• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

What rights are and how India won Fundamental Rights

Define a right and its three qualities, explain why rights are needed, recall how political thinkers defined rights, and trace the demand for Fundamental Rights from 1895 to Part III of the Constitution.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define a right and name its three qualities.
  • Explain why rights are necessary for a person and for society.
  • Recall the ideas of Laski, Wilde, Bosanquet and T.H. Green about rights.
  • Trace the demand for Fundamental Rights in the freedom movement.

Think of the things you do every day without asking anyone's permission: you speak your mind, travel to another town, follow your faith, celebrate festivals with your family. These freedoms exist because society and the state accept them. Such accepted freedoms are called rights.

What is a right?

The PSEB textbook describes rights as genuine demands of an individual or a group that are recognised by society and by the state. A right has three qualities:

  1. It is a reasonable claim made by a person.
  2. The claim is recognised by society - it does not harm the common good.
  3. It has political (legal) recognition - the state accepts and protects it.

A claim that society accepts but the state does not enforce remains only a moral claim. Rights and duties go together: my right to speak freely carries the duty to let others speak too. No one can claim a 'right' that works against the welfare of the whole society.

Why rights are needed

Imagine someone who cannot speak freely, move about, choose work or follow a religion. Such a person cannot develop mentally or physically. Rights are needed for the all-round development of a person, and since society is made of individuals, a nation progresses only when its people are free to grow.

How thinkers defined rights

Definitions of rights quoted in the textbook (in summary)
ThinkerMain idea
Harold LaskiRights are the conditions of social life without which no one can be at their best.
WildeA right is a reasonable claim to freedom in carrying out certain activities.
BosanquetA right is a claim recognised by society and enforced by the state.
T.H. GreenRights are the powers a person needs to fulfil their purpose as a moral being.

The demand for Fundamental Rights

Before independence, Indians had no guaranteed rights. The demand grew during the freedom movement, as the textbook narrates:

From demand to Part III

  1. 1895: Swaraj Bill The textbook links it to Bal Gangadhar Tilak: freedom of expression, equality before law
  2. 1928: Nehru Report Demanded rights including equal rights for men and women
  3. 1935: Government of India Act British left out any list of rights
  4. 1946: Cabinet Mission Recommended Fundamental Rights
  5. Constituent Assembly Advisory committee and sub-committee drafted them
  6. Part III of the Constitution Fundamental Rights included

The textbook adds that the democratic nature of a country can be judged from the fundamental rights its citizens enjoy, and that the idea of listing them in the Constitution was taken from the Constitution of the USA (its Bill of Rights).

A right = a reasonable claim + recognised by society + recognised and protected by the state. Fundamental Rights are in Part III of the Constitution.

Worked example 1: is it a right?

Question: A man says he has a right to play loud music at 2 a.m. in a crowded street. Is this a right? Reasoning: Step 1 - is it reasonable? It disturbs many people's sleep. Step 2 - would society recognise it? No, it harms the common good. Step 3 - would the state protect it? Noise laws restrict it. Answer: It fails all three tests, so it is not a right.

Worked example 2: matching a thinker

Question: Which thinker's definition stresses both social recognition and state enforcement? Reasoning: Laski speaks of conditions for being one's best; Green of moral purpose; Wilde of a reasonable claim to freedom. Only Bosanquet names both society and the state. Answer: Bosanquet.

Key takeaways: A right is a reasonable claim recognised by society and protected by the state; rights and duties go together. Rights are needed for all-round development. The demand for rights ran from the Swaraj Bill (1895) and the Nehru Report (1928) to the Cabinet Mission (1946), and Fundamental Rights were placed in Part III of the Constitution.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which is NOT one of the three qualities of a right described in the textbook?

    1. It is a reasonable claim
    2. It is recognised by society
    3. It is granted only to the rich
    4. It has political recognition
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A right is a reasonable claim, recognised by society and by the state. It is never limited to one class of people.

  2. 2. 'A right is a claim recognised by society and enforced by the state.' This definition is given by:

    1. Bosanquet
    2. Laski
    3. T.H. Green
    4. Wilde
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Bosanquet's definition stresses both recognition by society and enforcement by the state.

  3. 3. In which document did the demand for equal rights for men and women come up in 1928?

    1. Swaraj Bill
    2. Government of India Act
    3. Cabinet Mission Plan
    4. Nehru Report
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook says the Nehru Report of 1928 raised the demand for equal rights for men and women.

  4. 4. In which part of the Constitution are the Fundamental Rights placed?

    1. Part I
    2. Part III
    3. Part IV
    4. Part XV
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Fundamental Rights are in Part III. Part IV has the Directive Principles of State Policy.

  5. 5. A claim that society accepts but the state does not recognise remains:

    1. a fundamental right
    2. a legal duty
    3. only a moral claim
    4. a constitutional amendment
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Without political recognition a claim is only moral; state recognition is what makes it a right that can be protected.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery