- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Characters, themes and irony in A Gift for Christmas
Describe Della and Jim with evidence, explain the story's themes of love and sacrifice, identify its irony and twist ending, and write clear answers about the gift of rare love.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe Della and Jim with qualities backed by events.
- State the main themes and the message of the story.
- Explain the situational irony of the ending.
- Decide whether statements about the story are true or false, with reasons.
- Write a 50-word answer on how each gave the other the gift of rare love.
This story is short and simple, but its ending makes readers think. Was the couple foolish or wise? This lesson gives you the ideas and evidence to answer such questions.
The characters
| Character | Quality | Evidence (in our own words) |
|---|---|---|
| Della | Loving and self-sacrificing | She sells her beautiful hair, her greatest pride, for Jim's present. |
| Della | Thrifty | She saves pennies one or two at a time for months. |
| Della | Emotional but quick to act | She cries, then decides in a moment and hurries out. |
| Della | Anxious to please | She curls her hair and prays that Jim will still find her pretty. |
| Jim | Loving and self-sacrificing | He sells his family gold watch to buy the combs Della longed for. |
| Jim | Hard-working and burdened | Young, poorly paid, without gloves or a good overcoat. |
| Jim | Calm and gentle | He reassures Della of his love and smiles at the ending instead of complaining. |
Themes
- True love and sacrifice: each gives up the thing they treasure most to make the other happy.
- Poverty: the cheap flat, the tiny wage and the saved pennies show how hard life is for the couple, yet poverty does not reduce their love.
- The value of a gift: a gift's worth lies in the love and thought behind it, not in its price.
- Hope and patience: Della says her hair grows fast and Jim suggests keeping the gifts for later; both look forward, not back.
Irony and the twist ending
Situational irony happens when the result of an action is the opposite of what was intended. Della sells her hair to buy a chain for Jim's watch; Jim sells his watch to buy combs for Della's hair. Each sacrifice makes the other's gift useless. Yet there is a deeper twist: the gifts fail, but they prove something more valuable, that each loves the other more than their own treasure. The surprise ending, held back until the last lines, is typical of O. Henry.
The crossed sacrifices
- Della sells her hair to buy a chain for Jim's watch
- Jim sells his watch to buy combs for Della's hair
- The chain has no watch and the combs have no long hair
- Love is proved each gave up their greatest treasure
Then back to step 1: Della sells her hair
Worked example 1: true or false with reasons
- 'Jim loved Della more than she loved him.' False: both sacrificed their most prized possession, so their love is equal.
- 'Della could easily have bought a present without selling her hair.' False: she had only $1.87 after months of saving.
- 'Both gifts proved their true love for each other.' True: each gave up a treasure for the other.
- 'Della was proud of being Jim's wife.' True: she wanted a gift worthy of the honour of being owned by Jim, and prayed he would still find her pretty.
Worked example 2: the gift of rare love
Question: Both of them gave each other the gift of rare love. How? Answer (about 50 words): Della sold her beautiful hair, her greatest pride, to buy a platinum chain for Jim's watch. Jim sold his precious family watch to buy combs for her hair. The presents became useless, but each had given up the thing they valued most for the other. That willing sacrifice was a rarer gift than any object.
Were they foolish or wise?
The book asks you to discuss this. One view: they were foolish, because each lost a treasure and gained nothing usable, when a small, simple gift or an honest talk would have done. The other view: they were wise, because they learned how deeply they were loved, which no shop could sell. A good answer gives both views and then states your own with a reason.
Situational irony: the result is the opposite of the intention. In this story, the gifts fail but the love succeeds.
Key takeaways: Della and Jim are poor, loving and self-sacrificing. The story's irony is that each sacrifice makes the other's gift useless; its message is that love shown through sacrifice is worth more than any present.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which quality do Della and Jim share most clearly?
- Selfishness
- Willingness to sacrifice for each other
- Love of money
- Carelessness
Show answer
Answer: B. Della sells her hair and Jim sells his watch, each to please the other. Both are willing to give up their greatest treasure.
-
2. What kind of irony does the ending show?
- Situational irony: each sacrifice makes the other's gift useless
- No irony at all
- Irony that the shopkeeper cheated them
- Irony that Christmas was cancelled
Show answer
Answer: A. The result is the opposite of what each intended: the chain has no watch and the combs have no long hair. That is situational irony.
-
3. Is the statement 'Jim and Della loved each other equally' best supported by the story?
- No, Della loved Jim more.
- No, Jim loved Della more.
- We cannot tell from the story.
- Yes, because each gave up their most prized possession.
Show answer
Answer: D. Both made an equal sacrifice: Della her hair and Jim his watch. The story gives no sign that either loved more.
-
4. What is the main message of the story?
- Expensive gifts make people happy.
- Never sell anything you own.
- The love and sacrifice behind a gift matter more than the gift.
- Christmas is a time for shopping.
Show answer
Answer: C. The gifts themselves become useless, yet the story treats them as proof of a rare love. Its message is that the love behind a gift is what counts.
-
5. How does Jim react once he understands the situation at the end?
- Calmly, smiling and suggesting they keep the gifts for later
- Angrily, blaming Della
- Sadly, refusing to eat
- Proudly, boasting about his gift
Show answer
Answer: A. He sits back on the couch, smiles, suggests they put the presents away for a while, and asks for dinner: a calm, gentle reaction.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.