• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Magic Violin: characters, themes and 'the brain is mightier than a sword'

Describe the boy, the farmer, the magistrate and the angel with evidence, explain the themes of kindness rewarded, greed punished and wit over force, and prepare the book's discussion topic.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe each main character with evidence from the story.
  • State the main themes and the moral of the story.
  • Recognise the features of a folk tale in it.
  • Discuss the book's topic: the brain is mightier than a sword.

Questions on a story often ask what kind of person a character is, or what the story teaches. A good answer always backs a quality with something the character does. This lesson gives you that evidence.

The characters

Each quality is backed by something the character does (in our own words).
CharacterQualityEvidence
The boyCheerfulHe laughs at three coins for three years and leaves whistling.
The boyGenerousHe gives all his coins to a hungry beggar.
The boyCleverHe uses his last wish to play the violin, and keeps playing until he is safely away.
The boyHonest and trusting at firstHe works without fixing wages because he thinks the farmer is just.
The farmerMean and miserlyHe pays three copper coins for three years' work.
The farmerDishonest and spitefulHe falsely reports the boy as a thief, which could cost the boy his life.
The magistrateKind but hastyHe lets the boy play, yet sentences him without asking how he got the money.
The angelJustHe tests the boy's kindness and rewards it with gifts he deserves.

How the boy changes

At the start the boy trusts everyone: he does not even fix his wages, believing the farmer to be just. By the end he says plainly that he trusts no one any more, and he takes every precaution. His cheerfulness and kindness remain, but he has learnt from experience that goodness must be protected by good sense.

Themes and moral

  • Kindness is rewarded: the boy shares all he has and receives magic gifts.
  • Greed is punished: the miser who cheated the boy loses a thousand pieces of silver and ends up dancing in the dust.
  • Wit over force: the boy faces the police, the court and the hangman alone, and escapes by thinking, not fighting.
  • Justice: the boy finally receives a fair reward for three years of work, while the law, misled by appearances, nearly kills an innocent person.
  • Cheerfulness in hardship: the boy's good humour never fails him.

The boy and the farmer

  • The boy
    • Poor but happy
    • Gives freely
    • Trusts, then learns caution
    • Wins by cleverness
    • Ends free and rich
  • The farmer
    • Rich but mean
    • Takes without paying
    • Lies to the police
    • Is beaten by his own greed
    • Ends exhausted and poorer

A folk tale

The story has the usual marks of a folk tale: an unnamed hero, a clear villain, a magical helper in disguise, a number of wishes, magic objects and a happy ending in which good wins. Notice the pattern of threes: three years, three copper coins. Folk tales use such patterns because they were first told aloud and are easy to remember.

Discussion: the brain is mightier than a sword

The book asks you to discuss this saying. It means that intelligence and clever thinking achieve more than weapons and force. The story supports it: the boy has a gun that never misses, yet he never uses it against a person. When he is about to be hanged, he does not shoot his way out; he thinks, asks for a harmless last wish and turns the whole court into helpless dancers. In real life, too, quarrels are often settled by talks, laws and ideas rather than violence.

Worked example 1: a character answer

Question: What kind of man was the farmer? Working: choose two or three qualities and give evidence for each. Answer: the farmer was a mean miser; he hired the boy without wages and paid him only three copper coins for three years. He was also dishonest and cruel, because he falsely told the police the boy had stolen his silver, knowing the punishment was death.

Worked example 2: planning the discussion

Question: Plan a short talk on 'the brain is mightier than a sword'. Working: give the meaning, one example from the story and one from life, then a conclusion. Answer plan: (1) meaning: thinking wins where force fails; (2) story: the boy escapes the gallows with a clever last wish, not with his gun; (3) life: a student who calmly explains a mistake to the principal achieves more than one who shouts; (4) conclusion: force may win a moment, but wisdom wins lasting results.

A character quality needs evidence: say what the person is, then what he does that shows it.

Key takeaways: the boy is cheerful, generous and clever; the farmer is mean, dishonest and spiteful; the magistrate is kind but hasty. The story teaches that kindness is rewarded, greed is punished and wit is mightier than force.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which action best shows that the boy was generous?

    1. He took the farmer's silver.
    2. He shot a bird.
    3. He played the violin in the marketplace.
    4. He gave all three coins to a hungry beggar.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Giving away all his wages for three years to a stranger in need shows true generosity. The other actions do not show giving.

  2. 2. Which word best describes the farmer?

    1. Generous
    2. Miserly
    3. Brave
    4. Forgiving
    Show answer

    Answer: B. He paid only three copper coins for three years of work and hid a thousand pieces of silver under his floor. He hated spending money, so he was miserly.

  3. 3. How does the boy change during the story?

    1. From trusting everyone to trusting no one, while staying cheerful
    2. From cheerful to sad and bitter
    3. From rich to poor
    4. From honest to dishonest
    Show answer

    Answer: A. At first he works without fixing wages because he trusts the farmer. At the end he says he trusts no one and plays until he is safely away. He remains cheerful throughout.

  4. 4. How does the story support the saying 'the brain is mightier than a sword'?

    1. The boy shoots the hangman with his gun.
    2. The angel fights the farmer.
    3. The boy escapes death by a clever last wish, not by using his gun.
    4. The police defeat the boy.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Although the boy has a gun that never misses, he saves himself by thinking: he asks to play the violin, and its music forces the court to free him.

  5. 5. Which is a typical feature of a folk tale found in this story?

    1. Exact dates and real place names for every event
    2. A magical helper in disguise who grants wishes
    3. A sad ending where evil wins
    4. Long scientific explanations
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The beggar who is really an angel granting two wishes is a classic folk-tale feature, along with magic objects and a happy ending.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery