- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Born here or came here? The biggest trap in the topic
Separate people born in the region from people who came to it, and use that split to beat the most common wrong options.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Exam setters love a simple trick: they ask where a person was born, knowing that students link a famous name with the town where he or she is remembered. For Puducherry this trick works very well, because so many of its famous people came from elsewhere. In this lesson you learn to separate three ideas: born in, lived in and remembered in.
Three ideas, one table
| Person | Born | Lived and worked | Remembered in |
|---|---|---|---|
| Subramania Bharati | Ettayapuram, Tamil country | Pondicherry, about ten years | Bharathi Memorial Museum |
| Bharathidasan | Pondicherry | Pondicherry and the Tamil country | House memorial in Puducherry; a university in Tamil Nadu |
| Sri Aurobindo | Calcutta | Bengal, then Pondicherry from 1910 | The Ashram, the Samadhi |
| The Mother | Paris | Pondicherry; founded Auroville | Ashram and Auroville |
| Dupleix | France | Pondicherry as governor-general | French-era history |
| Francois Martin | France | Pondicherry as its founder | French-era history |
| Karaikal Ammaiyar | Karaikal, by tradition | Karaikal | Her temple and the Mangani festival |
Born in the region or came to it
-
Born in the region
- Bharathidasan: Pondicherry
- Karaikal Ammaiyar: Karaikal
-
Came to the region
- Bharati: from the Tamil country, 1908
- Sri Aurobindo: from Calcutta, 1910
- The Mother: from Paris
- Dupleix and Martin: from France
The question types and how to answer them
- Birthplace questions. Never answer 'Pondicherry' for Bharati, Sri Aurobindo or the Mother. Only Bharathidasan on this list was born there.
- Residence questions. If the question says 'where did he live for about ten years', the answer for Bharati is Pondicherry.
- Memorial questions. The Bharathi Memorial Museum is in Puducherry even though Bharati was born elsewhere.
- Nationality questions. The Mother was born in France; Sri Aurobindo was a Bengali who studied in England. Their link with India is through their work in Pondicherry.
Elimination method
When you do not remember a birthplace, eliminate. First remove the French names, Martin and Dupleix, because they came from France. Then remove the Ashram pair, because one was born in Calcutta and the other in Paris. Among the poets, the one with the pen-name copied from another poet is the follower, and the follower was born in the town. This three-step elimination leaves Bharathidasan as the person born in Pondicherry, even if you cannot recall his birth year.
Worked examples
Worked example 1. Which poet was born in Pondicherry: (a) Bharati (b) Bharathidasan (c) Sri Aurobindo (d) Mirra Alfassa? Working: Bharati was born at Ettayapuram, Sri Aurobindo in Calcutta, and Mirra Alfassa in Paris. Bharathidasan was born in Pondicherry. Answer: (b).
Worked example 2. 'Born in Calcutta, came to Pondicherry in 1910.' Who is described? Working: Sri Aurobindo was born in Calcutta in 1872 and arrived in 1910. Answer: Sri Aurobindo.
Worked example 3. Which statement is correct? (i) Bharati was born in Pondicherry. (ii) Bharati lived in Pondicherry for about ten years. Working: (i) is false because he was born at Ettayapuram; (ii) is true. Answer: only (ii).
Common trap. A question may say 'the town where he is remembered', not 'where he was born'. Read the verb. Born, lived, died and remembered can all be different places.
Read the verb: born, lived, came or remembered. The same person may have a different answer for each.
Key takeaways
- Only Bharathidasan among the poets and thinkers listed was born in Pondicherry.
- Bharati was born at Ettayapuram; Sri Aurobindo in Calcutta; the Mother in Paris.
- Memorials stand in Puducherry for people born elsewhere.
Check your understanding
-
1. Subramania Bharati was born at:
- Pondicherry
- Calcutta
- Karaikal
- Ettayapuram
Show answer
Answer: D. Bharati was born at Ettayapuram in the Tamil country and came to Pondicherry in 1908.
-
2. Which of these was born in Paris?
- Mirra Alfassa, the Mother
- Sri Aurobindo
- Bharathidasan
- Bharati
Show answer
Answer: A. The Mother was born in Paris. Sri Aurobindo was born in Calcutta.
-
3. A question asks: where did Bharati live for about ten years? The answer is:
- Calcutta
- Paris
- Pondicherry
- Mahe
Show answer
Answer: C. He lived in Pondicherry from 1908 for about ten years.
-
4. Which statement is correct?
- Sri Aurobindo was born in Pondicherry
- The Mother was born in Karaikal
- Bharati was born in Mahe
- Bharathidasan was born in Pondicherry
Show answer
Answer: D. Only Bharathidasan was born in Pondicherry.
-
5. Statement 1: The Bharathi Memorial Museum is in Puducherry. Statement 2: Bharati was born in Puducherry. Which is right?
- Only statement 2 is true
- Only statement 1 is true
- Both are true
- Neither is true
Show answer
Answer: B. The museum is in Puducherry, but Bharati was born at Ettayapuram.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.