- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Reading the question: directive words and what each one asks for
Break any descriptive question into its directive word, topic and limits, and know what explain, describe, discuss, compare, critically examine, comment and elucidate each demand.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many students lose marks in descriptive papers not because they did not know the topic, but because they answered a different question from the one printed. They saw a familiar word, felt relief and started writing everything they remembered. Good answer writing begins before the pen touches the answer sheet: with a slow, careful reading of the question. This lesson shows you how to take a question apart and how to read the small instruction word that tells you what kind of answer the examiner wants.
The three parts of every question
- The directive word tells you what to do: explain, describe, discuss, compare and so on.
- The topic tells you what to write about, for example 'the role of teachers' or 'trees in cities'.
- The limits narrow the topic: 'in shaping character', 'for school students', 'with examples', a word limit, or several parts joined by 'and'.
A useful habit is to mark all three on the question paper: circle the directive word, draw a box around the topic and underline every limit. It takes ten seconds and saves you from the most common mistake in descriptive answers.
Directive words and what they demand
| Directive word | What it asks you to do | Your answer must contain |
|---|---|---|
| Explain | Make clear how or why something happens | Reasons, causes or the working of the thing, linked step by step |
| Describe | Say what something is like | Features, parts or characteristics; little argument is needed |
| Discuss | Look at the issue from more than one side | Points for and against or several angles, then your reasoned view |
| Compare | Set two or more things side by side | Similarities and differences, ideally point by point |
| Critically examine | Look closely and judge | Strengths and weaknesses, evidence or reasons, a balanced verdict |
| Comment | Give your judgement on a statement | Your opinion with reasons, showing you understood the statement |
| Elucidate | Throw light on an idea | A clear explanation supported by examples or illustrations |
Notice how different these are. 'Describe a good study space' wants features. 'Explain why a good study space helps concentration' wants reasons. 'Discuss whether a separate study room is necessary' wants both sides and a conclusion. Same topic area, three different answers.
Worked example 1: Pooja decodes a 'discuss' question
Pooja, a B.A. second-year student in Lucknow, is practising this question: 'Discuss the role of teachers in shaping a student's character. (150 words)'.
- Step 1, directive word: she circles 'Discuss'. That means more than one angle and a view at the end.
- Step 2, topic: she boxes 'role of teachers'.
- Step 3, limits: she underlines 'shaping a student's character' (not marks, not jobs) and '150 words'.
- Step 4, what the answer needs: ways teachers shape character (as role models, through fair rules, through encouragement), plus the other side: family and friends also shape character, so a teacher's role is important but not the only one.
- Result: her plan has three positive points, one balancing point and a conclusion giving her view. Without step 3 she would have written about teaching methods, which the question did not ask.
Worked example 2: Arjun fixes a 'compare' answer
Arjun, who is preparing for competitive exams while working in a shop in Indore, answered 'Compare reading on paper and reading on a screen for study purposes' by listing five advantages of screens. His friend pointed out that this was a description of one side, not a comparison.
- Step 1: he rereads the directive word: compare means both things, similarities and differences.
- Step 2: he draws two columns, 'Paper' and 'Screen', and fills each row with the same feature: ease of carrying, eye comfort over long hours, making notes in the margin, distractions, cost of getting material.
- Step 3: he adds one similarity row: both work only if the reader reads actively.
- Step 4: he ends with a conclusion: each suits different tasks, so a student can combine them.
- Result: the new answer treats both sides on the same points, which is exactly what 'compare' asked for.
Before you write a word, circle the directive, box the topic and underline the limits. Answer the question that is printed, not the one you hoped for.
Key takeaways
- Every question has a directive word, a topic and limits; find all three first.
- Explain asks why or how, describe asks what it is like, discuss asks for sides and a view, compare asks for similarities and differences.
- Critically examine and comment both need your judgement, backed by reasons.
- Limits such as 'for students' or a word count are part of the question, not decoration.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the question 'Explain why libraries are useful for students in small towns', which word is the directive word?
- Libraries
- Useful
- Explain
- Small towns
Show answer
Answer: C. The directive word tells you what to do with the topic. Here it is 'Explain', so the answer must give reasons why libraries are useful.
-
2. A question says 'Describe the features of a good timetable'. What does it mainly want?
- Arguments for and against making timetables
- A personal opinion on whether timetables work
- A comparison of two timetables
- The characteristics of a good timetable
Show answer
Answer: D. 'Describe' asks what something is like, so the answer lists and explains the features. Arguments for and against would suit 'discuss'.
-
3. Which answer best matches the directive 'Compare'?
- One that explains only the advantages of the first thing
- One that tells the history of both things separately
- One that sets both things side by side on the same points, showing similarities and differences
- One that gives the student's opinion of the better thing in a single line
Show answer
Answer: C. Comparing means looking at both items on the same points and showing how they are alike and how they differ.
-
4. Meena reads 'Critically examine the idea that homework should be abolished'. What must her answer include that a simple description would not?
- Only the reasons in favour of abolishing homework
- A balanced judgement weighing strengths and weaknesses of the idea
- A list of all the subjects in which teachers usually give homework to students
- A story about her own homework
Show answer
Answer: B. 'Critically examine' asks you to look closely and judge, so strengths and weaknesses are weighed and a reasoned verdict is given.
-
5. In 'Discuss the role of sports in a student's life, with examples (150 words)', which of these is a limit rather than the topic or directive?
- Discuss
- Role of sports
- Student's life and sports together
- With examples
Show answer
Answer: D. 'With examples' narrows how you must answer, so it is a limit. 'Discuss' is the directive word and 'role of sports' is the topic.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.