- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Where wrong answers come from: slips, half-knowledge and blind guesses
Sort the wrong answers in a mock into slips, half-knowledge guesses and blind guesses, work out what each kind cost, and choose the cheapest fix.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A wrong answer under negative marking costs you twice: once for the mark you did not get and once for the penalty. But not all wrong answers are alike. Some come from a slip, some from a guess made with some knowledge, and some from a pure guess. Each kind needs a different cure. The marking scheme used below is invented: +2 for a right answer and -0.5 for a wrong one.
Three kinds of wrong answer
| Kind | What happened | The cure |
|---|---|---|
| Slip | You knew it, but made a small error: misread, miscalculated, marked the wrong bubble | Check routines, reading routine, marking routine |
| Half-knowledge guess | You ruled out one or two options and chose between the rest | Study the topic better; compare your hit rate with the break-even rate |
| Blind guess | You had no idea and chose any option | Decide in advance a rule for such questions and keep to it |
Tag each wrong answer as you review the mock. If you cannot remember why you chose it, ask what you would do now: if you could solve it with another minute, it was a slip; if you narrowed it down, half-knowledge; if you cannot start, a blind guess.
Worked example 1: Aarav's mock
In an invented mock, Aarav had 12 wrong answers. He tagged 4 as slips, 5 as half-knowledge guesses and 3 as blind guesses.
- Step 1: penalty paid for all 12 wrong answers = 12 x 0.5 = 6 marks.
- Step 2: the 4 slips would each have scored +2 instead of -0.5, a gain of 2.5 each: 4 x 2.5 = 10 marks lost to slips.
- Step 3: the blind guesses paid 3 x 0.5 = 1.5 marks in penalties, with a chance of a lucky right answer that did not come.
- Step 4: the 5 half-knowledge answers paid 5 x 0.5 = 2.5 marks in penalties. Here the question is whether Aarav's hit rate on such questions is above the break-even rate for this scheme; that depends on how many of them he got right overall, not just the wrong ones.
- Result: the largest loss is slips: 10 marks. The cheapest improvement is to check, not to study more.
Worked example 2: Sara tracks three mocks
Sara keeps the tally for three mocks, as in the table.
| Mock | Wrong answers | Slips | Share of slips |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 12 | 5 | 42% |
| 2 | 10 | 4 | 40% |
| 3 | 9 | 2 | 22% |
- Step 1: the share of slips = slips / wrong answers: 5/12 = 42%, 4/10 = 40%, 2/9 = 22%.
- Step 2: the share is falling, which suggests her checking routine is working.
- Step 3: but three mocks are a small sample, so she keeps the routine and tallies the next three before judging it a success.
- Result: she has evidence, not just a feeling.
Tag each wrong answer, work out what each kind cost, and treat the biggest loss first.
Key takeaways
- Wrong answers come from slips, half-knowledge and blind guesses.
- Slips cost the whole swing and are the cheapest to fix.
- Tally the kinds across several mocks, not just one.
- Use a small sample with care.
Check your understanding
-
1. A student knew the topic but marked the wrong bubble. This wrong answer is a
- Blind guess
- Half-knowledge guess
- Correct answer
- Slip
Show answer
Answer: D. The knowledge was there and a small error spoiled it. That is a slip, and it is cured with a marking routine.
-
2. In an invented scheme (+2, -0.5), 6 slips cost how many marks in swing?
- 12
- 15
- 3
- 9
Show answer
Answer: B. The swing is 2 + 0.5 = 2.5 per slip. 6 x 2.5 = 15.
-
3. Which wrong answer came after ruling out two options?
- A slip
- A blind guess
- A half-knowledge guess
- An unattempted question
Show answer
Answer: C. Narrowing the options with some knowledge and then choosing is half-knowledge. A blind guess uses no knowledge at all.
-
4. Why tally several mocks instead of one?
- One mock can be a small fluke
- One mock is always enough
- Tallies are only for teachers
- Mocks never repeat patterns
Show answer
Answer: A. A single mock can be unusual. A pattern across several mocks is more reliable evidence.
-
5. A student has 9 wrong answers, 3 of them slips. What share are slips?
- About 25%
- About 50%
- About 33%
- About 66%
Show answer
Answer: C. 3 divided by 9 is one-third, about 33%.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.