- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Charged particles in matter and Thomson's model of the atom
Explain why rubbing objects shows that atoms contain charged particles, describe the electron and the proton, and state Thomson's model of the atom with its strengths and limits.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why static electricity tells us that atoms are divisible.
- Describe canal rays and how they led to the proton.
- Compare the charge and mass of an electron and a proton.
- State the two points of Thomson's model of the atom.
- Say what Thomson's model explained and what it could not.
In Chapter 3 of the PSEB textbook (prepared by NCERT) you met Dalton's idea that atoms are the smallest, indivisible particles of matter. Chapter 4 asks two sharper questions: what makes an atom of one element different from an atom of another, and is the atom really indivisible? The answer begins with something you have seen many times: a plastic comb that picks up bits of paper after you run it through dry hair.
Clues from static electricity
When two different materials are rubbed together, both become electrically charged. A plastic scale rubbed on dry hair, or a glass rod rubbed with silk, can attract light objects such as paper scraps or a balloon. Rubbing does not create matter, so the charge must already be present inside the materials. This shows that the atom is divisible: it contains smaller particles that carry electric charge, and some of them can be moved from one object to another.
Safe classroom demonstration (teacher-supervised): the teacher rubs a plastic ruler on dry hair or a woollen cloth and holds it just above small torn pieces of paper; the pieces jump up and cling to it. Next, a glass rod rubbed with silk is brought near a hanging inflated balloon, and the balloon moves towards it. Students only watch and note the result; nothing hot, sharp or electrical is used.
Sub-atomic particles: electron and proton
By about 1900 scientists knew that the atom contained at least one smaller particle, the electron, identified by J.J. Thomson. Even earlier, in 1886, E. Goldstein observed new rays in a gas discharge tube which he called canal rays. Canal rays are positively charged radiations, and they led to the discovery of a second particle, the proton.
| Particle | Symbol | Relative charge | Relative mass |
|---|---|---|---|
| Electron | e⁻ | −1 | negligible (about 1/2000 of a proton) |
| Proton | p⁺ | +1 | 1 unit |
The proton's charge is equal in size to the electron's but opposite in sign, and its mass is roughly 2000 times the electron's (the accurate figure is about 1836 times). Electrons can be removed from atoms fairly easily, as rubbing shows, but protons cannot. This suggested that protons sit deep in the interior of the atom while electrons are towards the outside.
Worked example 1: is the atom charged?
Question: An atom contains one electron and one proton. Does it carry a net charge? Working: charge of proton = +1, charge of electron = −1. Net charge = (+1) + (−1) = 0. The atom is neutral. (This is a hydrogen atom.)
Worked example 2: counting charges
Question: A particle has 11 protons and 10 electrons. What is its net charge? Working: total positive charge = +11, total negative charge = −10. Net = +11 − 10 = +1. The particle has lost one electron, so it is a positive ion, not a neutral atom.
Thomson's model of the atom
Once electrons and protons were known, Dalton's idea of an indivisible atom failed, and scientists had to work out how these particles are arranged. J.J. Thomson gave the first model. He pictured the atom like a Christmas pudding, with electrons scattered through it like dry fruits. A watermelon gives the same picture: the red flesh is the spread-out positive charge and the seeds are the electrons fixed in it.
- An atom is a sphere of positive charge, and the electrons are embedded in it.
- The total positive and negative charges are equal in magnitude, so the atom as a whole is electrically neutral.
Thomson's model: what it did and did not do
-
Explained
- Why an atom is neutral overall
- That the atom contains electrons
- That positive charge balances negative charge
-
Could not explain
- Results of later experiments, such as alpha-particle scattering
- Where the positive charge and mass are concentrated
- Why a few fast particles bounce back from a thin foil
Thomson's model: electrons embedded in a uniform sphere of positive charge; equal positive and negative charges make the atom neutral.
J.J. Thomson (1856-1940), a British physicist, received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1906 for discovering the electron.
Key takeaways: rubbing produces charge, which proves that atoms contain charged particles. The electron (charge −1, very light) was identified by Thomson; canal rays discovered by Goldstein led to the proton (charge +1, mass 1 unit). Thomson's 'pudding' or 'watermelon' model explained why atoms are neutral, but, as the next lesson shows, it failed an important experiment.
Check your understanding
-
1. A comb run through dry hair attracts bits of paper. What does this tell us about atoms?
- Atoms are indivisible
- Atoms contain charged particles that can be transferred
- Atoms are created by rubbing
- Paper contains only protons
Show answer
Answer: B. Rubbing cannot create matter, so the charge must come from charged particles already inside atoms that move between the comb and the hair. This shows atoms are divisible.
-
2. Canal rays discovered by Goldstein are:
- Negatively charged radiations
- Uncharged radiations
- Positively charged radiations
- Beams of neutrons
Show answer
Answer: C. Goldstein's canal rays carried positive charge, and they led to the discovery of the proton.
-
3. An ion has 8 protons and 10 electrons. What is its net charge?
- −2
- +2
- 0
- −18
Show answer
Answer: A. Net charge = +8 + (−10) = −2. It has gained two electrons.
-
4. In Thomson's model, the seeds of a watermelon stand for:
- Protons
- The nucleus
- Neutrons
- Electrons
Show answer
Answer: D. The red flesh is the spread-out positive charge; the seeds embedded in it are the electrons.
-
5. Why did the discovery of electrons and protons go against Dalton's atomic theory?
- It showed atoms have no mass
- It showed that the atom is made of smaller particles, so it is not indivisible
- It showed that atoms of one element differ in charge
- It proved that atoms are positively charged
Show answer
Answer: B. Dalton said atoms cannot be divided. Finding particles inside the atom showed that this part of his theory was wrong.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.