- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Reviewing and improving: a three-pass check, self-marking and a weekly routine
Check an answer in three quick passes for content, structure and language, mark your own answers against a four-part rubric, keep an error log, and build a small weekly routine that raises the quality of your writing.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Writing an answer is only half of the skill. The other half is reading it as an examiner would and learning from what you find. Students who write many answers but never review them tend to repeat the same mistakes. Students who review even a few answers carefully improve faster. This lesson gives you a quick check for the exam hall, a way to mark your own practice answers, and a simple weekly routine.
The three-pass check
In the exam, set aside the last two or three minutes of each long answer, or of the whole paper, for a quick check in three passes. Do the passes in this order, because a deeper problem is not worth polishing around.
- Pass 1, content: does the answer reply to the question that was asked, with the right directive? Is any point missing, and is any point wrong?
- Pass 2, structure: is there an introduction, a body with one idea per point and a conclusion? Are the points in a sensible order?
- Pass 3, language and presentation: check spelling of key terms, agreement and tense, and make sure that the writing is legible and corrections are neat.
Marking your own practice answers
After a timed practice answer, put it away for an hour, and then mark it using a simple rubric of four criteria, each out of 5: relevance (answers the question), structure (three-part shape and order), depth (reasons and examples, no invented facts) and language and presentation. Mark honestly and write one sentence of evidence for each score. Total the four scores, out of 20.
Then keep an error log: a page on which you write the type of each error you found, such as spelling of a key term, long introduction, missing conclusion, or drifting from the question. After five answers, count each type. The type with the highest count is the next thing to fix, and fixing one habit at a time works better than trying to correct everything.
Rule to remember: check content first, structure second and language last; score your own answers against a rubric; and fix the most frequent error first.
Worked example 1: scoring a practice answer
Isha writes a 150-word answer on the benefits of a reading habit and marks it. Relevance 4 (all points relate to the question). Structure 3 (the introduction is long and there is no real conclusion). Depth 3 (points have reasons but only one example). Language and presentation 5 (neat and correct). The total is 4 + 3 + 3 + 5 = 15 out of 20, which is 15 ÷ 20 × 100 = 75 per cent. The weakest scores are for structure and depth, so her next goals are a shorter introduction with a closing sentence, and one short example for every point.
Worked example 2: reading an error log
Over five practice answers, Isha's error log shows: spelling of key terms, 4 times; long introduction, 3 times; no conclusion, 2 times; drifting from the question, 1 time. The total number of errors logged is 4 + 3 + 2 + 1 = 10. The most frequent error is spelling of key terms (4 out of 10, which is 40 per cent). She decides to make a list of the key terms of each topic, to check the spelling before a test and to read the list aloud. Next week she will see whether the count falls.
A weekly routine
| Day | Task | Time (illustrative) |
|---|---|---|
| Day 1 | Write one timed answer | About 20 minutes |
| Day 2 | Self-mark with the rubric and update the error log | About 15 minutes |
| Day 3 | Rewrite the weakest paragraph | About 10 minutes |
| Day 4 | Read a good model answer and note what it does well | About 15 minutes |
| Day 5 | Write a new timed answer, aiming at the one error you chose | About 20 minutes |
Two timed answers a week for four weeks gives 2 × 4 = 8 reviewed answers in a month, which is enough to see a real change. The routine is small on purpose: a plan that fits into a busy week is a plan you will keep.
Key takeaways. Check in three passes (content, structure, language). Mark your own answers against a four-part rubric and keep an error log. Fix the most frequent error first, and keep the routine short enough to repeat.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the three-pass check, which pass comes first?
- Content
- Language
- Handwriting
- Spelling
Show answer
Answer: A. Content comes first. A well-spelt answer to the wrong question does not earn marks.
-
2. Isha scores 4, 3, 3 and 5 on the four criteria, each out of 5. What is her total?
- 12 out of 20
- 16 out of 20
- 15 out of 20
- 17 out of 20
Show answer
Answer: C. 4 + 3 + 3 + 5 = 15 out of 20, which is 75 per cent.
-
3. An error log shows spelling 4 times, long introduction 3 times, no conclusion 2 times and drifting 1 time. What should the student work on first?
- Drifting from the question
- Spelling of key terms
- No conclusion
- Long introduction
Show answer
Answer: B. The most frequent error, with 4 of the 10 errors, is the best one to fix first.
-
4. Why is a quick check for language the last pass and not the first?
- Language never has any effect on the marks given
- Language is more important than structure and content
- Examiners are told to ignore grammar and spelling
- Polishing the words of a weak answer is of little use
Show answer
Answer: D. Deeper problems should be fixed first. Polishing the wording of a point that does not answer the question wastes time.
-
5. A student writes two timed answers a week for four weeks. How many reviewed answers is that?
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 16
Show answer
Answer: B. 2 × 4 = 8 answers.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.