• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Lawmaking in the Vidhan Sabha: bills, ordinances and the Speaker

Trace what happens to a bill in a state with one House, the Governor's four choices, and the traps on ordinances and the Speaker.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Odisha has one House, so the lawmaking path is shorter than in Parliament. Examiners use this to set traps such as 'the Council rejects the bill' or 'the Speaker assents'. This lesson fixes the path and the roles.

What a single House changes

In a state with a Legislative Council the bill would have to pass two Houses. Odisha has no Council, so there is no second House to pass it and no question of the Council delaying it. If an option says 'Legislative Council of Odisha', it is wrong. The legislature of Odisha is the Governor plus the Vidhan Sabha.

The Governor's four choices on a bill

What the Governor can do (Article 200)
ChoiceMeaning
Give assentThe bill becomes an Act
Withhold assentThe bill does not become law
Return itThe Governor sends a bill other than a money bill back for reconsideration; if the House passes it again, the Governor must assent
Reserve it for the PresidentThe President decides whether to assent (Articles 200 and 201)

Memory hook: A-W-R-R - assent, withhold, return, reserve.

Money bills

A money bill (Article 199) deals with taxation, borrowing and money from the state's funds. It can be introduced only in the Vidhan Sabha and only on the Governor's recommendation. The Speaker's decision on whether a bill is a money bill is final. The annual budget is laid before the House as the 'annual financial statement' (Article 202).

Ordinances

Life of an ordinance

  1. House not in session Governor sees a need for urgent law
  2. Ordinance issued It has the force of an Act (Article 213)
  3. House reassembles The ordinance is placed before it
  4. Ends Latest six weeks after the House reassembles, or earlier if disapproved
Article 213 in four steps

The Speaker

  • Elected by the members from among themselves (Article 178).
  • Presides over sittings, and decides on money bills and on disqualification under the anti-defection law (Tenth Schedule).
  • Resigns by writing to the Deputy Speaker (Article 179).
  • Does not have an ordinary vote, but may cast a deciding vote in a tie.

Worked example 1: the lifetime of an ordinance

Question: the Vidhan Sabha reassembles on 10 July. Latest date for an ordinance to cease if it is not passed? Working: six weeks is 42 days. From 10 July, 21 days takes us to 31 July and another 21 days to 21 August.

Worked example 2: who is wrong?

Question: 'After the Odisha Vidhan Sabha passes a bill, the Legislative Council considers it.' Working: Odisha has no Legislative Council. The statement is wrong; the bill goes to the Governor.

Worked example 3: the next session

Question: a session ends on 20 February. By when must the House meet again? Working: the gap may not be more than six months. The House must meet by 20 August.

Worked example 4: spot the wrong option

Question: which is correct for Odisha - (a) the Council rejects the bill, (b) the Speaker gives assent, (c) the Governor gives assent, (d) the Chief Minister gives assent? Working: there is no Council, the Speaker presides but does not assent, and the Chief Minister leads the government but does not assent. Only the Governor gives assent to a bill, so the answer is (c). Also remember the difference between withholding assent and reserving a bill: withholding ends the bill, while reserving sends it to the President for a decision.

A-W-R-R: assent, withhold, return, reserve. Money bill: only in the Vidhan Sabha, on the Governor's recommendation. Ordinance: six weeks after reassembly.

Key takeaways: Odisha has no Council. The Governor can assent, withhold, return or reserve. A money bill starts only in the Vidhan Sabha. An ordinance lapses within six weeks of the House meeting. The Speaker presides and decides on money bills and defection.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A bill that has been passed by the Odisha Vidhan Sabha is sent to the:

    1. Governor
    2. Legislative Council
    3. Speaker for assent
    4. Chief Secretary
    Show answer

    Answer: A. With one House, the bill goes straight to the Governor.

  2. 2. Which of these is NOT a choice open to the Governor on a bill?

    1. Withhold assent
    2. Amend the bill himself or herself
    3. Reserve it for the President
    4. Give assent
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Governor cannot rewrite the bill. The choices are assent, withhold, return (for a non-money bill) or reserve.

  3. 3. An ordinance ceases to operate at the latest:

    1. One year after it is issued
    2. One week after it is issued
    3. When the Governor retires
    4. Six weeks after the House reassembles
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 213 gives six weeks from reassembly.

  4. 4. A money bill can be introduced in Odisha:

    1. Only in the Vidhan Sabha, on the Governor's recommendation
    2. Only in the Legislative Council
    3. By any private person
    4. Only by the Speaker
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 199 and 207: it begins in the assembly with the Governor's recommendation.

  5. 5. A member of the Vidhan Sabha who wishes to give up the post of Speaker resigns to the:

    1. Governor
    2. Chief Minister
    3. Deputy Speaker
    4. Chief Justice
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 179 says the Speaker resigns by writing to the Deputy Speaker.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery