- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The Home-Coming, part 1: the village, the log and Uncle Bishamber
Retell the first half of Rabindranath Tagore's story - Phatik's prank with the log, the fight with Makhan, the mother's anger and the arrival of Uncle Bishamber who takes Phatik to Calcutta - and use its new words.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Say who wrote the story and introduce its main characters.
- Retell the events in the village in the right order, in your own words.
- Explain why Phatik's mother was glad to send him away.
- Use new words such as ringleader, sauntered, futility, manoeuvre, sheepish, sullenly and perpetual.
Lesson 6 of the PSEB English Main Course Book is The Home-Coming by Rabindranath Tagore, the great Bengali writer. The book's introduction asks the question at the heart of the story: what happens to a boy of fourteen who leaves his own home to live with relatives? Is his own home the only real paradise for him? The story is in two halves - in the village, and in the city of Calcutta (now Kolkata). This lesson covers the first half.
The characters
| Character | Who they are |
|---|---|
| Phatik Chakravarti | a boy of fourteen, leader of the village boys, full of mischief |
| Makhan | Phatik's younger brother; quiet, stubborn, his mother's favourite |
| The mother | a widow who finds Phatik a constant nuisance |
| Bishamber | the mother's brother, back from business in Bombay (now Mumbai) |
| The aunt | Bishamber's wife in Calcutta, mother of three boys |
The prank with the log
A heavy log lies on the mud-flat by the river, waiting to be made into a boat's mast. Phatik, the ringleader, plans that the boys will roll it away together to surprise and annoy its owner. Everyone agrees. But just as they begin, Makhan strolls up without a word and sits on the log, calm as a little philosopher. A boy pushes him nervously; he does not move. Phatik, furious, threatens to beat him, but Makhan only gets more comfortable. Phatik's position as leader is now at stake, yet he cannot bring himself to carry out the threat. So his quick mind finds a new plan: roll the log over with Makhan on it. Makhan holds on out of pride - and at the word 'go' the log turns and Makhan tumbles off, his dignity gone.
The boys shout with delight, but Phatik is uneasy, and rightly so. Makhan gets up screaming, scratches, hits and kicks Phatik, and runs home crying. Tagore playfully calls this the end of the drama's first act.
The stranger, the lie and the uncle
A middle-aged man with grey hair steps off a boat and asks Phatik where the Chakravartis live. Phatik, chewing a blade of grass, answers rudely and points vaguely. A servant then arrives and carries the struggling Phatik home, because his mother has called him. She accuses him of hitting Makhan again. Phatik denies it and tells her to ask Makhan - but Makhan sticks to his story. Unable to bear this injustice, Phatik hits Makhan again. The mother pulls him away and hits him back; when he pushes her, she is shocked.
At that very moment the grey-haired stranger walks in. The mother recognises him as her brother Bishamber and touches his feet with joy. He had gone to Bombay soon after her marriage, and she had lost her husband meanwhile. When he asks about the boys, she describes Phatik as lazy, disobedient and a constant nuisance, and Makhan as good as gold and fond of reading. Bishamber offers to take Phatik to Calcutta and educate him with his own children. The mother agrees at once; she is relieved, because she fears Phatik may harm Makhan one day, though she is a little hurt to see how eager he is to leave. Phatik is thrilled, can hardly sleep, and generously gives Makhan his fishing rod, kite and marbles for ever.
Part 1 in six steps
- Prank Phatik plans to roll away the log.
- Makhan sits He is rolled off with the log.
- Fight Makhan attacks Phatik and runs home.
- Accusation Makhan's lie; Phatik hits him again.
- Uncle arrives Bishamber returns and hears about Phatik.
- Departure Phatik leaves happily for Calcutta.
New words from part 1
| Word | Meaning | Our own example |
|---|---|---|
| ringleader | the leader of a group in mischief | Everyone knew Bunty was the ringleader of the water-balloon attack. |
| sauntered | walked slowly and casually | He sauntered into class ten minutes late. |
| futility | uselessness | She realised the futility of arguing with the referee. |
| manoeuvre | a clever plan or move | A smart manoeuvre got the car out of the crowded lane. |
| discomfit | to embarrass or upset | The sudden question discomfited the speaker. |
| impotent rage | helpless anger | Stuck in the jam, the driver honked in impotent rage. |
| sheepish | embarrassed because of a mistake | He gave a sheepish smile when caught eating the cake. |
| sullenly | in a bad-tempered, silent way | She sullenly pushed her plate away. |
| perpetual | never-ending | The leaking tap was a perpetual problem. |
| on pins | very restless and eager or anxious | We were on pins waiting for the result. |
Worked example 1: what was the 'new manoeuvre'?
Question: What was Phatik's new manoeuvre, and why did he need it? Working: first the problem - he had threatened Makhan before the other boys but lacked the courage to beat him, so his position as leader was at risk. Then the plan - roll the log over with Makhan sitting on it, which would both defeat Makhan and amuse the boys. Answer: he ordered the boys to roll the log and Makhan over together, saving face without hitting his brother himself.
Worked example 2: was Makhan telling the truth?
Question: Was Makhan speaking the truth when he said Phatik hit him? Working: check the events - the log rolled over, Makhan fell, and it was Makhan who scratched and hit Phatik. Phatik did not hit him at the river. Answer: no; Makhan lied, which is why Phatik felt so wronged.
Part 1 sets up the tragedy: a mother who sees only Phatik's faults, and a boy eager to leave a home where he feels unjustly treated.
Key takeaways: Phatik is a lively, proud leader; Makhan is stubborn and lies; the mother favours Makhan; Bishamber is kind. Phatik leaves happily for Calcutta - not yet knowing what he is leaving behind.
Check your understanding
-
1. What mischief did Phatik plan with the boys?
- To steal a boat
- To roll away a heavy log lying on the mud-flat
- To throw stones at the stranger
- To hide Makhan's books
Show answer
Answer: B. The log was waiting to be shaped into a mast; Phatik planned to roll it away to annoy its owner.
-
2. Why did Phatik not simply beat Makhan when he refused to get off the log?
- His courage failed him at the moment of crisis
- His mother was watching
- The other boys stopped him
- Makhan ran away first
Show answer
Answer: A. The story says his courage failed him, so he thought of a cleverer plan - rolling the log with Makhan on it.
-
3. Who was the grey-haired stranger?
- The owner of the log
- A schoolteacher
- Phatik's mother's brother, Bishamber
- A police officer
Show answer
Answer: C. The mother recognised him as her brother Bishamber, back from business in Bombay.
-
4. Why was the mother relieved to send Phatik away?
- She wanted to move to Bombay
- Phatik had asked to go to school
- She could not afford his food
- She feared he might harm Makhan and saw him as a nuisance
Show answer
Answer: D. She had a prejudice against him and was afraid he would drown Makhan or hurt him one day.
-
5. Which word best describes how Phatik felt when the stranger walked in during the quarrel?
- sheepish
- invincible
- perpetual
- unanimous
Show answer
Answer: A. He had just pushed his mother; caught in the act by a stranger, he looked embarrassed - sheepish.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.