• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

A Gift for Christmas, part 2: Jim comes home and the twist in the tale

Retell the second half: Della's worry about her short hair, Jim's strange stare, the set of combs, the secret of the sold watch, and Jim's calm ending, and use its new words correctly.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe Della's feelings as she waits for Jim.
  • Explain Jim's strange expression when he sees her.
  • Say what Jim's present was and why it could not be used.
  • Explain the twist at the end of the story.
  • Use words such as critically, feminine and scream correctly.

In the second half the story slows down. We wait with Della for Jim, watch his face with her, and then meet the twist that makes the story famous.

Della waits

At home, the excitement fades and Della grows nervous about what she has done. She studies her reflection long and carefully, then curls her short hair with curling irons. The little curls make her look like a schoolboy. She worries that Jim will say she looks like a boy, and asks herself what else she could have done with so little money.

By seven o'clock the coffee is made and dinner is ready. Jim is never late. Della sits near the door holding the chain. When she hears his step on the stairs she turns pale and quietly prays that he will still think her pretty.

Jim's strange stare

Jim comes in looking thin and serious. The writer calls him a poor fellow: he is only twenty-two and already has a family to support; he needs a new overcoat and has no gloves. He stares at Della with an expression she cannot read. It is not anger or surprise, and it frightens her. Della rushes to explain: she cut off and sold her hair to buy him a present; it will grow again quickly; he must be happy, because she has a wonderful gift for him. Jim, speaking with difficulty, keeps asking whether her hair is really gone, and looks around the room as if he cannot believe it.

The combs

At last Jim seems to wake up. He kisses Della and tells her that nothing could make him love her less. He takes a package from his overcoat and puts it on the table, saying that when she opens it she will understand why he acted so strangely. Inside is a set of beautiful, expensive combs for the side and back of the hair, the very combs Della had long admired in a shop window on Broadway. She screams with joy, then bursts into tears: the hair she would have worn them in is gone. Smiling through her tears, she says her hair grows very fast.

The twist

Then Della remembers her own gift and eagerly holds out the platinum chain, asking for Jim's watch to see how it looks. Instead of handing it over, Jim lies back on the couch, smiles, and suggests they put their presents away for a while, because they are too nice to use just now. He sold the watch to buy her combs. Then he calmly asks her to serve dinner.

Two gifts, two sacrifices

  • Della
    • Sold: her long hair
    • Bought: a platinum chain
    • For: Jim's gold watch
    • But the watch is sold
  • Jim
    • Sold: his gold watch
    • Bought: a set of combs
    • For: Della's long hair
    • But the hair is sold
Each gave up a treasure to honour the other's treasure.

New words from this part

Meanings with example sentences written for this lesson.
WordMeaningOur own example
criticallycarefully, looking for faultsThe artist looked critically at her painting.
curling ironsa heated tool for curling hairShe used curling irons before the wedding.
burdenedweighed down with a duty or worryHe was burdened with the care of his younger brothers.
terrifiedvery frightenedThe puppy was terrified of the thunder.
packagea parcel or packetThe postman brought a package for my sister.
femininehaving qualities thought typical of womenThe room was decorated in a soft, feminine style.
screama loud, high cryA scream of delight came from the playground.

Worked example 1: what did Jim's look mean?

Question: Was the expression in Jim's eyes shock, surprise or anger? Working: the story says it was neither anger nor surprise. Think of what Jim knew: he had just sold his watch to buy combs for her long hair, and now the hair was gone. Answer: it was a kind of stunned shock and disbelief. He was not angry with Della; he was struck by the thought that his own sacrifice had become useless, which is why he kept asking if her hair was really gone.

Worked example 2: how did Jim get the combs?

Question: How had Jim managed to buy the combs? Working: the combs were expensive and Jim earned little; the last lines reveal the answer. Answer: he sold his precious gold watch, the family treasure handed down from his father and grandfather, and used the money to buy the combs.

The twist: each sold the very treasure the other's present was meant for.

Key takeaways: Della waits anxiously, and Jim is stunned to see her hair gone. His present, the combs she had longed for, cannot be used, and her chain is useless too, because Jim sold his watch to buy the combs. The gifts are useless, but the love behind them is priceless.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What did Della think she looked like after curling her short hair?

    1. A film star
    2. A schoolboy
    3. An old woman
    4. A grey cat
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The tiny curls made her look like a schoolboy, and she feared Jim would say she looked like a boy.

  2. 2. Why does the writer call Jim 'a poor fellow'?

    1. He was ill.
    2. He had lost his job.
    3. He was only twenty-two and had to support a family on little money.
    4. He had forgotten Christmas.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The story says he was only twenty-two and already burdened with a family; he needed a new overcoat and had no gloves. His youth and responsibilities make him a 'poor fellow'.

  3. 3. What was in the package Jim brought for Della?

    1. A gold watch
    2. A new overcoat
    3. A platinum chain
    4. A set of combs for her hair
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The package held the set of side and back combs that Della had admired in a Broadway shop window.

  4. 4. Why could Della not use her present at once?

    1. She had sold the hair the combs were meant for.
    2. The combs were broken.
    3. Jim took them back.
    4. They were the wrong colour.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The combs were meant for her long hair, but she had cut it off and sold it that very day.

  5. 5. What does Jim do when Della asks for his watch?

    1. He gives it to her at once.
    2. He gets angry and leaves.
    3. He lies back, smiles and says he sold it to buy her combs.
    4. He says he has lost it.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Instead of handing it over, he sits on the couch, smiles, suggests they put the presents away for a while, and reveals that he sold the watch to buy the combs.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery