- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Written down value method and comparison with the straight line method
Calculate depreciation on the written down value (diminishing balance) method, find its rate from cost, scrap value and life, and compare it point by point with the straight line method.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Prepare a written down value depreciation schedule.
- Find the rate of depreciation using the textbook's formula.
- State merits, limitations and suitability of the method.
- Compare the straight line and written down value methods.
Many machines give their best work when new and need more repairs as they age. The written down value method charges more depreciation in the early years and less later, so the total of depreciation and repairs stays more even.
The method
A fixed percentage is applied each year to the written down value (book value): original cost less depreciation up to the previous year. Because the base shrinks, the charge falls every year, so the method is also called the diminishing balance or reducing instalment method.
Rate of depreciation = [1 − (Scrap value ÷ Original cost)^(1/n)] × 100, where n is the useful life in years.
If there is no scrap value the formula gives 100%, so in that case a scrap value of ₹1 is assumed. The lower the scrap value, the higher the rate.
Worked example 1: rate and schedule
All names, dates and amounts in the worked examples are made up for practice. (a) A machine costs ₹1,25,000, life 3 years, scrap value ₹8,000. Find the rate. (b) Another machine costs ₹2,00,000 and is depreciated at 20% on written down value. Prepare a 3-year schedule.
Working (a): 8,000 ÷ 1,25,000 = 0.064. Cube root of 0.064 = 0.4 (because 0.4 × 0.4 × 0.4 = 0.064). Rate = (1 − 0.4) × 100 = 60%. Check: 1,25,000 × 0.4 = 50,000; 50,000 × 0.4 = 20,000; 20,000 × 0.4 = 8,000, the scrap value.
| Year | Opening WDV (₹) | Depreciation at 20% (₹) | Closing WDV (₹) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2,00,000 | 40,000 | 1,60,000 |
| 2 | 1,60,000 | 32,000 | 1,28,000 |
| 3 | 1,28,000 | 25,600 | 1,02,400 |
Total depreciation in 3 years = 40,000 + 32,000 + 25,600 = ₹97,600, and 2,00,000 − 97,600 = 1,02,400, which agrees with the closing value. Under the straight line method at the same 20% of cost, each year would carry 40,000, total ₹1,20,000, leaving ₹80,000. Both methods give the same first-year charge; afterwards straight line is higher.
Worked example 2: part year
All names, dates and amounts in the worked examples are made up for practice. A plant costing ₹1,20,000 is bought on 1 July; 15% a year on written down value; books closed on 31 March.
Working: first year, July to March = 9 months: 1,20,000 × 15% × 9/12 = ₹13,500; WDV = 1,20,000 − 13,500 = ₹1,06,500. Second year: 1,06,500 × 15% = ₹15,975; WDV = 1,06,500 − 15,975 = ₹90,525.
Merits, limitations and suitability
Written down value method
-
Merits
- Total of depreciation and repairs stays almost the same each year
- Logical: more depreciation when the asset is most productive
-
Limitations
- Asset can never be written off to zero
- Ignores interest on money invested
- Rate is hard to determine
- Ignores actual use of the asset
Suitability: assets with a long life that need more repairs as they grow older, such as buildings and plant and machinery.
Straight line versus written down value
| Point | Straight line method | Written down value method |
|---|---|---|
| Basis | Original cost every year | Written down value of each year |
| Amount of depreciation | Same every year | Decreases every year |
| Book value at end of life | Zero or scrap value | Never becomes zero |
| Rate | Easy to calculate | Difficult to calculate |
| Order of calculation | Amount first, then rate | Rate first, then amount |
| Depreciation plus repairs | Rises year after year | Almost the same each year |
| Suits | Assets with low repairs and little obsolescence, where cost expires with time | Assets affected by technology and needing more repairs with age |
Key takeaways: the written down value method applies a fixed rate to the reducing book value, so the charge falls each year and the asset never reaches zero. Rate = [1 − (scrap ÷ cost)^(1/n)] × 100. It evens out the total of depreciation and repairs, while the straight line method keeps depreciation itself equal.
Check your understanding
-
1. A machine costs ₹2,00,000 and is depreciated at 10% a year on written down value. Depreciation for the third year is:
- ₹20,000
- ₹18,000
- ₹16,200
- ₹14,580
Show answer
Answer: C. Year 1: 20,000, WDV 1,80,000. Year 2: 18,000, WDV 1,62,000. Year 3: 1,62,000 × 10% = ₹16,200.
-
2. Which method keeps the combined charge of depreciation and repairs almost uniform over the years?
- Written down value method
- Straight line method
- Revaluation method
- Machine hour rate method
Show answer
Answer: A. In the written down value method depreciation falls as repairs rise, so their total stays nearly level.
-
3. An asset costs ₹1,00,000, has a life of 2 years and a scrap value of ₹25,000. The written down value rate is:
- 25%
- 37.5%
- 75%
- 50%
Show answer
Answer: D. Scrap ÷ cost = 0.25. Square root of 0.25 = 0.5. Rate = (1 − 0.5) × 100 = 50%. Check: 1,00,000 → 50,000 → 25,000.
-
4. If the same rate is used, the straight line charge compared with the written down value charge is:
- higher in the first year and equal later
- equal in the first year and higher in later years
- lower in all years
- equal in all years
Show answer
Answer: B. In year 1 both apply the rate to cost. Later, straight line still uses cost while written down value uses a smaller base, so straight line is higher.
-
5. Under which method is the asset never reduced to zero?
- Straight line method
- Sum of years of digits method
- Written down value method
- Depletion method
Show answer
Answer: C. A fixed percentage of a reducing balance always leaves something. Straight line can reach zero or scrap value.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.