• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Problems of large dams and water conflicts

Explain the environmental, social and safety problems linked with large dams, including sedimentation, reservoir-induced seismicity, displacement, movements like Narmada Bachao Andolan, changed cropping patterns and inter-state disputes.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe how dams affect rivers and aquatic life.
  • Explain reservoir-induced seismicity.
  • Explain why large dams have led to social movements.
  • Weigh the advantages and disadvantages of multi-purpose projects.

Dams have brought canal water and electricity to millions. But in recent years large dams have also faced strong questions and protests. A good citizen should be able to weigh both sides; this lesson gives the other side of the balance sheet.

Effects on rivers and the environment

  • Natural flow is disturbed: less sediment moves downstream, while too much settles at the bottom of the reservoir; stream beds become rockier and poorer homes for aquatic life.
  • Rivers are fragmented: fish and other animals cannot migrate, especially to spawn.
  • Land is submerged: vegetation and soil on the flooded floodplain decay over time.
  • Sedimentation reduces storage: a reservoir filled with silt holds less water and can even worsen floods.
  • Flood control can fail: during very heavy rain, releasing water from dams can make floods worse. The textbook gives the Kerala floods of 2018 as an example.

Reservoir-induced seismicity (RIS)

Areas under very large reservoirs can develop strain in the rocks and experience earthquakes. The textbook explains that the weight of the water and the sediment presses on the rocks, opening new cracks or widening old faults, while water seeping into the rocks acts like a lubricant, making blocks of rock slip more easily. This is called reservoir-induced seismicity.

How a large reservoir can trigger earthquakes

  1. Huge weight of water and sediment
  2. Pressure on rocks below
  3. Cracks form or faults widen
  4. Seeping water lubricates the faults
  5. Rocks slip: tremors

Social effects

Large projects often displace local communities, who lose land, livelihood and their access to resources for the 'greater good'. This has led to movements such as the Narmada Bachao Andolan and the Tehri Dam Andolan. The textbook asks who really gains: often landowners, large farmers, industrialists and cities, rather than the landless poor of the area.

Irrigation has also changed cropping patterns: farmers shift to water-hungry commercial crops, which can cause salinisation of soil, and the gap between rich landowners and the landless can widen. Dams also cause conflicts between users who want different things from the same water, and inter-state water disputes over sharing costs and benefits, such as the Kaveri dispute between Karnataka and Tamil Nadu.

Weighing multi-purpose projects

  • Advantages
    • Irrigation for dry areas
    • Hydroelectric power for homes and industry
    • Water supply to cities and factories
    • Flood control when well managed
    • Navigation, fishing, recreation
  • Disadvantages
    • Displacement and loss of livelihood
    • Submerged forests and farmland
    • Blocked fish migration, poorer river habitat
    • Sedimentation; risk of floods and RIS
    • Salinity, inequality and inter-state disputes

Large dams bring water and power, but can displace people, harm rivers, fill with silt and spark disputes. Planning must count both sides.

Worked example 1: sorting arguments

Which statement is NOT an argument in favour of multi-purpose projects? (a) They bring water to dry areas. (b) They control floods by regulating flow. (c) They cause large-scale displacement and loss of livelihood. (d) They generate electricity. Statements a, b and d are benefits; c is a cost, so it is the argument against.

Worked example 2: tracing a chain of effects

Canal water arrives in a dry district. Farmers switch from millets to sugarcane and paddy (more water). Heavy watering raises the water table and brings salts up (salinisation). Yields fall on salty land. Large farmers who could afford tube-wells and fertiliser gain most, while the landless gain little (social gap). One change can trigger a chain of effects.

Key takeaways: large dams disturb river flow, block fish, submerge land, trap sediment and may trigger earthquakes (RIS). They have displaced people and led to movements such as the Narmada Bachao Andolan. Irrigation changes cropping patterns and can cause salinity and inequality, and water sharing causes disputes like that over the Kaveri.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which statement is NOT an argument in favour of multi-purpose river projects?

    1. They bring water to areas that suffer from scarcity
    2. They help control floods by regulating flow
    3. They lead to large-scale displacement and loss of livelihood
    4. They generate electricity for homes and industries
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Displacement and loss of livelihood are disadvantages; the other three are benefits.

  2. 2. RIS, linked with large reservoirs, stands for:

    1. Reservoir-Induced Seismicity
    2. River Irrigation Scheme
    3. Rainfall Index System
    4. Regional Irrigation Survey
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Reservoir-Induced Seismicity means earthquakes triggered by the weight of water in large reservoirs and by water seeping into faults.

  3. 3. The Narmada Bachao Andolan arose mainly because of:

    1. Shortage of electricity in cities
    2. Large-scale displacement of local communities by dams
    3. A dispute over fishing licences
    4. Lack of canals in Punjab
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Resistance to large dams on the Narmada was mainly about the displacement of people who lost land and livelihoods.

  4. 4. How do dams harm fish in a river?

    1. They make water too cold
    2. They add salt to the river
    3. They remove all oxygen
    4. They block migration, especially for spawning
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Dams fragment rivers, so fish cannot move upstream or downstream to breed.

  5. 5. The Kaveri water dispute is mainly between which states?

    1. Punjab and Haryana
    2. Karnataka and Tamil Nadu
    3. Gujarat and Madhya Pradesh
    4. Odisha and West Bengal
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook gives the Kaveri dispute between Karnataka and Tamil Nadu as an example of inter-state water disputes.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery