• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Evidences of evolution: organs, embryos and fossils

Tell homologous organs from analogous ones, give examples of vestigial organs and atavism, explain the biogenetic law, and say why Archaeopteryx is a connecting link.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define homologous, analogous and vestigial organs and atavism, with examples.
  • Explain what comparative embryology and the biogenetic law tell us.
  • Describe palaeontology and the features of Archaeopteryx.

If all living things share common ancestors, we should find traces of that shared history in their bodies, in the way their embryos grow and in fossils. The Tamil Nadu textbook groups this evidence under three headings: morphology and anatomy, embryology and palaeontology.

Evidence from morphology and anatomy

Homologous organs are inherited from a common ancestor and develop in the embryo in a similar way, but they may look different and do different jobs. The forelimbs of mammals are the standard example: a human hand, the front leg of a cat, the flipper of a whale and the wing of a bat. Each has the same set of bones in the same order: humerus, radius and ulna, carpals, metacarpals and phalanges. Same plan, different use: this points to divergence from one ancestor.

Analogous organs look similar and do the same job but have a different origin and a different pattern of development. The wings of a bat, a bird and an insect all help in flying, but an insect's wing is a thin outgrowth of the body wall with no bones, while the bat's and the bird's wings are built on very different limb bones. Same use, different plan.

Homologous versus analogous organs

  • Homologous organs
    • Same basic structure and origin
    • Similar development in the embryo
    • May do different jobs
    • Example: forelimbs of human, cat, whale, bat
  • Analogous organs
    • Different structure and origin
    • Different development
    • Do the same job
    • Example: wings of bat, bird, insect

Vestigial organs are reduced and non-functional organs, though the same organs are well developed and working in related animals. In humans the textbook lists the vermiform appendix, the nictitating membrane (the small fold in the inner corner of the eye), the caudal vertebrae and the coccyx (tail bone). They are leftovers from ancestors in which these parts were useful.

Atavism is the reappearance of an ancestral character in some individuals, such as a rudimentary tail in a newborn baby or thick hair over the human body. Vestigial organs are present in everyone; atavism shows up only now and then.

Evidence from embryology

When embryos of fish, salamander, tortoise, chick, rabbit and human are compared, they look remarkably alike in their early stages: all show gill slits and a tail. Their special features appear only later. Ernst Haeckel summed this up in the biogenetic law (recapitulation theory): ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny. Ontogeny is the development of an individual; phylogeny is the evolutionary history of its group. The stages an animal passes through while developing repeat, in a rough way, the history of its race.

Evidence from palaeontology

Palaeontology is the study of fossils. The textbook names Leonardo da Vinci as the Father of Palaeontology. Fossil records show evolution as a gradual process from simple to complex organisms, and they help trace the line of descent of many animals.

Archaeopteryx is the oldest known fossil bird, from the Jurassic period. It is a connecting link between reptiles and birds because it had features of both:

Archaeopteryx: a connecting link

  • Bird-like features
    • Wings
    • Feathers
  • Reptile-like features
    • Long tail
    • Clawed digits
    • Conical teeth

Worked example 1: sorting organs

Question: Are the wing of a butterfly and the wing of a sparrow homologous or analogous? Reasoning: Both are used for flying, so their function is the same. But the butterfly's wing has no bones and grows from the body wall, while the sparrow's wing is a forelimb with bones. Same function, different structure and origin: they are analogous.

Worked example 2: vestigial or atavism?

Question: Every adult human has a coccyx; a very small number of babies are born with a short tail-like outgrowth. Classify each. Reasoning: The coccyx is a reduced, non-working remnant found in all humans, so it is a vestigial organ. A tail appearing in a few individuals is an ancestral character reappearing, so it is atavism.

Homologous = same structure, different function (divergence). Analogous = same function, different structure. Vestigial = present but useless in all. Atavism = an ancestral feature reappearing in a few.

Key takeaways: homologous organs, vestigial organs and atavism point to common ancestry. Similar early embryos support the biogenetic law of Haeckel. Fossils such as Archaeopteryx show links between groups, here between reptiles and birds.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The flipper of a whale and the wing of a bat have the same set of bones but different uses. They are:

    1. Analogous organs
    2. Vestigial organs
    3. Homologous organs
    4. Examples of atavism
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Same basic bone plan and origin with different functions defines homologous organs. Analogous organs are the reverse: same function, different structure.

  2. 2. Which of these is a vestigial organ in humans?

    1. Vermiform appendix
    2. Heart
    3. Humerus
    4. Thick hair over the whole body in an individual
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The vermiform appendix is reduced and has no clear digestive role in humans, though it is well developed in some related mammals. Thick body hair in an individual is atavism, not a vestigial organ; the heart and humerus are fully working.

  3. 3. 'Ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny' was stated by:

    1. Charles Darwin
    2. Ernst Haeckel
    3. Hugo de Vries
    4. Jean Baptiste Lamarck
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Ernst Haeckel gave the biogenetic law or recapitulation theory: an individual's development repeats the evolutionary history of its group.

  4. 4. Which feature of Archaeopteryx is reptile-like?

    1. Feathers
    2. Wings
    3. A beak with no teeth
    4. Conical teeth
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Archaeopteryx had feathers and wings like a bird, but a long tail, clawed digits and conical teeth like a reptile. That mix makes it a connecting link.

  5. 5. Early embryos of fish, chick and human all show gill slits and a tail. This mainly supports:

    1. Common ancestry of vertebrates
    2. Spontaneous generation
    3. Inheritance of acquired characters
    4. Panspermia
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Shared early stages suggest that these vertebrates inherited a common pattern of development from shared ancestors; this is embryological evidence of evolution.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery