- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The state executive: who appoints, who removes, who answers
Match each office of the Odisha executive with its appointing authority, its article and its answerability, and avoid the common mix-ups.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The executive is the richest source of 'match the following' and 'who appoints' questions. The trick is to learn the chain of appointment once and then use it for each question. This lesson gives you that chain, the article numbers, and the traps built around them.
The chain of appointment
Who appoints whom
- President Appoints the Governor (Article 155)
- Governor Appoints the Chief Minister (Article 164)
- Chief Minister Advises the Governor on the other ministers
- Ministers Collectively answerable to the Vidhan Sabha
The President appoints the Governor. The Governor appoints the Chief Minister. The Governor then appoints the other ministers on the Chief Minister's advice. The ministers answer to the Vidhan Sabha. A question that skips a link is usually wrong.
Articles to learn
| Article | Subject |
|---|---|
| 153 | A Governor for each state |
| 155 | Governor appointed by the President |
| 158 | Conditions of the Governor's office (not a member of a legislature) |
| 163 | Council of Ministers to aid and advise the Governor |
| 164 | Chief Minister and other ministers; collective responsibility |
| 165 | Advocate General |
| 213 | Governor's power to issue ordinances |
Trap 1: appointed is not responsible
The President appoints the Governor, but the Governor is not 'responsible' to the Vidhan Sabha. It is the Council of Ministers that is collectively responsible to the Vidhan Sabha. The Chief Minister is appointed by the Governor but is answerable to the House because the Governor must appoint a person who commands its support.
Trap 2: the six-month rule
A person who is not a member of the Vidhan Sabha can be made a minister, but must become a member within six months, or must cease to be a minister (Article 164(4)).
Trap 3: the size of the ministry
The Council of Ministers, including the Chief Minister, may not exceed 15 per cent of the members of the Vidhan Sabha, and a state must have at least 12 ministers. With 147 members the limit is 22 (22.05, rounded down). For a very small assembly, say of 40 members, 15 per cent would give only 6, but the minimum of 12 still applies.
Trap 4: the Governor's discretion
The Governor acts on ministers' advice in most matters, but Article 163 allows the Governor to act in his or her discretion in a few matters. Choosing a Chief Minister when no party has a clear majority is one place where the Governor must use judgement. The Governor also has special duties for Scheduled Areas, covered in lesson 5.
Worked example 1: the missing link
Question: 'The Chief Minister of Odisha is appointed by the President.' True or false? Working: the President appoints the Governor; the Governor appoints the Chief Minister (Article 164). The statement is false.
Worked example 2: six months
Question: a person who is not a member of the Vidhan Sabha is made a minister on 1 June. Latest date to become a member? Working: six months from 1 June is 1 December.
Worked example 3: size of ministry
Question: how many ministers can a state with a 60-member assembly have? Working: 15 per cent of 60 is 9, but the Constitution says a state must have at least 12 ministers including the Chief Minister, so the minimum of 12 applies.
President > Governor > Chief Minister > Ministers. Article 155, 164. Ministers answer to the Vidhan Sabha. 15 per cent maximum, 12 minimum.
Key takeaways: follow the chain from the President to the ministers. Learn Articles 153, 155, 163, 164 and 165. A non-member minister has six months. The ministry is limited to 15 per cent of the assembly with a floor of 12.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which article provides for the Chief Minister and the Council of Ministers?
- Article 153
- Article 164
- Article 165
- Article 213
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 164 covers the Chief Minister and ministers.
-
2. A non-member of the Vidhan Sabha appointed as minister must become a member within:
- One month
- Three months
- One year
- Six months
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 164(4) gives six months.
-
3. The Advocate General is appointed by the:
- President
- Chief Minister alone
- Speaker
- Governor
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 165: the Governor appoints the Advocate General.
-
4. The ministers of a state are collectively answerable to:
- The President
- The Vidhan Sabha
- The High Court
- The Chief Secretary
Show answer
Answer: B. Collective responsibility to the assembly is in Article 164.
-
5. A state with a small assembly must still have at least how many ministers, as per the constitutional rule?
- 6
- 9
- 12
- 15
Show answer
Answer: C. A state must have at least 12 ministers, even if 15 per cent of its assembly would be fewer.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.