- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Kerala, Punjab and Bihar: comparing development
Read the textbook's comparison of Kerala, Punjab and Bihar on income-based and non-income-based indicators, and draw careful conclusions from such a table.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Name the income-based and non-income-based indicators used in the comparison.
- Define BPL population and maternal mortality rate.
- Read the textbook's table and rank the three states on each indicator.
- State the textbook's overall conclusion and its limits.
India is diverse, economically and socially. The textbook compares three states, Kerala, Punjab and Bihar, using both income-based and non-income-based indicators, to show how different the picture of development can be within one country.
The indicators
Indicators used in the comparison
-
Income-based
- Per capita income: average income per person
- BPL population: share of people below the poverty line
-
Non-income-based
- Sex ratio: females per 1,000 males
- Infant mortality rate: infant deaths under one year per 1,000 live births
- Maternal mortality rate: mothers' deaths linked to childbirth per 1,00,000 live births
- Literacy rate: % of people who can read, write and understand
BPL (below poverty line) population is the part of the population that cannot meet the basic necessities of life. The textbook explains that in India the poverty line is set in terms of monthly per capita consumption expenditure, and states that 21.9% of India's population was below the poverty line (it links this figure to 2011). The maternal mortality rate counts deaths of mothers due to pregnancy and childbirth; it is usually expressed per 1,00,000 live births.
The textbook's table
| Indicator | Kerala | Punjab | Bihar |
|---|---|---|---|
| Per capita income (₹) | 50,146 | 44,769 | 12,090 |
| BPL population | 7.05% | 8.26% | 33.74% |
| Sex ratio (females per 1,000 males) | 1,084 | 895 | 918 |
| Infant mortality rate (per 1,000 live births) | 12 | 30 | 44 |
| Maternal mortality rate (per 1,00,000) | 66 | 155 | 219 |
| Literacy rate | 94.00% | 75.84% | 61.80% |
Reading the table
- Income-based: Kerala and Punjab have far higher per capita income and far lower BPL shares than Bihar.
- Sex ratio: Kerala is the only one of the three with more females than males. Punjab's ratio is the lowest of the three, even lower than Bihar's.
- Infant and maternal mortality: Kerala's rates are the lowest by a wide margin, showing better health care for mothers and babies; Bihar's are the highest.
- Literacy: Kerala leads, Punjab is in the middle, Bihar is last.
For mortality rates and BPL share, LOWER is better. For per capita income, sex ratio (towards balance) and literacy, HIGHER is better.
Worked example 1: comparing gaps in the textbook's figures
Question: Using the table, how many more infants per 1,000 live births died in Bihar than in Kerala, and how many times Kerala's rate is Bihar's? Working: 44 − 12 = 32 more per 1,000 live births. 44 ÷ 12 ≈ 3.7 times. Meaning: By these figures, a baby born in Bihar faced a risk of dying in infancy nearly four times that in Kerala.
Worked example 2: is income enough?
Question: Kerala's per capita income in the table is about 12% higher than Punjab's ((50,146 − 44,769) ÷ 44,769 × 100 ≈ 12%). Is Kerala's lead in health and literacy just as small? Working: IMR: 12 against 30, less than half. MMR: 66 against 155, less than half. Literacy: 94.00% against 75.84%, about 18 percentage points higher. Answer: No. The gap in social indicators is much wider than the gap in income. This is exactly why the textbook uses non-income indicators: income alone would make Kerala and Punjab look much alike.
The textbook's conclusion
The textbook concludes that, on these indicators, Kerala performs better than Punjab and Bihar on all of them and can be called relatively developed; Punjab stands in the middle and is called a developing state; and Bihar lags behind. Remember that these are figures from one past period; the states' positions on particular indicators can change, so always check the year of any data you use.
Key takeaways: The comparison uses income-based indicators (per capita income, BPL share) and non-income-based ones (sex ratio, IMR, MMR, literacy). In the textbook's table Kerala leads on all six, Punjab is in the middle overall but has the lowest sex ratio of the three, and Bihar lags. Social indicators can show gaps that income hides.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which is an income-based indicator in the textbook's comparison?
- Sex ratio
- Literacy rate
- BPL population
- Infant mortality rate
Show answer
Answer: C. Per capita income and BPL population are the income-based indicators; the other three are non-income-based.
-
2. In the textbook's table, which state has the lowest sex ratio of the three?
- Punjab
- Kerala
- Bihar
- All are equal
Show answer
Answer: A. Punjab has 895 females per 1,000 males, below Bihar (918) and Kerala (1,084).
-
3. For which indicator is a LOWER figure a sign of better development?
- Literacy rate
- Maternal mortality rate
- Per capita income
- Sex ratio in a state with fewer females
Show answer
Answer: B. Fewer mothers dying in childbirth is better, so a lower maternal mortality rate signals better development.
-
4. Using the table, Bihar's literacy rate is how many percentage points below Kerala's?
- 14.04
- 61.80
- 18.16
- 32.20
Show answer
Answer: D. 94.00 − 61.80 = 32.20 percentage points. 18.16 is the Kerala-Punjab gap, and 14.04 is the Punjab-Bihar gap.
-
5. According to the textbook, the poverty line in India is set in terms of:
- Monthly per capita consumption expenditure
- The number of cars owned
- Sex ratio
- Land owned by each family
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook says the poverty line is measured in terms of monthly per capita consumption expenditure.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.