• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Half A Rupee Worth: the War, food control and Subbiah's tricks

Retell the middle of the story in your own words: how the War makes Subbiah richer, how he turns his shop into a Fair Price Grain Depot, and the tricks he uses to hoard rice in a secret godown.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain how Subbiah's profits rose during the War.
  • Describe how he reacted to price and food control.
  • List the dishonest methods he used at his depot.
  • Explain how he tackled the officials and where he hid his rice.

In the first part, Subbiah was a greedy but successful trader. In this part, a war and a set of government rules give him the chance to become something worse: a hoarder and black-marketeer who profits from other people's hunger.

Part 4: the War brings profit

When the War begins, it first seems like the end of the world. Soon it looks almost welcome to Subbiah. Rice stops coming from Saigon and Burma, so the stock he holds becomes as precious as gold. Crowds come to his shop at all hours. He buys the house next door as a godown (a storehouse), then more houses, then a dozen more villages. To him, war seems a fine thing.

Part 5: price and food control

Then the government brings in Price and Food Control: rules on what rice may be sold and at what price, so that the poor are not left hungry. For the first time Subbiah is worried. He cannot understand why anyone should tell him what to sell and at what rate, and he is pleased to hear others grumble that the Food Department is a fraud. Still, he adapts. By waiting on officials and filling in forms, he is allowed to carry on as a Fair Price Grain Depot. He must also hand over to the government all the rice grown on his village fields. He thinks this outrageous, cannot sleep or eat, and broods night after night.

Part 6: the solution: rice 'out of paper'

At last he decides what the government really wants: neat figures on paper. That, he thinks, it shall have. He keeps all the rice he wants, out of sight and off the records. When inspectors come to check his stock and accounts, he slips them money; a small bribe hides grain worth a hundred times as much. Soon he decides that controls are a blessing. He gives a few annas to charity twice a week and breaks a coconut at the temple every Friday, as if thanking God for his help.

  1. Short measures: he measures rice so skilfully that, by evening, a good quantity is left over that belongs to no one, except him.
  2. Confusing hours: he opens, closes and reopens the shop so that people must come again and again; when they have money he has no stock, and when he has stock they have no money.
  3. Hiding the harvest: only a small part of his village crop reaches the Food Department.
  4. Bribing inspectors: money paid to those who check his stock and accounts.
  5. A secret godown: a house in a back street, piled with rice bags from floor to ceiling, which he claims is a store of waste paper and rags for the paper mills.
  6. Secret sales: he sells only small amounts, only to known customers, takes cash in advance, and keeps a story ready about 'a man' who might or might not have rice.

On paper and in reality

  • What the records showed
    • An honest Fair Price Grain Depot
    • Village harvest handed to the government
    • A store of waste paper and rags
  • What was really happening
    • Short measures and confusing hours
    • Most of the harvest kept back
    • A godown full of hoarded rice

Worked example 1: did he follow the rules?

Question: Did Subbiah follow the rules laid down by the government? How did he tackle the officers? Working: separate appearance from reality. He followed the rules on paper (he became a Fair Price Depot and filled in forms) but broke them in practice (hoarding, short measures, hidden harvest). For the officers, find what he gave them. Answer: no; he only kept his records in order, and he bribed the officials who checked his stock so that they would not see what he was hiding.

Worked example 2: why the waste-paper story?

Question: Why did Subbiah say his back-street house stored waste paper and rags? Working: ask what would happen if people knew the truth. A hidden pile of rice in a time of shortage and control would expose him as a hoarder. Answer: to hide the rice he was hoarding illegally; a store of rags for paper mills would not attract inspectors or hungry buyers.

Narayan's irony: the man who cheats the hungry thanks God every Friday with a coconut.

Key takeaways: the War stops rice imports and makes Subbiah richer. Price and Food Control worries him, but he becomes a Fair Price Depot and cheats in many ways: short measures, confusing hours, hidden harvest, bribes and a secret godown passed off as a waste-paper store.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why did Subbiah's stock of rice become 'worth its weight in gold' during the War?

    1. Rice prices were fixed very high by law
    2. His rice was of a new variety
    3. Rice stopped coming from Saigon and Burma, so rice became scarce
    4. He mixed gold dust in the rice
    Show answer

    Answer: C. With imports from Saigon and Burma cut off, rice was scarce, so whatever he held became very valuable.

  2. 2. What was Subbiah's first reaction to Price and Food Control?

    1. He welcomed it
    2. He was worried and felt no one had the right to tell him what to sell and at what price
    3. He closed his shop in protest
    4. He left the town
    Show answer

    Answer: B. For the first time in his life he was worried; he could not see why anyone should fix what he sold and at what rate.

  3. 3. How did Subbiah deal with the people who came to examine his stock and accounts?

    1. He showed them his secret godown
    2. He refused to let them in
    3. He reported them to the police
    4. He bribed them
    Show answer

    Answer: D. He had to give away a lot of money to such visitors. A small note handed over hid rice worth far more.

  4. 4. What did Subbiah claim his back-street godown held?

    1. Waste paper and rags for the paper mills
    2. Old furniture
    3. Cattle feed
    4. Government rice
    Show answer

    Answer: A. It was piled with hoarded rice, but he passed it off as a store of waste paper and rags.

  5. 5. Which of these was NOT one of Subbiah's tricks at the depot?

    1. Measuring out rice so that some was left over each day
    2. Opening and closing the shop at confusing times
    3. Selling extra rice to the poor at below the controlled price
    4. Hiding most of his village harvest from the Food Department
    Show answer

    Answer: C. He never sold cheaply to the poor; he did the opposite. The other three are tricks the story describes.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery