- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Why blind guessing is risky under negative marking
Tell a blind guess from an informed answer, work out what a batch of blind guesses earns on average under illustrative schemes, and see how far the real result can swing.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
When time is short or a question looks unfamiliar, it is tempting to just mark something. Under negative marking, that habit has a cost. This lesson shows, with simple counting, what blind guessing earns on average and why the actual result can be worse than the average suggests.
What a blind guess is
A blind guess is an answer chosen with no reason to prefer one option over another: you do not understand the question, cannot rule out any option, and pick at random. An informed answer is different: you know something, perhaps enough to rule out one or two options. This lesson is only about blind guesses. Informed answers are handled in the next lesson.
Counting blind guesses on four-option questions
With four options and no knowledge, each guess has one chance in four of being right. Over many blind guesses, about one in four will be right and about three in four wrong. That is an average, not a promise: in any one paper you may be luckier or unluckier.
Worked example 1: Deepa's 20 blind guesses
Suppose Deepa's paper gives +1 for a right answer and deducts 1/3 for a wrong one, and she blindly guesses 20 four-option questions. On average right: 20 x 1/4 = 5. On average wrong: 20 - 5 = 15. Marks: 5 x 1 = 5. Penalty: 15 x 1/3 = 5. Average result: 5 - 5 = 0. Twenty guesses, and on average nothing gained. Under this scheme the penalty was set so that blind guessing breaks even on average.
Now suppose instead that the scheme deducts 1/2 for a wrong answer. Average result: 5 - 15 x 1/2 = 5 - 7.5 = -2.5. Blind guessing now loses marks on average.
The average hides the swing
An average of zero does not mean your result will be zero. Look at what Deepa's 20 guesses could actually produce under the +1 / -1/3 scheme.
| Right out of 20 | Wrong | Marks earned | Penalty | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | 18 | 2 | 6 | -4 |
| 5 | 15 | 5 | 5 | 0 |
| 8 | 12 | 8 | 4 | +4 |
Blind guessing turns part of your score into a lottery. Sometimes it lifts you, sometimes it drops you, and on average it gives nothing under this scheme and less than nothing under a harsher one. When a few marks decide whether you clear a stage, a lottery is the last thing you want.
Worked example 2: Deepak's mock review
Suppose Deepak's mock gives +1 for a right answer and deducts 1/3 for a wrong one. In the last ten minutes he panicked and blindly marked 16 questions. When he checked, 3 were right and 13 wrong. Marks: 3. Penalty: 13 x 1/3, about 4.33. Result of the guesses: 3 - 4.33 = about -1.33. If he had left those 16 blank, his score would have been about 1.33 marks higher. He also lost time filling them that he could have used to recheck two answers he was unsure about.
Other hidden costs
- Time: every blind guess takes seconds that could check a doubtful answer.
- Marking errors: hurried marking on an answer sheet causes misplaced answers.
- False confidence: a lucky guess in a mock can make you trust guessing on the real day.
A blind guess earns nothing on average at best, and loses marks under a harsher penalty. Its real result is a gamble.
Key takeaways
- A blind guess means no reason to prefer any option; an informed answer is different.
- With four options, about one blind guess in four is right on average.
- Under an illustrative +1 / -1/3 scheme blind guessing averages zero; under -1/2 it averages a loss.
- Even when the average is zero, the real result can swing below zero.
Check your understanding
-
1. You blindly guess 12 four-option questions. On average, how many will be right?
- 4
- 6
- 3
- 1
Show answer
Answer: C. Each blind guess has a 1 in 4 chance, so 12 x 1/4 = 3 on average.
-
2. Suppose +1 for right and -1/3 for wrong. What is the average result of 12 blind guesses on four-option questions?
- 0
- +3
- -1
- +1
Show answer
Answer: A. On average 3 right and 9 wrong: 3 - 9 x 1/3 = 3 - 3 = 0.
-
3. Suppose +1 for right and -1/2 for wrong. What is the average result of 12 blind guesses on four-option questions?
- 0
- -4.5
- -1.5
- +1.5
Show answer
Answer: C. On average 3 right and 9 wrong: 3 - 9 x 1/2 = 3 - 4.5 = -1.5.
-
4. Which of these is a blind guess?
- Choosing between two options after ruling out two others
- Marking an answer you have worked out fully
- Choosing an option because you remember the fact
- Picking an option at random because you cannot rule out any of them
Show answer
Answer: D. A blind guess means no knowledge favours any option. Ruling out options makes it an informed answer.
-
5. Under an illustrative +1 / -1/3 scheme, blind guessing averages zero. Why is it still risky?
- Because blind guesses are always wrong
- The actual result can easily fall below zero, and guessing also uses time
- Because the examiner can see which answers were guesses
- Because a blank question is penalised more
Show answer
Answer: B. The average describes many guesses; in one paper you can get fewer right than average and lose marks, as the table showed (2 right out of 20 gives -4).
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.