- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Independent judiciary, judicial review and why the rights are fundamental
Describe the provisions that keep the judiciary independent, explain judicial review, note the role of human rights commissions, and give the reasons the textbook offers for calling these rights fundamental.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List the provisions that keep India's judiciary free and fearless.
- Explain the power of judicial review.
- Say what human rights commissions do.
- Explain why Fundamental Rights are called fundamental.
Rights are only as strong as the courts that protect them. If judges could be removed or punished for an unpopular ruling, no one would dare to rule against the government. So the Constitution makes the judiciary independent - free from pressure, so that judges give justice without fear.
Provisions for an independent judiciary
- Appointment: Supreme Court judges are appointed by the President after consulting the Chief Justice of India (and other judges as needed); only persons with the qualifications laid down in the Constitution can be appointed.
- Security of tenure: a Supreme Court judge serves until 65. Removal is possible only for proved misbehaviour or incapacity, by the President, after each House of Parliament passes a motion by a majority of its total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting.
- Salary protected: judges' salaries and allowances cannot be reduced to their disadvantage during their term.
- Consolidated Fund: their salaries are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India and are not put to the vote of Parliament.
- Powers: the textbook says Parliament can add to the Supreme Court's powers but not reduce them.
- No practice after retirement: a retired Supreme Court judge cannot plead or act in any court or before any authority in India.
- Own staff: the Supreme Court appoints its staff and sets their conditions of service.
- Contempt: the Supreme Court can punish anyone for contempt of court.
The textbook credits the judges' wisdom and courage with securing the rule of law in India. It also notes that the National Human Rights Commission was set up in 1993, and State Human Rights Commissions in the states, to guard against violations of human rights. (The textbook says December 1993; the Commission itself dates its founding to 12 October 1993.)
Judicial review
Judicial review is the power of the courts to examine laws made by the legislature and orders of the executive, and to declare them null and void if they go against the Constitution. The textbook gives two reasons the Supreme Court has this power: India has a federal system, so someone must keep the Centre and states within their own fields, and the Constitution contains Fundamental Rights that must be protected from misuse of power.
How judicial review protects a right
- A law or order is made
- A citizen says it violates a right
- Petition in the Supreme Court or High Court
- Court tests it against the Constitution
- If unconstitutional, declared void
Why are Fundamental Rights 'fundamental'?
- They are essential for the all-round development of citizens.
- They are written into the Constitution itself.
- The Constitution gives an effective way to enforce them; a law or ordinance that violates them can be struck down.
- The Right to Constitutional Remedies is itself a Fundamental Right.
- Parliament cannot change them by ordinary law. (They can be changed only by a constitutional amendment, and the Supreme Court has held that even an amendment cannot destroy the Constitution's basic structure.)
The chapter ends with some important human rights - such as the right to live with dignity, to earn a livelihood, to fair wages and rest, to a fair trial, to personal liberty and to protection against torture.
Judicial review: the courts can declare any law or order void if it violates the Constitution.
Worked example 1: applying judicial review
Made-up case: A state passes a law that only people born in that state may open shops there. A citizen from another state challenges it. Reasoning: Step 1 - Article 15 bars discrimination by place of birth and Article 19 gives every citizen freedom to carry on trade anywhere in India. Step 2 - the court tests the law against these. Step 3 - it conflicts with them. Answer: The court can declare the law void through judicial review.
Worked example 2: why salary protection matters
Question: Why are judges' salaries charged on the Consolidated Fund and not voted by Parliament? Reasoning: If Parliament voted on them every year, a government unhappy with a ruling could threaten to cut them. Answer: It removes a means of pressure, so judges can decide without fear.
Key takeaways: The judiciary is kept independent through careful appointment, tenure to 65, difficult removal, protected salaries charged on the Consolidated Fund, a ban on practice after retirement and the power to punish contempt. Judicial review lets courts strike down unconstitutional laws. Fundamental Rights are fundamental because they are essential, written in the Constitution, enforceable and protected from ordinary law.
Check your understanding
-
1. Up to what age can a judge of the Supreme Court serve?
- 60 years
- 62 years
- 65 years
- 70 years
Show answer
Answer: C. A Supreme Court judge holds office until the age of 65.
-
2. Judicial review means the power of courts to:
- declare a law or order void if it violates the Constitution
- make new laws for the country
- appoint ministers
- conduct elections
Show answer
Answer: A. Under judicial review the courts test laws and orders against the Constitution and can declare unconstitutional ones null and void.
-
3. Why are judges' salaries charged on the Consolidated Fund of India?
- So that judges earn more than ministers
- So that states pay them
- So that Parliament can cut them easily
- So that they are not put to Parliament's vote, protecting judges from pressure
Show answer
Answer: D. Charged expenditure is not voted on, so the legislature cannot use salaries to pressure judges.
-
4. On which grounds can a Supreme Court judge be removed?
- Giving a ruling against the government
- Proved misbehaviour or incapacity
- Reaching 60 years
- A complaint by one minister
Show answer
Answer: B. Only proved misbehaviour or incapacity, after a special-majority motion in each House, can lead to removal.
-
5. Which is one reason the textbook gives for calling these rights 'fundamental'?
- They are written in the Constitution and can be enforced in courts
- They can be changed by any ordinary law
- They apply only during elections
- They were granted by the British in 1935
Show answer
Answer: A. They are part of the Constitution, are essential for development, and are enforceable through the Right to Constitutional Remedies; ordinary law cannot take them away.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.