- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Democracy at the international level
Describe how the UN General Assembly, Security Council, IMF and World Bank take decisions, judge whether they work democratically, and explain the textbook's concerns about powerful countries and multinational companies.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain that there is no world government, only international organisations.
- Describe the UN General Assembly and Security Council and the veto power.
- Explain how voting works in the IMF and the World Bank.
- Give the textbook's view on democracy imposed by force and on multinational companies.
Many countries are now democracies. But is the world as a whole run democratically? There is no world government that can give orders to every country. Instead, some international organisations work to keep peace and security, give financial help to poor countries, protect the environment, stop one country from attacking another unjustly and promote social equality. This lesson asks whether these organisations themselves work democratically.
The United Nations
The United Nations Organisation (UNO) was set up on 24 October 1945 with 51 member countries; India is a founder member. According to the textbook, 193 countries are members. Its parliament is the General Assembly, where every member country has one vote of equal value and all members discuss the world's problems. The Assembly's sessions are presided over by its elected head (the textbook calls this person the chairman; the UN's title is President of the General Assembly). The Secretariat is headed by the Secretary-General. In this sense the General Assembly looks democratic.
But the General Assembly cannot decide what action to take in a conflict between countries. That power lies with the Security Council, which has the main responsibility for keeping international peace and security and can call on armed forces supplied by members to repel an aggressor.
UN Security Council: 15 members
-
5 permanent members
Hold the veto power
- United States of America
- Britain (United Kingdom)
- China
- France
- Russia
-
10 non-permanent members
Elected by the General Assembly for two years
- India has served as a non-permanent member many times
Veto means the power to say no. A single 'no' from any one of the five permanent members stops a proposal from being approved, however many others support it.
The IMF and the World Bank
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) aims to promote international monetary cooperation. In the IMF the members do not have equal votes: each country's vote is weighed by how much money it has contributed. According to the textbook, the IMF had 188 members, and ten countries - the USA, Japan, Germany, France, the UK, China, Italy, Saudi Arabia, Canada and Russia - held about 52 per cent of the voting power, leaving the rest with only a small role. The World Bank works on a similar system, and the textbook notes that its head has always been a citizen of the USA.
| Body | Voting rule | Equal say for all? |
|---|---|---|
| UN General Assembly | One country, one vote | Yes |
| UN Security Council | Any permanent member can veto | No |
| IMF and World Bank | Votes weighed by money contributed | No |
Are these bodies democratic?
The textbook asks us to imagine a cabinet in which five ministers can cancel any decision, or a parliament in which some members' votes count more than others. We would not call these democratic. By the same test, most global institutions fall short of democratic principles. The textbook adds that while nations are becoming more democratic, these organisations are becoming less so: after the break-up of the USSR in 1991 the balance between two great powers ended, and in its view the dominance of the USA now affects how international organisations work.
Democracy by force, and multinational companies
The textbook argues that establishing democracy through violence or military attack goes against the principle of democracy itself. Its example is Iraq, which became free of British rule in 1932. Saddam Hussein became President in 1979 and, the textbook says, ran a dictatorial government in which opponents and ethnic minorities suffered, though women gained some rights, including the vote. The USA and Britain accused Iraq of holding nuclear and other destructive weapons; a UN team found no evidence of them. Even so, the USA and its allies invaded Iraq in 2003, removed Saddam and installed a government of their choice. The textbook calls this action undemocratic and says the UN's chief called it illegal.
The textbook also warns about multinational companies. Under open markets and globalisation they do business in developing countries with the aim of maximum profit. In the textbook's view, they can make services costlier, shape government policies in their own favour and widen the gap between rich and poor. It calls for world public opinion against such domination, and notes that home-grown (swadeshi) companies keep jobs and income in the country.
One country, one vote of equal value is democratic. A veto for a few, or votes weighed by money, is not.
Worked example 1: the power of a veto
Question: A Security Council proposal gets 14 votes in favour, but France votes against it. Is it passed? Reasoning: Step 1 - France is a permanent member. Step 2 - a single 'no' from a permanent member is a veto. Answer: No. The proposal fails, even with 14 of 15 members in favour.
Worked example 2: counting the Security Council
Question: How many Security Council members do not have the veto? Working: Total members 15 - permanent members 5 = 10 non-permanent members, elected for two years, with no veto.
Key takeaways: There is no world government. The UN (24 October 1945, India a founder member) has a General Assembly with one vote per country, but the Security Council's five permanent members (USA, UK, China, France, Russia) hold a veto. In the IMF and World Bank votes are weighed by money. By democratic tests these bodies fall short. The textbook says democracy imposed by force, as in Iraq in 2003, is undemocratic, and warns that multinational companies can threaten democracy.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these countries does NOT have the veto power in the UN Security Council?
- USA
- India
- France
- China
Show answer
Answer: B. The five permanent members with veto power are the USA, Britain, China, France and Russia. India has served many times as a non-permanent member, which has no veto.
-
2. When was the United Nations Organisation established?
- 24 October 1945
- 15 August 1947
- 1 September 1939
- 26 January 1950
Show answer
Answer: A. The UNO was set up on 24 October 1945 with 51 members, India among them.
-
3. Why is the IMF not considered democratic in its voting?
- It has no member countries
- Only the Secretary-General votes
- Each country's vote is weighed by the money it has contributed
- It never holds votes
Show answer
Answer: C. In the IMF members do not have equal votes. A country's vote depends on how much money it has contributed, so a few rich countries hold most of the voting power.
-
4. For how long are the non-permanent members of the Security Council elected?
- One year
- Five years
- For life
- Two years
Show answer
Answer: D. The ten non-permanent members are elected by the General Assembly for two years each.
-
5. What is the textbook's view of establishing democracy in another country by military attack?
- It is against the principle of democracy
- It is the best way to spread democracy
- It is required by the UN
- It is democratic if a powerful country does it
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook argues that setting up democracy by violent means goes against democracy's own principle, and calls the 2003 invasion of Iraq undemocratic.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.