• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Ruling systems and democracy in the ancient and medieval world

Name the main ruling systems, describe democracy in ancient Greece and Rome, explain the Chola village system of self-rule, and say why the medieval feudal age had no democracy.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Name the different ruling systems the world has known.
  • Explain direct democracy in the Greek city-states and its limits.
  • Describe how the Chola kingdom ran its villages through elected committees.
  • Explain what feudalism was and why it left no room for democracy.

Over thousands of years people have been ruled in many different ways. The PSEB textbook lists monarchy (rule by a king or queen), authoritarian rule, totalitarian rule, dictatorship and military dictatorship. Today, however, is called the age of democracy: it has become the most popular form of government, and even countries that are not fully democratic like to call themselves democratic. This chapter traces how democracy grew, where it slipped back, and how it spread across the world.

The textbook makes one test clear from the start: a country where no opposition party is allowed cannot truly be called a democracy, even if it holds regular elections. Keep this test in mind through the whole chapter.

Democracy in ancient Greece and Rome

Historians generally regard the Greek city-state of Athens as the first well-known democracy. The Greek city-states were small, with few people, so citizens could gather together and decide matters directly. This is called direct democracy. Citizens took part in making laws, framing public policy and passing the yearly budget of the state.

But it was a limited democracy. A large part of the population were slaves, and they had no say at all in running the state. Women and foreigners were also kept out. In the Roman state, the textbook says, the ruler was in theory chosen by and representative of the people, but in practice he ran the administration as he wished.

Ancient India: self-rule in the Chola villages

In some parts of ancient India the idea of self-rule (Swaraj) at the local level was practised. The textbook's main example is the Chola kingdom of South India. To run the administration well, the Chola kings divided the kingdom into smaller and smaller units, and these units were given real powers of their own.

Chola administrative units (largest to smallest)

  • Mandalam The largest unit, like a province
  • Valanadu A division of a Mandalam
  • Nadu A district-sized unit
  • Ur The village: the smallest unit
The Ur was the smallest unit, like a village of today.

Work was shared out through committees, a method the textbook calls the Variyam system. There were separate committees for tax, for cleanliness, for water supply and for giving justice. The Ur had a committee of 30 members, elected for one year by the adults of the village. The village was divided into 30 wards, and one member came from each ward.

How a Chola village member was chosen

The palm-leaf draw (Kudavolai)

  1. Ward proposes names Residents put forward more than one person
  2. Names on palm leaves Each name is written on a leaf
  3. Leaves in a container All the leaves are mixed together
  4. A child draws The child picks the leaves without looking
  5. Members chosen Those whose names are drawn serve for one year

This method is known as Kudavolai (the textbook spells it 'Kodu Blai'); the word joins the Tamil words for a pot and a palm leaf. Committee meetings were held in the temple or under shady trees. Even so, the textbook concludes that a full democratic system was not established in ancient India: this was self-government at village level inside a kingdom.

The medieval age: feudalism

According to the textbook, the medieval period in Europe runs from the 5th to the 15th century, and in India from the 7th to the 18th century. Its main system was feudalism, a social and economic arrangement built on land.

How feudalism worked

  1. King Gives land to feudal lords
  2. Feudal lords Give the king money and soldiers in return
  3. Tenants Work the land and keep only a small share of its produce

The common man had no rights, and the textbook describes the feudal lords as cruel and calls this period a 'dark era' with no sign of democracy. Towards its end the Renaissance began, but conditions still favoured the feudal lords.

Direct democracy works only in small states: Greek citizens decided matters themselves, but slaves had no voice. The Chola Ur chose 30 members, one from each ward, by drawing palm leaves.

Worked example 1: was Athens a full democracy?

Question: A classmate says, 'Ancient Greece gave every person a vote, so it was a perfect democracy.' Is this right? Reasoning: Step 1 - in the city-states citizens did decide laws and budgets directly, so there was democracy. Step 2 - but slaves, a large part of the population, had no say. Step 3 - a democracy that leaves out a large group is limited. Answer: No. It was a direct but limited democracy.

Worked example 2: counting the Ur committee

Question: If an Ur had 30 wards and each ward sent one member, how many members did the committee have, and for how long did they serve? Working: 30 wards x 1 member = 30 members, chosen for one year. This matches the textbook's description of the Ur committee.

Key takeaways: Many ruling systems have existed, but democracy is the most popular today. Greek city-states had direct but limited democracy; Rome's ruler acted as he pleased in practice. The Chola kingdom ran its villages through elected committees (Variyam) chosen by a palm-leaf draw (Kudavolai). Medieval feudalism gave the common man no rights.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why was the democracy of the Greek city-states called a limited democracy?

    1. Its citizens could not pass the budget
    2. Slaves, a large part of the population, had no say
    3. Only the king could make laws
    4. Elections were held only once in a lifetime
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Citizens took part directly in laws, policy and the budget, but slaves, who formed a large part of the population, were kept out of all administrative matters. That is why it was limited.

  2. 2. Which was the smallest administrative unit in the Chola kingdom?

    1. Mandalam
    2. Valanadu
    3. Nadu
    4. Ur
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The units in descending order were Mandalam, Valanadu, Nadu and Ur. The Ur was the smallest, like a village of today.

  3. 3. How was a member of the Ur committee finally chosen in the Chola system?

    1. A child drew palm leaves carrying candidates' names
    2. The king appointed him
    3. The eldest man of the ward became member
    4. The temple priest selected him
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Names proposed by each ward were written on palm leaves and mixed together; a child drew the leaves, and the persons whose names were drawn became members. This was the Kudavolai system.

  4. 4. In feudalism, what did the feudal lords give the king in return for land?

    1. Votes in the assembly
    2. Nothing at all
    3. Economic and military help
    4. A share of foreign trade
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The king distributed land to feudal lords and took economic and military help from them in return. The lords in turn gave land to tenants.

  5. 5. Why does the textbook say there was no democracy in the medieval period?

    1. Kings were elected every year
    2. The common man had no rights and feudal lords dominated
    3. Village committees ruled the whole country
    4. Slavery had ended everywhere
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Under feudalism the common man had no rights and power lay with the king and cruel feudal lords, so the textbook calls it a dark era without signs of democracy.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery