• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Characters, themes and who is responsible for Phatik's death

Write character sketches of Phatik, Makhan, the mother, Bishamber and the aunt, understand the themes of love, home and the needs of adolescence, discuss responsibility for Phatik's death, and see how irony and similes work in the story.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Write a short character sketch with traits backed by evidence from the story.
  • Explain the main themes of the story.
  • Give a balanced answer to 'Who is responsible for Phatik's death?'
  • Spot irony and figurative comparisons in the story.

Many questions on this story ask for character sketches or for your judgement. A good answer names a trait and proves it with an event from the story.

The characters, trait by trait

CharacterTraitsEvidence from the story
Phatiklively, proud leader; sensitive; generous; hungry for loveplans the log prank; feels the injustice of Makhan's lie; gives away his kite and marbles; gazes longingly at rooftops
Makhanstubborn, calm, clever at getting his way, untruthfulsits on the log and will not move; lies that Phatik hit him
The mothershort-tempered, partial to Makhan, but loving underneathbelieves Makhan at once; is relieved to send Phatik away; at the end weeps 'my darling'
Bishamberkind, well-meaning, affectionate, but not careful enoughoffers to educate Phatik; sits by him all night; sends for the mother; did not think how his wife would react
The auntcold, unwelcoming, harshresents the boy; calls him a country lout; complains when he is brought back ill

Themes

Themes of The Home-Coming

  • Home and love
    • A child's own home is his paradise
    • No comfort can replace a mother's love
  • Adolescence
    • Fourteen is the age that most needs love
    • Adults misunderstand and scold
  • Injustice and neglect
    • Phatik is blamed for what he did not do
    • He is unwanted in Calcutta
  • Irony
    • He longs to leave, then longs to return
    • The home-coming comes only at death

Who is responsible for Phatik's death?

There is no single correct answer; the best answers weigh several people. The mother favoured Makhan, believed his lie and sent Phatik away mainly to be rid of him. The aunt made him feel unwanted and insulted him when he most needed kindness, which drove him to run away while ill. Bishamber was kind but did not foresee his wife's attitude or notice how unhappy Phatik was. The school's harshness added to his misery. Tagore also suggests a wider cause: adults in general fail to understand and love boys of this age. A balanced answer names the main causes and supports each with an event.

Irony and comparisons

Irony is when the result is the opposite of what is expected. Phatik is overjoyed to leave home but dies longing to return. The holidays he waits for 'come' only in his delirium. Tagore also uses vivid comparisons: Makhan on the log is like a young philosopher; Phatik at school is like an overloaded donkey bearing its beatings; the unloved boy is like a stray dog without a master. Each comparison makes us see a feeling. And Makhan is described with the simile 'as good as gold' - from his mother's point of view.

Worked example 1: a character sketch of Bishamber

Bishamber is a kind and affectionate man. As soon as he returns from Bombay, he looks for his widowed sister and offers to educate her troublesome son with his own children. In Calcutta he is gentle with Phatik, and when the boy falls ill he sits by him all night, holding his hands, and sends for his mother. His fault is a lack of foresight: he does not consider how his wife will treat the boy, nor notice how unhappy Phatik has become. (Traits: kind, affectionate, well-meaning; weakness: lack of foresight - each proved by an event.)

Worked example 2: why did Phatik beat Makhan before his mother?

Question: Why did Phatik hit Makhan even in front of their mother? Working: what pushed him? Makhan repeated a lie, the mother believed it, and Phatik's patience was already exhausted. Answer: the injustice of being blamed for something he had not done made him lose control - showing how strongly he felt about truth and fairness.

Character sketch formula: trait + proof from the story, two or three times, then one weakness or change.

Key takeaways: Phatik is lively, sensitive and starved of love; Makhan is stubborn and untruthful; the mother is partial but loving; Bishamber is kind but short-sighted; the aunt is cold. The story's themes are home, love, the needs of adolescence and injustice, sharpened by irony.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which event best proves that Phatik could be generous?

    1. He planned to roll the log
    2. He gave Makhan his fishing rod, kite and marbles before leaving
    3. He hit Makhan in front of his mother
    4. He answered the stranger rudely
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Before leaving for Calcutta he gave away his treasured things to Makhan for ever - the story calls his generosity unbounded.

  2. 2. Which trait of Bishamber's is a weakness?

    1. He did not foresee how his wife would treat Phatik
    2. He sat up with Phatik all night
    3. He looked for his widowed sister
    4. He sent for the mother
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The other three show kindness. His failure to think about his wife's attitude is the weakness the story hints at.

  3. 3. What is ironic about Phatik's journey?

    1. He became rich in Calcutta
    2. He never left the village
    3. He was eager to leave home, but in the city he longed only to return
    4. He liked his aunt more than his mother
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Irony is a reversal of expectation: he left happily, then suffered, longing to go home - which he reaches only in death.

  4. 4. Tagore compares the unloved boy of fourteen to...

    1. a young philosopher
    2. a king on his throne
    3. a busy bee
    4. a stray dog that has lost its master
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The writer says scolding and lack of open love make such a boy like a stray dog without a master.

  5. 5. Which is the most balanced answer to 'Who is responsible for Phatik's death?'

    1. Only Makhan, because he sat on the log
    2. Only the police
    3. Several people: the mother's partiality, the aunt's coldness and Bishamber's lack of foresight, along with the harsh school
    4. Nobody; he simply caught a cold
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The story shows many causes acting together; a strong answer weighs them and supports each with an event.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery