• Practice
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

Other methods of depreciation and the two ways of recording it

Calculate depreciation by sum of years of digits, machine hour and depletion methods, describe the annuity, revaluation, sinking fund and insurance policy methods, and record depreciation with or without a provision for depreciation account.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Use the sum of years of digits, machine hour rate and depletion methods.
  • Explain the annuity, revaluation, sinking fund and insurance policy methods.
  • Pass journal entries when depreciation is charged to the asset account.
  • Pass journal entries when a provision for depreciation account is kept, and show both in the balance sheet.

Straight line and written down value are the most used methods, but some assets wear out by hours of use, some by quantity extracted, and some need money set aside to replace them. The textbook names a method for each case, and two ways of putting depreciation into the books.

Sum of years of digits method

The charge falls each year in proportion to the remaining life. Each year's depreciation = (Original cost − Scrap value) × (remaining years of life, including the current year) ÷ (sum of the digits 1 to n).

Machine hour rate method

Life is estimated in hours. Rate per hour = (Original cost − Scrap value) ÷ life in hours. Depreciation for a year = hours actually worked × rate per hour. Depreciation is directly in proportion to use.

Depletion method

For mines, quarries and oil fields. Rate per unit = Original cost ÷ total estimated output (in units). Depreciation = output of the year × rate per unit.

Worked example 1: three methods

All names, dates and amounts in the worked examples are made up for practice. (a) Sum of years of digits: cost ₹1,10,000, scrap ₹10,000, life 4 years. (b) Machine hour: cost ₹3,30,000, scrap ₹30,000, life 20,000 hours, 2,400 hours worked in year 1. (c) Depletion: a quarry costs ₹50,00,000 and holds 2,00,000 tonnes; 18,000 tonnes are extracted in year 1.

Working (a): depreciable amount = 1,10,000 − 10,000 = 1,00,000; sum of digits = 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 = 10.

Sum of years of digits schedule (made up)
YearRemaining lifeFractionDepreciation (₹)
144/1040,000
233/1030,000
322/1020,000
411/1010,000
Total10/101,00,000

(b) Rate per hour = (3,30,000 − 30,000) ÷ 20,000 = 3,00,000 ÷ 20,000 = ₹15. Year-1 depreciation = 2,400 × 15 = ₹36,000. (c) Rate per tonne = 50,00,000 ÷ 2,00,000 = ₹25. Year-1 depreciation = 18,000 × 25 = ₹4,50,000.

Annuity, revaluation, sinking fund and insurance policy methods

Methods that look beyond cost

  • Annuity method Also allows for interest the money could have earned
    • Depreciation = annuity factor × original cost
    • Annuity factor = i(1 + i)^n ÷ [(1 + i)^n − 1]
  • Revaluation method For livestock, loose tools and the like
    • Asset valued by experts at the end of the year
    • Depreciation = opening value − closing value
  • Sinking fund (depreciation fund) method Writes off the asset and provides money to replace it
    • Depreciation transferred to a fund and invested in safe securities
    • Interest reinvested; investments sold at end of life to buy the new asset
  • Insurance policy method Policy taken for the replacement cost
    • Depreciation paid as the yearly premium
    • Policy money on maturity buys the new asset

Illustration of the annuity factor (made up): at 10% interest for 2 years, (1.1)² = 1.21, so the factor = 0.1 × 1.21 ÷ (1.21 − 1) = 0.121 ÷ 0.21 = 0.57619. On a cost of ₹1,00,000 the yearly depreciation is about ₹57,619. Revaluation example (made up): loose tools valued at ₹18,000 at the start and ₹15,500 at the end of the year give depreciation of ₹2,500.

Recording depreciation: method 1, charging it to the asset account

Depreciation is debited to depreciation account and credited to the asset account; depreciation account is closed to profit and loss account. The asset is shown at its depreciated value.

Recording depreciation: method 2, provision for depreciation account

Depreciation is credited to a provision for depreciation account instead of the asset account, so the asset stays at original cost. The textbook shows the accumulated provision on the liabilities side of the balance sheet under current liabilities and provisions. Depreciation account is still closed to profit and loss account each year.

Worked example 2: both methods in the books

All names, dates and amounts in the worked examples are made up for practice. Machinery costing ₹80,000 is bought by cheque on 1 April. Depreciation is ₹8,000 a year (straight line). Books are closed on 31 March.

Method 1: depreciation charged to the asset account (made up)
DateParticularsL.F.Dr. (₹)Cr. (₹)
Apr 1Machinery A/c Dr.80,000
To Bank A/c80,000
(Machinery bought)
Mar 31Depreciation A/c Dr.8,000
To Machinery A/c8,000
(Depreciation provided)
Mar 31Profit and loss A/c Dr.8,000
To Depreciation A/c8,000
(Depreciation transferred to profit and loss account)
Method 2: provision for depreciation account (made up)
DateParticularsL.F.Dr. (₹)Cr. (₹)
Apr 1Machinery A/c Dr.80,000
To Bank A/c80,000
(Machinery bought)
Mar 31Depreciation A/c Dr.8,000
To Provision for depreciation A/c8,000
(Depreciation provided)
Mar 31Profit and loss A/c Dr.8,000
To Depreciation A/c8,000
(Depreciation transferred to profit and loss account)
Balance sheet extract at the end of year 1 (made up)
MethodLiabilities sideAssets side
Method 1Machinery 80,000 less depreciation 8,000 = 72,000
Method 2Provision for depreciation 8,000Machinery 80,000

At the end of year 2, method 1 shows machinery at 80,000 − 16,000 = ₹64,000; method 2 shows machinery at ₹80,000 and a provision of 8,000 + 8,000 = ₹16,000. The net figure is the same.

Key takeaways: sum of years of digits weights depreciation by remaining life; machine hour and depletion methods follow actual use or output; annuity adds interest; revaluation compares opening and closing values; sinking fund and insurance policy methods provide money for replacement. Depreciation is credited either to the asset account or to a provision for depreciation account; with a provision, the asset stays at cost.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Cost ₹66,000, scrap ₹6,000, life 3 years. Under the sum of years of digits method, depreciation for year 2 is:

    1. ₹30,000
    2. ₹22,000
    3. ₹20,000
    4. ₹10,000
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Depreciable amount 60,000; sum of digits 1 + 2 + 3 = 6. Year 2 remaining life is 2, so 60,000 × 2/6 = ₹20,000.

  2. 2. A machine costs ₹1,25,000, scrap ₹5,000, estimated life 40,000 hours. It worked 3,500 hours this year. Depreciation under the machine hour rate method is:

    1. ₹10,500
    2. ₹10,937
    3. ₹12,000
    4. ₹3,000
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Rate per hour = (1,25,000 − 5,000) ÷ 40,000 = ₹3. Depreciation = 3,500 × 3 = ₹10,500.

  3. 3. Under which method is the amount of depreciation invested outside the business in safe securities, with interest reinvested, to replace the asset later?

    1. Insurance policy method
    2. Annuity method
    3. Revaluation method
    4. Sinking fund method
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The sinking fund (depreciation fund) method transfers depreciation to a fund invested outside the business; the investments are sold at the end of the asset's life to buy a new one.

  4. 4. When a provision for depreciation account is maintained, the asset appears in the balance sheet at:

    1. original cost
    2. market value
    3. written down value
    4. scrap value
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Depreciation is credited to the provision account, not the asset account, so the asset account keeps its original cost.

  5. 5. The journal entry to provide depreciation under the provision method is:

    1. Asset A/c Dr, To Depreciation A/c
    2. Depreciation A/c Dr, To Provision for depreciation A/c
    3. Provision for depreciation A/c Dr, To Asset A/c
    4. Profit and loss A/c Dr, To Provision for depreciation A/c
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Depreciation is debited and the provision for depreciation account is credited; later depreciation account is closed to profit and loss account.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery