• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Rutherford's alpha-particle scattering experiment and nuclear model

Describe Rutherford's gold foil experiment, link each observation to its conclusion, state the features of his nuclear model and explain why that model could not be stable.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the set-up of the alpha-particle scattering experiment.
  • List its three observations and the conclusion drawn from each.
  • State the features of Rutherford's nuclear model.
  • Explain the main drawback of the model.

Thomson's model spread positive charge evenly through the atom. Ernest Rutherford wanted to know how the particles are really arranged, so he fired tiny, fast 'bullets' at a sheet of gold and watched where they went. The surprising result changed our picture of the atom for ever.

The experiment

  • Projectiles: alpha (α) particles. They are doubly charged helium ions (charge +2) with a mass of 4 u, so when moving fast they carry a lot of energy.
  • Target: a very thin gold foil. Gold was chosen because it can be beaten into an extremely thin sheet; the foil was about 1000 atoms thick.
  • Expectation: if Thomson were right, the positive charge would be spread thinly, and the heavy alpha particles would pass with only small deflections.

Rutherford's experiment in steps

  1. Source sends fast alpha particles Positively charged, mass 4 u
  2. Particles strike a thin gold foil About 1000 atoms thick
  3. A screen around the foil records them Each hit shows where a particle went
  4. Deflections are counted Straight through, slightly bent or bounced back

Observations and conclusions

Linking what was seen to what it means
ObservationConclusion
Most alpha particles passed straight through the foilMost of the space inside an atom is empty
Some were deflected through small anglesThe positive charge occupies only a very small part of the atom
A very few (the textbook says about one in 12000) bounced back, turning through about 180°All the positive charge and almost all the mass are packed into a tiny volume at the centre

Rutherford compared the bounce-back to firing a large artillery shell at tissue paper and having it return. From his data he also worked out that the radius of the nucleus is about 10⁵ times smaller than the radius of the atom.

Picture it: if a blindfolded child throws stones at a solid wall, every stone hits and makes a sound. If the same child throws at a barbed-wire fence, most stones pass through the gaps and only a rare one hits a wire. The gold atoms behaved like the fence, not the wall.

Worked example 1: scaling the atom

Question: Using the textbook's figure that the atom's radius is about 10⁵ times the nucleus's radius, how big would the atom be if the nucleus were a 1 cm marble? Working: atom radius ≈ 1 cm × 10⁵ = 100 000 cm = 1000 m = 1 km. A marble-sized nucleus would sit inside an atom about 1 km in radius, which is why the atom is mostly empty space.

Worked example 2: reading a result

Question: In a made-up repeat of the experiment, 24 000 alpha particles hit the foil and 2 bounce back. Is this consistent with a tiny nucleus? Working: fraction bouncing back = 2 ÷ 24 000 = 1 in 12 000. Only a tiny fraction meets the nucleus head-on, so yes: a very small, dense, positive centre is the explanation. (The numbers are invented for practice.)

Rutherford's nuclear model

  1. There is a positively charged centre in the atom called the nucleus; nearly all the mass of the atom is in it.
  2. The electrons revolve around the nucleus in circular paths.
  3. The nucleus is very small compared with the size of the atom.

Drawback of the model

A body moving in a circle is constantly changing direction, so it is accelerating. Physics tells us that an accelerating charged particle radiates energy. A revolving electron would therefore lose energy, spiral inwards and fall into the nucleus. Atoms would be unstable and matter as we know it could not exist. Since atoms are clearly stable, the model needed correcting.

Rutherford: tiny, heavy, positive nucleus + electrons revolving around it + mostly empty space. Weakness: a revolving electron should radiate energy and fall into the nucleus.

Ernest Rutherford (1871-1937) is often called the father of nuclear physics; he received the Nobel Prize in Chemistry in 1908 for his work on radioactivity.

Key takeaways: most alpha particles passing straight through showed empty space; small deflections and rare rebounds showed a tiny, dense, positive nucleus. Rutherford's nuclear model placed electrons in orbits around it, but could not explain why atoms are stable.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Most alpha particles passed straight through the gold foil. What did Rutherford conclude from this?

    1. Gold atoms have no electrons
    2. Most of the space inside the atom is empty
    3. The nucleus is very large
    4. Alpha particles have no charge
    Show answer

    Answer: B. If particles meet nothing on their way, the atom must be mostly empty space.

  2. 2. Alpha particles used in the experiment are:

    1. Fast electrons
    2. Neutral hydrogen atoms
    3. Gold ions
    4. Doubly charged helium ions of mass 4 u
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook describes alpha particles as doubly charged helium ions with a mass of 4 u.

  3. 3. Which observation shows that almost all the mass and positive charge are concentrated in a tiny volume?

    1. A very few particles bounced back
    2. Most particles passed straight through
    3. The foil became warm
    4. The foil was 1000 atoms thick
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Only a very heavy, highly concentrated positive centre could turn a fast alpha particle right back.

  4. 4. Why was Rutherford's model expected to be unstable?

    1. The nucleus would repel the electrons
    2. Electrons have no mass
    3. A revolving electron accelerates, radiates energy and should fall into the nucleus
    4. Protons would escape from the nucleus
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Circular motion is accelerated motion; an accelerated charge radiates energy, so the electron would lose energy and spiral into the nucleus.

  5. 5. Why did Rutherford choose a gold foil?

    1. Gold is the only metal with a nucleus
    2. Gold can be made into an extremely thin layer
    3. Gold has no electrons
    4. Gold attracts alpha particles
    Show answer

    Answer: B. He wanted as thin a layer as possible, and gold can be beaten very thin (about 1000 atoms thick).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery