- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Compare, analyse and evaluate: three directives that need different shapes
See how a comparison, an analysis and an evaluation are built differently, with a simple layout for each that you can reuse on any topic.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Students often answer 'compare', 'analyse' and 'evaluate' with the same shape: a general description followed by a few points. But each directive asks for a different job. A comparison needs both items set against the same points. An analysis breaks something into parts and shows how they connect. An evaluation sets criteria and reaches a judgment. This lesson gives each directive its own layout.
Compare: same points, both items
A good comparison is organised by points of comparison, not by item. Choose three or so points, and for each point say what is true of both items. Include at least one similarity and one difference. A small table suits 'compare' very well, with a sentence of explanation before or after it.
Analyse: parts, then links
To analyse is to split a whole into parts and explain how the parts relate. Name the parts (three or four), say what each does, and then say how they depend on one another. The links are what make it analysis rather than a list.
Evaluate: criteria, evidence, verdict
To evaluate is to judge how good, useful or successful something is. Choose two or three criteria (such as cost, speed, reliability), assess the thing against each, and end with a verdict that follows from your assessment. The verdict is the heart of the answer.
| Directive | Shape | Must contain |
|---|---|---|
| Compare | Points of comparison, both items under each | Similarities and differences |
| Analyse | Parts, then how they connect | Links between the parts |
| Evaluate | Criteria, assessment against each, verdict | A reasoned judgment |
Worked example 1: Maya compares two study methods
Maya, in Pune, answers: 'Compare reading a chapter again with answering questions on it. (150 words)'.
- Step 1: she picks three points: effort, feedback, and long-term recall.
- Step 2: effort: rereading is easy and comfortable; answering questions is harder because you must pull facts from memory.
- Step 3: feedback: rereading gives none; answering questions shows at once what you do not know.
- Step 4: recall: rereading can create a feeling of knowing without real recall; answering questions trains the recall that exams demand.
- Step 5: a similarity: both help only if done regularly. She puts the three points into a three-row table and adds two sentences, with a closing verdict that a mix works best, starting with questions.
Worked example 2: Imran evaluates and analyses
Imran meets two questions in one practice paper.
- 'Evaluate a printed notebook against a phone app for note-making. (150 words)': he uses criteria of speed of writing, ease of searching and chance of distraction. The notebook is slower to search but has fewer distractions; the app is easy to search but a phone invites distraction. His verdict: for a student who is easily distracted, the notebook; for one who needs fast search and has control, the app. The verdict follows from his criteria.
- 'Analyse the parts of a good revision plan. (150 words)': he names three parts: a list of topics, a schedule of when each is revised, and a check of what has been remembered. He then links them: without the list the schedule has nothing to schedule, and without the check the schedule cannot be improved. The links make the difference between an analysis and a list.
A check before moving on
- Compare: did I use the same points for both items?
- Analyse: did I name the parts and show how they connect?
- Evaluate: did I state my criteria and give a verdict?
Compare by points, analyse by parts and links, evaluate by criteria and verdict.
Key takeaways
- The three directives ask for three different shapes of answer.
- A table helps a comparison; links make an analysis; a verdict completes an evaluation.
- Choose points, parts or criteria in the planning minute, before you write.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which layout suits 'Compare X and Y' best?
- Shared points, with X and Y under each
- All of X, then a long story on Y
- A list of facts about X alone
- A verdict without any points at all
Show answer
Answer: A. A comparison is organised by points so that the reader sees X and Y side by side. Describing one item at a time leaves the comparing to the reader.
-
2. What turns a list of parts into an analysis?
- Making the list of parts longer
- Putting every part into a table
- Showing how the parts link up
- Writing each part in capital letters
Show answer
Answer: C. An analysis explains how the parts depend on or affect one another. Without the links, it is only a description of parts.
-
3. An evaluation answer should end with
- A fresh list of new facts
- A verdict from the criteria
- A copy of the question
- A question for the examiner
Show answer
Answer: B. Evaluation means judging, so the answer must reach a judgment, and the judgment must follow from the assessment against the criteria.
-
4. In an evaluation of two note-making methods, which is a suitable criterion?
- The colour of the cover
- The name of the shop
- The date of purchase
- Ease of searching later
Show answer
Answer: D. A criterion must be something that matters for the purpose. Ease of searching matters for notes. The others have no bearing on how good the method is.
-
5. A comparison answer should include
- Differences, with no likeness
- A similarity and a difference
- Similarities, with no contrast
- Facts about one item alone
Show answer
Answer: B. Comparison covers both likeness and unlikeness. Including both shows that you have considered the items fully.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.