ". # . .". The columns used so far are 1, 3 and 2, so row 4 must use column 4: ". . . #".
Example 3. In a 3 by 3 grid with exactly two filled cells in each row, the total is 3 times 2 = 6 filled cells.
Fill a cell only where its row and its column both still need more. Check all rows and columns at the end.
Key takeaways
- Count each row and column against the rule.
- Fill only where both row and column need more.
- Check whether the completion is unique.
Check your understanding
-
1. A 3 by 3 grid has exactly one filled cell in every row and column. Row 1 is . # . and row 2 is # . . . What is row 3?
- . . #
- # . .
- . # .
- # # .
Show answer
Answer: A. Row 1 uses column 2 and row 2 uses column 1. Only column 3 is left, so row 3 is . . #.
-
2. A 4 by 4 grid has exactly one filled cell in every row and column. Rows 1 to 3 are # . . . , . . # . and . # . . . What is row 4?
- . . . #
- # . . .
- . # . .
- . . # .
Show answer
Answer: A. Columns 1, 3 and 2 are used by rows 1 to 3. Only column 4 is left, so row 4 is . . . #.
-
3. A 3 by 3 grid has exactly two filled cells in every row and column. Row 1 is # . # and row 2 is # # . . What is row 3?
- # # .
- # . #
- . # #
- # # #
Show answer
Answer: C. Column 1 already has two (rows 1 and 2), so row 3, column 1 is empty. Columns 2 and 3 each have one and need another, so both are filled: . # #. Row 3 then has two cells, as required.
-
4. How many filled cells are there in a 3 by 3 grid with exactly two filled cells in each row?
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
Show answer
Answer: D. 3 rows x 2 cells = 6 filled cells.
-
5. A 3 by 3 grid has exactly one filled cell in each row and column. Only row 1 is given: . # . . Is the rest of the grid fixed?
- Yes, there is only one completion
- No, there are six completions
- No completion exists
- No, there are two completions
Show answer
Answer: D. Column 2 is used. Row 2 can take column 1 or column 3, and row 3 then takes whichever is left. That gives two completions, so the grid is not fixed.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.