• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Magic Violin: false charge, death sentence and freedom

Retell the last part of the story: the farmer's false complaint, the boy's death sentence, his last wish to play, the whole marketplace dancing, and how he wins back his silver and his freedom.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Retell the last part of the story in order.
  • Explain why the magistrate punished the boy and what the punishment was.
  • Explain how the boy got his silver and his freedom back.
  • Explain why the boy keeps playing as he walks away.

The farmer has lost his silver, and a miser cannot bear that. Instead of accepting his defeat, he turns to the law, and he lies. The story now becomes a matter of life and death.

The false complaint

As soon as the boy went on his way, the farmer ran ahead into the village and told the police that the boy was a thief. The magistrate (a judge in a local court) sent policemen, who quickly caught the boy carrying the thousand pieces of silver. In those days, the story tells us, the punishment for stealing in Sicily was death. It seemed impossible that such a poor boy could honestly have so much money, so he was sentenced to be hanged at once. Notice that no one asked how he came to have the money; his poverty itself was taken as proof.

The last wish

In the marketplace, before the hanging, the boy asked to play his violin one last time. The kind magistrate agreed. When the farmer saw the hangman hand back the violin, he cried out in alarm and begged the magistrate not to let the boy play. The magistrate only smiled; he thought a little music could do no harm and that the lad was too young to die. The boy began to play.

At once the magistrate, the hangman, the farmer and the whole crowd who had gathered to watch the hanging began to dance, and none of them could stop. The magistrate cried that he could not go on; the farmer offered the thousand pieces of silver if only the boy would stop; the hangman wailed that he would die. They danced until they looked like dead people dancing, with no strength left. At last the magistrate called out that the boy should go free: the farmer would give him the silver and the magistrate would give him his freedom.

The boy takes no chances

The boy agreed, but on his own terms. He told them to have the hangman fetch his gun and silver from the courthouse. The hangman danced all the way there and back. The boy had the gun tied to his belt and the money put in his pockets, saying that he no longer trusted anyone and would not stop playing until he had what was his and was too far away to be caught again. So he walked off, still playing, while the three of them danced in the marketplace until the music faded in the distance. Then they fell to the ground, exhausted. The boy went on to seek his fortune, with his violin, his gun and his thousand pieces of silver.

Part 3 in six steps

  1. Lie The farmer tells the police the boy is a thief.
  2. Sentence The magistrate orders him hanged, as stealing was punished by death.
  3. Last wish The boy asks to play his violin; the magistrate allows it.
  4. Dance Everyone in the marketplace dances and cannot stop.
  5. Freedom The magistrate frees him; the farmer gives the silver.
  6. Away He leaves playing, until he is too far to be caught.

Worked example 1: why was the boy punished?

Question: Why did the magistrate punish him? What was the punishment? Working: give the cause (the farmer's charge and the money found on him) and the punishment (death by hanging). Answer: the farmer falsely told the police the boy had stolen his thousand pieces of silver. The police found the silver on him, and since it seemed impossible for such a poor boy to own so much money, the magistrate believed he had stolen it. Theft was punished by death in Sicily at that time, so he was sentenced to be hanged at once.

Worked example 2: how did he get his silver and freedom back?

Question: How did the boy get the silver coins and his freedom back? Working: trace the steps from the last wish to the walk away. Answer: he asked to play his violin before being hanged. Its music made the magistrate, the hangman, the farmer and the crowd dance helplessly. Exhausted, the magistrate set him free and the farmer gave up the silver. The boy had his gun and money brought to him and kept playing until he was far away, so no one could catch him again.

The miser's lie leads to his own punishment: the farmer ends up dancing in the dust, and the boy walks away free.

Key takeaways: the farmer falsely accuses the boy, who is sentenced to death because a poor boy with silver looks like a thief. His last wish, to play the violin, makes the whole marketplace dance until he is freed and given the silver. Having learnt not to trust them, he plays until he is safely away.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What did the farmer tell the police?

    1. That the boy had run away with his goats
    2. That the boy had stolen his silver
    3. That the boy had a magic violin
    4. That the boy had shot his bird
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The farmer ran into the village and told the police that the boy was a thief, so they arrested him with the thousand pieces of silver.

  2. 2. Why did the magistrate believe the boy was a thief?

    1. The boy confessed.
    2. The angel accused him.
    3. It seemed impossible for such a poor boy to have so much money.
    4. A witness saw him break into the house.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The story says it seemed impossible for such a poor boy to have such a large sum. No one asked how he got it; his poverty was taken as proof.

  3. 3. Why did the farmer cry out in alarm when the boy was given the violin?

    1. He knew its music would make everyone dance.
    2. He wanted to play it himself.
    3. He thought it was stolen.
    4. He hated music.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The farmer had already been forced to dance by the violin, so he knew what would happen and begged the magistrate not to let the boy play.

  4. 4. Why did the boy keep playing the violin as he walked away?

    1. He wanted to entertain the town.
    2. He had forgotten how to stop.
    3. He wanted to tire himself out.
    4. He no longer trusted them and wanted to be too far away to be caught.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. He said he trusted no one any more and would keep playing until he had what was his and was too far away for them to catch him again.

  5. 5. What happened to the farmer, the magistrate and the hangman at the end?

    1. They became the boy's friends.
    2. They danced until the music died away and then fell to the ground, exhausted.
    3. They chased the boy out of Sicily.
    4. They were arrested.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. They kept dancing in the marketplace until the sound of the violin faded in the distance, then fell to the ground because they were so tired.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery