- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Economic growth, economic development and sustainable development
Distinguish economic growth from economic development, define sustainable development and explain why it is needed, and compare growth that harms the environment with sustainable progress.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List the differences between economic growth and economic development.
- Explain why some growth is needed for development.
- Define sustainable development and say where the term was first used, according to the textbook.
- Give five reasons why sustainable development is needed.
People often use 'growth' and 'development' as if they meant the same. They do not. And even development can go wrong if it uses up the air, water and land that our children will need. This lesson sorts out the three ideas.
Growth is not the same as development
Economic growth means only quantitative change: more goods and services are produced. Economic development includes quantitative change and qualitative change, such as changes in the social, moral, religious and political structures of a country. The textbook explains that developed countries have already gone through most qualitative changes, so for them the word growth is used; for developing and under-developed countries, which still have both kinds of change ahead, the word development is used.
| Point | Economic growth | Economic development |
|---|---|---|
| Dimensions | Single-dimensional | Multidimensional |
| Kind of change | Only quantitative | Quantitative and qualitative |
| Used for | Developed nations | Developing and under-developed nations |
| Relation | Can happen without development | Needs some growth, because qualitative change needs money |
Growth is a part of development: development needs some growth, but growth alone is not development.
Worked example 1: growth, development, or both?
Case A: A country's factories double their output, but schools, health and the status of women stay the same. Case B: Output rises and, at the same time, more girls finish school, clinics open in villages and more people get secure jobs. Reasoning: A has only a quantitative change; B has quantitative and qualitative change. Answer: A is economic growth only; B is economic development (which includes growth).
The cost to the environment
In the race to raise GDP, many policies have damaged the environment: polluted air, water and land, and an earth emptied of natural resources. The results include air pollution and smog, water shortage and pollution, climate change and the running down of coal and petroleum. The textbook recalls that in 2017 smog in Punjab became so severe that schools and colleges were shut, and that Delhi introduced an odd-even rule for vehicles. The present generation has a moral duty to leave a healthy environment for the next.
Sustainable development
So the question is no longer only how to develop, but how to keep development going so that future generations as well as the present one enjoy its benefits. This is sustainable development: a process that meets the needs of present and future generations while protecting the environment, without reducing the quantity and quality of environmental resources. According to the textbook, the term was first used in the World Conservation Strategy presented by the International Union for the Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources in 1980.
Why it is needed
- To save the environment from degradation.
- To maintain biodiversity, the variety of living creatures.
- To maintain the quality of life of present and future generations.
- To protect ourselves and future generations from the harm of climate change.
- To reduce inequality in the distribution of resources.
Two paths
-
Growth at any cost
- Heavy industry, smoke and waste
- High income and output now
- Polluted air, water and land
- Worse life for present and future generations
-
Sustainable development
- Output with clean air and water
- Resources used with care
- Greenery protected
- Better life now and later
Worked example 2: is this sustainable?
Question: A village (made-up case) can (i) pump groundwater without limit to grow more paddy this year, or (ii) switch part of its land to crops that need less water and recharge its ponds, earning slightly less now. Which is sustainable? Reasoning: Option (i) raises output now but runs down a resource the next generation needs. Option (ii) keeps the water available for the future while still producing. Answer: Option (ii) is sustainable development.
Key takeaways: Economic growth is a quantitative, single-dimensional change; economic development is multidimensional, with quantitative and qualitative change, and needs some growth. Growth that destroys the environment harms present and future generations. Sustainable development meets present and future needs while protecting the environment; the textbook says the term was first used by the World Conservation Strategy of the IUCN in 1980.
Check your understanding
-
1. Economic growth includes:
- Only qualitative change
- Both quantitative and qualitative change
- Only quantitative change
- No change in output
Show answer
Answer: C. Growth means only more goods and services produced, a quantitative change. Development adds qualitative change.
-
2. Which statement is correct?
- Some economic growth is needed for economic development
- Development is possible with no money at all
- Growth and development mean exactly the same
- Growth is multidimensional
Show answer
Answer: A. Qualitative changes such as schools and health care need money, so some growth is necessary for development.
-
3. According to the textbook, the term 'sustainable development' was first used in:
- The Wealth of Nations, 1776
- The first Human Development Report, 1990
- A Census of India report, 2011
- The World Conservation Strategy, 1980
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says the term was first used in the World Conservation Strategy presented by the IUCN in 1980.
-
4. Sustainable development mainly aims to:
- Raise GDP as fast as possible, whatever the cost
- Meet present needs while keeping resources and environment for future generations
- Stop all production
- Use all resources now
Show answer
Answer: B. It balances present needs with those of future generations by protecting the quantity and quality of environmental resources.
-
5. Which is NOT a reason for sustainable development given in the lesson?
- Maintaining biodiversity
- Protection from climate change
- Making pollution grow faster
- Reducing inequality in resources
Show answer
Answer: C. Sustainable development aims to reduce pollution and degradation, not increase it. The other three are reasons the textbook gives.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.