• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Answering questions and discussing The Bewitched Jacket

Write clear answers to the comprehension questions on the story, and argue the discussion topics: whether ill-gotten money makes a person happy, and whether mystery stories should be taught.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Answer the story's comprehension questions completely.
  • Write a discussion paragraph on ill-gotten money with examples.
  • Argue for and against teaching mystery stories.
  • Avoid common errors in answers on this story.

The book's exercises ask thirteen comprehension questions and two discussion questions on this story. The model answers below are written for this lesson; practise writing your own in your own words.

Comprehension answers

Worked example 1: model answers

  1. Why was the author not keen to wear the suit? Working: recall his feeling after visiting the tailor. Answer: The tailor's too-warm smiles had left him uneasy, and for reasons he could not explain he did not feel like wearing the suit for weeks.
  2. What did he find in the right pocket, and what happened next? Answer: He found a ten-thousand-lire note. Each time he put his hand in again, another note appeared, so he went home and drew out money until he had 58 million lire.
  3. What did he do with the money? Answer: He bought a huge villa, paintings and big cars, left his job and travelled the world.
  4. Was he happy after getting rid of the jacket? Why? Working: what did he lose, and how does he feel? Answer: No. All his wealth vanished, he had to work hard at his old job, and he lives in fear that the tailor will come to settle his account.

Discussion 1: Ill-gotten money does not make a person happy

Ill-gotten means gained by wrong or dishonest means. A strong answer explains why such money fails to bring happiness and supports the claim from the story and from life, using general examples rather than real names.

Why ill-gotten money brings no happiness

  • Guilt
    • The conscience is never at rest
    • The narrator cannot sleep after the fire
  • Fear
    • Of being found out
    • Of paying the price, as he fears the tailor
  • Greed
    • It is never enough
    • He keeps wanting more
  • It does not last
    • It can be lost suddenly
    • His wealth turns to dust

Model paragraph: 'Money gained by harming others cannot make a person happy. The narrator of The Bewitched Jacket has villas, cars and travel, yet he cannot sleep, he hides his secret from everyone, and he knows each note means someone else's loss. In real life too, a person who cheats may enjoy luxuries for a while, but lives in fear of being caught and loses the trust of others. Honest money may be less, but it lets us sleep in peace. True happiness comes from a clear conscience, not a full trunk.'

Discussion 2: Should mystery stories be taught?

Arguments in our own words.
Mystery stories are worth teachingSome objections
They make reading exciting and build the habit of reading.They show impossible events, like a magic pocket.
Readers learn to notice clues and think logically.Some may frighten young readers.
Many carry a serious moral, as this one does about greed.Time might be used for factual texts instead.
They train imagination and the skill of predicting.Readers may confuse fantasy with reality.

Worked example 2: a balanced conclusion

'It is true that a magic pocket is not sensible in a literal way. But a story need not be literally true to teach a true lesson. The Bewitched Jacket uses magic to show something very real: greed harms others and destroys the greedy. Mystery stories also make students eager to read on, notice clues and think. So I disagree with the statement: mystery stories should be taught, chosen with care for the age of the readers.' Working: the paragraph admits the objection, answers it with an example, adds two benefits and ends with a clear, qualified opinion.

A strong discussion answer: define the key term, give reasons with examples, answer the other side, conclude clearly.

Common mistakes: saying the narrator never knew where the money came from (he knew after the fire); saying he burned the jacket out of fear of police (it was the pensioner's death); and confusing the amounts (58 million with the robbery, 135 million with the fire). Key takeaways: answer every part of each question with details from the story, and in discussions weigh both sides before concluding.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What does 'ill-gotten money' mean?

    1. Money earned by hard work
    2. Money spent on medicine
    3. Money gained by wrong or dishonest means
    4. Money saved in a bank
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Ill-gotten means obtained wrongly. The narrator's money came from robbery, fire and a poor woman's lost pension.

  2. 2. Which is the best answer to 'Why did the author decide to destroy the jacket?'

    1. He decided to destroy it after a retired woman in his building killed herself over her lost pension, which he knew was now with him.
    2. Because.
    3. He was bored of the jacket.
    4. The tailor asked him to.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A full answer names the event that moved him and his realisation that he had the money. The others are incomplete or wrong.

  3. 3. Which point from the story supports 'Ill-gotten money does not make a person happy'?

    1. The suit fitted well
    2. The tailor had dyed hair
    3. He met a stranger at a party
    4. He could not sleep after reading about the fire
    Show answer

    Answer: D. His sleeplessness shows guilt and fear, so his wealth did not bring peace.

  4. 4. Which is an argument FOR teaching mystery stories?

    1. They are impossible
    2. They help readers notice clues and think logically
    3. They may frighten children
    4. They take time from factual texts
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Training readers to follow clues and reason is a benefit. The other three are objections.

  5. 5. Which statement would be a MISTAKE in an answer?

    1. The second sum was 135 million lire.
    2. A voice said 'Too late'.
    3. He never suspected any link between his money and the crimes.
    4. His villa disappeared.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. He did suspect a link after the robbery and was sure after the fire. The other statements match the story.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery