- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Half A Rupee Worth: the man with half a rupee and the ending
Retell the last part of R.K. Narayan's story in your own words: the hungry man's plea, Subbiah's bargain, the long wait, the search, and how Subbiah dies in his own godown, with the price arithmetic explained.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Retell the last part of the story in the correct order.
- Work out how much Subbiah was overcharging the poor man.
- Explain why Subbiah told the man to wait and what reasons he gave.
- Explain how Subbiah died and why the ending is ironic.
Everything in the story so far has been leading to one evening and one small coin. This part is short and tense, and its ending is one of the most famous in Narayan's stories.
Part 7: a plea in the street
One evening, just as Subbiah has locked his shop and is leaving with the key in his pocket, a man stops him, upset to find the shop shut. Subbiah brushes him off: he has other business. The man follows, grabs his arm and begs. His two children are crying for food; they and his old mother have been starving; his ration card ran out three days ago. He has searched the whole town without finding a grain, and his family at home are expecting him to bring something. He asks for one seer of rice for the six people in his house, and holds up all he has: a half-rupee coin.
Part 8: the bargain
Subbiah looks at the coin with scorn. The man reminds him that the controlled price is three seers for a rupee. Subbiah, angered, tells him not to talk of controlled prices, or he will starve. With another eight annas, he says, perhaps he might get a seer. The man has nothing more; it is the end of the month. Subbiah says he will get only half a seer, the price that a man he knows will ask. The man accepts: it is better than nothing. Subbiah takes the coin and tells him not to follow, because the supplier is suspicious and will refuse if he sees anyone. He makes no promise: if the man says no, that will be just bad luck.
| Price | Rice for 1 rupee | Rice for half a rupee (8 annas) |
|---|---|---|
| Controlled price | 3 seers | 1.5 seers |
| Subbiah's first offer | 1 seer | half a seer |
| What the man asked for | - | 1 seer |
Worked example 1: how much was he overcharging?
Question: By how many times was Subbiah's price higher than the controlled price? Working: at the controlled price, half a rupee buys 3 ÷ 2 = 1.5 seers. Subbiah offers half a seer for the same coin. 1.5 ÷ 0.5 = 3. Answer: he was charging three times the controlled price; the poor man would get only one-third of the rice he was entitled to.
Part 9: the long wait
Subbiah goes off with the coin, and the man waits at the street corner. Three hours pass. Night deepens. The man mutters to himself: where has he gone, when will I cook, what about the children? He walks the way Subbiah went, but finds nothing, because Subbiah had pretended to go that way so as to hide the godown, and then turned off in another direction. The man wanders the silent streets, goes back to the shop (still locked), and finally knocks at Subbiah's house.
Part 10: the search and the discovery
Subbiah's wife says he has not come home and becomes anxious. By six the next morning both are nervous, and she asks whether he has looked at 'the other godown'. She is the only person who knows where it is, so she has to lead the way. Through narrow lanes they reach the building; its door is bolted from the inside. They break open a ventilator, push a boy through to open the door, and in the faint morning light they see an electric torch on the floor, a half-rupee coin, and a part of a hand sticking out from under a heap of fallen rice bags. Subbiah has been crushed to death under his own hoarded rice.
The last night, step by step
- The plea A starving man begs for one seer.
- The bargain Subbiah offers half a seer for half a rupee.
- The wait The man waits three hours at the corner.
- The search Shop, then house; the wife fears the worst.
- The godown Bolted from inside; a boy goes in through the ventilator.
- The end A torch, the coin and a hand under the fallen bags.
Worked example 2: how do we know he waited long?
Question: Did the man wait for long, and how do you know? Working: look for time words and actions. The story says three hours passed and night deepened; the man began to mutter and then went searching. Answer: yes; he waited for over three hours, until the night deepened and his worry for his children drove him to search for Subbiah.
Irony of the ending: the rice he hoarded from the hungry becomes his grave, and the poor man's coin lies beside him.
Key takeaways: a starving father with half a rupee begs for rice; Subbiah demands three times the controlled price and makes him wait. Hours later, the man and Subbiah's wife find the secret godown bolted from inside, with Subbiah dead under the fallen bags, the coin beside him.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why could the man not get rice through the ration system?
- He had lost his ration card
- The ration shop had closed for good
- He did not have a ration card
- His ration card had run out three days earlier
Show answer
Answer: D. He tells Subbiah that his ration card was exhausted three days ago, so his family had been starving.
-
2. How much rice did Subbiah finally agree to get for the half-rupee coin?
- Half a seer
- One seer
- One and a half seers
- Three seers
Show answer
Answer: A. When the man had no more money, Subbiah said he would get only half a seer, which he claimed was the price a man he knew would demand.
-
3. Why did Subbiah tell the man not to follow him?
- He said the supplier was suspicious and would refuse if he saw anyone, but really he wanted to hide his secret godown
- He was going home to eat first
- He was afraid of the man
- The police were watching the street
Show answer
Answer: A. His stated reason was a suspicious supplier. The real reason, shown when he walks off in a false direction, was to keep his secret godown hidden.
-
4. Who led the man to the secret godown?
- A policeman
- Subbiah's assistant
- Subbiah's wife, the only person who knew where it was
- A boy from the street
Show answer
Answer: C. She was the only one who knew its whereabouts, so she had to show the way. A boy was later slipped in through the ventilator to open the door.
-
5. How did Subbiah die?
- He fell from the roof of his house
- He was crushed under a pile of fallen rice bags in his secret godown
- He was attacked by the hungry man
- He died of illness in his shop
Show answer
Answer: B. A hand stuck out from a heap of fallen bags; the hoarded rice had fallen on him in the bolted godown.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.