- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Theories of evolution: Lamarckism and Darwinism
State the four principles of Lamarckism and the five principles of Darwin's natural selection, use the giraffe and kiwi examples, and explain the three kinds of struggle for existence.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define evolution as the textbook does.
- List and explain the principles of Lamarckism, with the giraffe and kiwi examples.
- List and explain the principles of Darwinism and the three types of struggle.
- Compare how Lamarck and Darwin would explain the same change.
Evolution is the gradual change in living organisms over a long period of time. When specific characters change over many generations in response to natural selection, new species form. Two scientists gave the best-known explanations of how this happens: Lamarck and Darwin.
Lamarckism
Jean Baptiste Lamarck (1744-1829) was a French naturalist. He published his theory in Philosophie Zoologique in 1809. It is called the theory of inheritance of acquired characters, the use and disuse theory, or Lamarckism. It has four principles:
- Internal vital force: living things and their parts tend to keep growing in size because of an inner ability.
- Environment and new needs: a change in the environment creates new needs, and organisms develop adaptive characters, even new body parts, to meet them.
- Use and disuse: an organ used constantly grows strong; an organ not used for a long time slowly degenerates.
- Inheritance of acquired characters: characters developed during an animal's lifetime in response to the environment (acquired characters) are passed on to the offspring.
Lamarck's examples: the ancestors of the giraffe had short necks and forelimbs. When grass became scarce they stretched to eat leaves on trees, and the constant stretching produced long necks and forelimbs (use). The reduced wings of the kiwi show degeneration through disuse.
Lamarck's chain of reasoning
- Environment changes
- New need arises
- Organ used more or less Use develops it; disuse degenerates it
- Acquired character Formed during the lifetime
- Passed to offspring
- New species After many generations
Later studies did not support the inheritance of acquired characters: a change in body cells during one lifetime (such as a strong arm from exercise) is not written into the germ cells, so it is not passed on. This is why Darwin's theory replaced Lamarck's as the main explanation.
Darwinism: the theory of natural selection
Charles Darwin (1809-1882) was born in England. Through his teacher Professor J. S. Henslow he joined the voyage of the ship H.M.S. Beagle, which lasted about five years (the textbook gives 1831-1835; the ship returned to England in 1836). He studied the land, plants and animals of many places, including the Galapagos islands, and then worked for about 20 more years before publishing On the Origin of Species in 1859. His theory has five principles:
- Overproduction: living things can multiply in a geometric manner, producing far more offspring than can survive.
- Struggle for existence: food and space stay limited, so organisms compete. The struggle is intraspecific (among members of the same species), interspecific (between different species living together) or environmental (against heat, cold, drought, floods).
- Variations: no two individuals are exactly alike. Small variations matter for evolution; favourable ones help the organism, unfavourable ones are harmful or useless.
- Survival of the fittest, or natural selection: organisms with favourable variations overcome the challenges and survive; the unfit are eliminated. Selection of those with favourable variations is natural selection.
- Origin of species: new species arise by the gradual build-up of favourable variations over many generations.
Three types of struggle for existence
-
Intraspecific
- Same species
- Two crows competing for the same food
-
Interspecific
- Different species
- Deer and cattle grazing the same field
-
Environmental
- Against natural conditions
- Drought, flood, extreme heat or cold
Worked example 1: the giraffe both ways
Question: Explain the long neck of the giraffe as Lamarck and as Darwin would. Lamarck: each ancestor stretched its neck to reach leaves; the stretched neck (an acquired character) was inherited, and necks grew longer over generations. Darwin: ancestors varied in neck length; when food was short, those with slightly longer necks reached more leaves, survived and bred more; their offspring inherited the longer necks, and over many generations long necks became common. The key difference: Darwin's change is selected from variation already present, not acquired by effort.
Worked example 2: naming the struggle
Question: In a pond, frog tadpoles of the same species compete for algae, while a water snake hunts them, and a dry summer shrinks the pond. Name each struggle. Reasoning: tadpoles of one species competing = intraspecific; snake and frogs are different species = interspecific; the drying pond is a natural condition = environmental.
Lamarck: use and disuse + inheritance of acquired characters. Darwin: overproduction → struggle for existence → variations → survival of the fittest (natural selection) → origin of species.
Key takeaways: Lamarck explained evolution by use and disuse and the inheritance of acquired characters, a view later evidence did not support. Darwin explained it by natural selection acting on variations among the many offspring that compete in a struggle for existence.
Check your understanding
-
1. The 'use and disuse theory' was proposed by:
- Charles Darwin
- Gregor Mendel
- Ernst Haeckel
- Jean Baptiste Lamarck
Show answer
Answer: D. Lamarck's theory, published in 1809, is also called the use and disuse theory or the theory of inheritance of acquired characters.
-
2. The reduced wing of the kiwi is given by Lamarck as an example of:
- Use of an organ
- Disuse of an organ
- Atavism
- Analogous organs
Show answer
Answer: B. According to Lamarck an organ not used for a long time degenerates. The kiwi's tiny, useless wings are his example of disuse.
-
3. Competition between members of the same species is called:
- Intraspecific struggle
- Interspecific struggle
- Environmental struggle
- Natural selection
Show answer
Answer: A. 'Intra' means within: intraspecific struggle is within one species. 'Inter' means between: interspecific struggle is between different species.
-
4. Which is NOT a principle of Darwinism as listed in the textbook?
- Overproduction
- Variations
- Internal vital force
- Survival of the fittest
Show answer
Answer: C. Internal vital force is Lamarck's first principle. Darwin's five are overproduction, struggle for existence, variations, survival of the fittest (natural selection) and origin of species.
-
5. A man builds strong muscles by lifting weights. Why do his children not inherit those muscles?
- Muscles are vestigial organs
- Natural selection removes strong people
- Only interspecific characters are inherited
- The change is in body cells, not in germ cells, so it is not passed on
Show answer
Answer: D. Strong muscles are an acquired character formed in body (somatic) cells during his life. Only changes in germ cells reach the next generation, which is why Lamarck's inheritance of acquired characters was not supported.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.