- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Early ideas and the two laws of chemical combination
Recall the early ideas of Maharishi Kanad and Democritus, state the law of conservation of mass and the law of constant proportions, and solve problems with each.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the early Indian and Greek ideas about the smallest particles of matter.
- State the law of conservation of mass and check reactions against it.
- State the law of constant (definite) proportions.
- Use a mass ratio to find how much of one element combines with another.
If you keep breaking a piece of chalk into smaller and smaller bits, is there a smallest bit that cannot be broken? Chapter 3 of the PSEB textbook (prepared by NCERT) starts with thinkers who asked this question long before laboratories existed, and then shows how two experimental laws led to the modern idea of atoms.
Early ideas about indivisible particles
According to the textbook, the idea of divisibility of matter was considered in India around 500 BC. The Indian philosopher Maharishi Kanad suggested that if matter (padarth) is divided again and again, we finally reach the smallest particles that cannot be divided further; he called them Parmanu. Another Indian philosopher, Pakudha Katyayana, added that these particles normally exist in combined forms, which give us the various kinds of matter.
Around the same era the Greek philosophers Democritus and Leucippus reached a similar idea. Democritus called the indivisible particles atoms, meaning 'indivisible'. These were ideas from reasoning, not experiment. By the end of the eighteenth century scientists could tell elements from compounds and began to study how elements combine. Antoine L. Lavoisier and Joseph L. Proust, after many experiments, established two laws of chemical combination.
Law of conservation of mass
In the textbook's activity, done as a teacher demonstration, a solution of one chemical (for example copper sulphate) is placed in a small ignition tube hung by a thread inside a conical flask containing a solution of another (for example sodium carbonate). The flask is corked and weighed. It is then tilted so the two solutions mix and react (a change can be seen), and it is weighed again. The mass does not change. The cork matters: if a gas formed and escaped from an open flask, the mass would appear to fall. (Some of the suggested chemicals, such as barium chloride and lead nitrate, are poisonous, so only the teacher handles them.)
Law of conservation of mass: mass can neither be created nor destroyed in a chemical reaction. Total mass of reactants = total mass of products.
Worked example 1: checking the law
Question: when 10.0 g of calcium carbonate is heated strongly, it forms 5.6 g of calcium oxide and some carbon dioxide gas escapes. What mass of carbon dioxide is formed? Working: by conservation of mass, mass of reactant = mass of products. 10.0 g = 5.6 g + mass of carbon dioxide, so carbon dioxide = 10.0 − 5.6 = 4.4 g. Check: 5.6 + 4.4 = 10.0 g.
Law of constant proportions
Scientists noticed that a given compound always contains the same elements in the same proportions by mass, whatever its source and whoever prepares it. In water, the mass of hydrogen to the mass of oxygen is always 1 : 8, so 9 g of water always gives 1 g of hydrogen and 8 g of oxygen. In ammonia, nitrogen and hydrogen are always in the ratio 14 : 3 by mass. Proust stated this as the law of constant proportions (also called the law of definite proportions): in a chemical substance, the elements are always present in definite proportions by mass.
Worked example 2: using the water ratio
Question: what mass of oxygen combines completely with 2.5 g of hydrogen to form water, and how much water forms? Working: hydrogen : oxygen = 1 : 8, so oxygen = 8 × 2.5 = 20 g. Water formed = 2.5 + 20 = 22.5 g (conservation of mass). Check: 2.5 : 20 = 1 : 8.
Worked example 3: when one reactant is in excess
Question: carbon and oxygen combine in the ratio 3 : 8 by mass to form carbon dioxide. If 6 g of carbon is burnt in 30 g of oxygen, how much carbon dioxide forms and how much oxygen is left? Working: 6 g of carbon needs (8 ÷ 3) × 6 = 16 g of oxygen. Only 16 g of the 30 g reacts, so carbon dioxide = 6 + 16 = 22 g, and 30 − 16 = 14 g of oxygen is left unused. The fixed ratio (law of constant proportions) decides how much reacts, and conservation of mass gives the product. Check: 22 + 14 = 36 g = 6 + 30 g.
From ideas to theory
- Kanad, Democritus Smallest indivisible particles, by reasoning
- Lavoisier, Proust Two laws from experiments
- Dalton (1808) Atomic theory explains both laws
Key takeaways: early thinkers imagined indivisible particles (Parmanu, atoms). Experiments gave two laws: the total mass does not change in a reaction, and a compound always has its elements in a fixed ratio by mass. Use the ratio to find how much reacts; use conservation to find the product. In lesson 2 we see how Dalton explained these laws.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who gave the name Parmanu to the smallest indivisible particles of matter?
- Democritus
- Maharishi Kanad
- John Dalton
- Antoine Lavoisier
Show answer
Answer: B. The Indian philosopher Maharishi Kanad suggested that repeated division of matter ends in the smallest particles, which he called Parmanu. Democritus called them atoms.
-
2. In a closed flask, 4.2 g of substance A reacts with 3.6 g of substance B. Two products form; one has a mass of 5.0 g. What is the mass of the other?
- 7.8 g
- 1.4 g
- 2.8 g
- 0.6 g
Show answer
Answer: C. Total mass of reactants = 4.2 + 3.6 = 7.8 g. By conservation of mass, products also total 7.8 g, so the other product = 7.8 − 5.0 = 2.8 g.
-
3. Hydrogen and oxygen combine in the ratio 1 : 8 by mass to form water. How much oxygen is needed for 4 g of hydrogen?
- 32 g
- 8 g
- 2 g
- 36 g
Show answer
Answer: A. Oxygen = 8 × mass of hydrogen = 8 × 4 = 32 g. The water formed would be 4 + 32 = 36 g.
-
4. Why is the flask corked in the conservation-of-mass demonstration?
- To keep the solutions warm
- To make the reaction faster
- To stop light entering
- So that no gas or vapour escapes and changes the mass
Show answer
Answer: D. If any gas formed and escaped, the flask would weigh less and the law would seem to fail. A closed flask keeps all the reactants and products inside.
-
5. Ammonia always has nitrogen and hydrogen in the ratio 14 : 3 by mass, whatever its source. This is an example of
- the law of conservation of mass
- the law of constant proportions
- diffusion
- sublimation
Show answer
Answer: B. A fixed ratio by mass of the elements in a compound, independent of source, is the law of constant (definite) proportions stated by Proust.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.