• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

CAM, photorespiration, factors affecting photosynthesis and bacterial photosynthesis

Explain the CAM cycle, the C2 cycle of photorespiration and the CO₂ compensation point, apply Blackman's law of limiting factors to external and internal factors, and compare bacterial with plant photosynthesis.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the CAM cycle and its value to succulents.
  • Trace photorespiration (C2 cycle) through chloroplast, peroxisome and mitochondrion.
  • Define the CO₂ compensation point.
  • Apply Blackman's law of limiting factors and explain external and internal factors.
  • Compare photosynthesis in bacteria and in plants.

A cactus in the desert cannot open its stomata at noon without losing precious water. A rice plant on a hot day finds its main enzyme grabbing oxygen instead of carbon dioxide. This lesson looks at how plants cope with such problems and at what limits the rate of photosynthesis in the real world.

Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM)

CAM was first seen in the family Crassulaceae (Bryophyllum, Sedum, Kalanchoe) and also occurs in Agave, Opuntia, pineapple and many orchids, all succulents of dry places. Their stomata are open at night and closed by day (scotoactive), the reverse of most plants, which saves water.

CAM: separating the steps in time

  • Night (stomata open)
    • CO₂ enters
    • PEP + CO₂ → OAA (PEP carboxylase)
    • OAA → malic acid, stored in the vacuole
    • Leaf becomes more acidic
  • Day (stomata closed)
    • Malic acid leaves the vacuole
    • Malic acid → pyruvic acid + CO₂
    • CO₂ enters the Calvin cycle using light-made ATP and NADPH
    • Leaf acidity falls

C4 plants separate the two carboxylations in space (mesophyll and bundle sheath); CAM plants separate them in time (night and day). CAM lets succulents photosynthesise by day with stomata shut, avoiding transpiration loss.

Photorespiration (C2 cycle)

Decker (1959) noticed that some plants release more CO₂ in light than in the dark. Photorespiration is this extra light-dependent respiration of photosynthetic cells, which happens when CO₂ is low and O₂ high around RuBisCO. Then RuBisCO acts as an oxygenase: it adds O₂ to RuBP, giving one PGA and one 2-carbon phosphoglycolate. Because the first product is a 2-carbon compound, this is the C2 cycle (photosynthetic carbon oxidation cycle). It involves three organelles.

The C2 cycle

  1. Chloroplast RuBP + O₂ → PGA + phosphoglycolate; phosphoglycolate loses phosphate → glycolate.
  2. Peroxisome Glycolate + O₂ → glyoxylate + H₂O₂; glyoxylate → glycine.
  3. Mitochondrion 2 glycine → serine + CO₂ + NH₃ (CO₂ is lost here).
  4. Peroxisome Serine → hydroxypyruvate → glyceric acid (using NADH + H⁺).
  5. Chloroplast Glyceric acid + ATP → PGA, which re-enters the Calvin cycle.

Photorespiration makes no ATP and loses fixed carbon as CO₂; the textbook says up to 50% of photosynthetic potential can be lost under some conditions. It has some uses: glycine and serine made in it are raw materials for chlorophyll, proteins and nucleotides; it uses up excess NADH; and glycolate helps protect against photo-oxidation.

Photorespiration versus dark respiration
FeaturePhotorespirationDark respiration
WhereGreen cells only; chloroplast, peroxisome, mitochondrionAll living cells; mitochondrion (with cytoplasm)
WhenOnly in lightAll the time
SubstrateGlycolic acidCarbohydrates, fats or proteins
ATP yieldNoneATP produced
H₂O₂ProducedNot produced
End productsCO₂ and PGACO₂ and water

CO₂ compensation point: the CO₂ concentration at which photosynthesis exactly equals respiration, so there is no net exchange of O₂ or CO₂. With light not limiting, the textbook gives about 50–100 ppm for C3 plants; C4 plants, free of photorespiration, have a much lower compensation point.

Factors affecting photosynthesis

Sachs (1860) described cardinal points (minimum, optimum and maximum) for each factor. Blackman's law of limiting factors (1905), developed from Liebig's law of the minimum, states that when a process depends on several factors, its rate is limited by the factor present in the least amount relative to need.

Blackman: at any moment, the factor in shortest supply limits the rate; raising any other factor has no effect until that one is raised.

External and internal factors
FactorEffect
Light intensityRate rises with intensity up to a point; sun plants (bean) need more than shade plants (Oxalis)
Light qualityHighest in red and blue, lowest in green; PAR is 400–700 nm
Light durationLonger exposure gives more total photosynthesis
CO₂Rate rises with CO₂, but very high levels inhibit it
O₂High O₂ lowers the rate (Warburg effect, first shown in Chlorella)
TemperatureOptimum usually 25–35 °C; extremes close stomata and inactivate enzymes
WaterSupplies electrons and H⁺; stress closes stomata and cuts NADPH supply
MineralsMg, Fe, N for chlorophyll; P for phosphorylation; Mn, Cl for photolysis; Cu for plastocyanin
PollutantsSO₂, NO₂, ozone and smog reduce the rate
InternalPigment amount, hydrated protoplasm and enzymes, sugar build-up, leaf anatomy (cuticle, stomata, Kranz), hormones such as gibberellins and cytokinins

Worked example 1: applying Blackman's law

A plant in bright light shows the same photosynthetic rate when light is made even brighter, but the rate jumps when CO₂ is raised. Reasoning: extra light changed nothing, so light was not limiting; extra CO₂ raised the rate, so CO₂ was the limiting factor. If CO₂ keeps rising, the rate will level off again when light (or another factor) becomes limiting.

Photosynthesis in bacteria

Bacterial photosynthesis appeared first in evolution. Bacteria have no chloroplasts; their pigments sit in chlorosomes and chromatophores. Van Niel (1930) studied bacteria that release sulphur instead of oxygen, using hydrogen sulphide as the electron donor. They contain bacteriochlorophylls and carotenoids. There are three groups: green sulphur bacteria (Chlorobium), purple sulphur bacteria (Chromatium, Thiospirillum) and purple non-sulphur bacteria (Rhodospirillum, Rhodopseudomonas).

Plant and bacterial photosynthesis (as compared in the textbook)
FeaturePlantsBacteria
Electron donorWaterH₂S (or other compounds)
Oxygen releasedYesNo
PhotosystemsPS I and PS IIOne photosystem
Reaction centreP700 and P680P870
PhosphorylationCyclic and non-cyclicCyclic
Reducing agentNADPH + H⁺NADH + H⁺
ApparatusChloroplastChlorosomes and chromatophores

Worked example 2: the bacterial equation

By analogy with plants, write a balanced equation for sulphur bacteria making glucose: 6CO₂ + 12H₂S → C₆H₁₂O₆ + 6H₂O + 12S. Check: C 6 = 6. H: 24 = 12 + 12. O: 12 = 6 + 6. S: 12 = 12. Balanced. Sulphur, not oxygen, is released because the electron donor is H₂S, which supports the idea that the O₂ of plants comes from water.

Key takeaways: CAM separates CO₂ capture (night) and the Calvin cycle (day). Photorespiration is RuBisCO acting as oxygenase, running through chloroplast, peroxisome and mitochondrion and wasting carbon. The factor in shortest supply limits photosynthesis. Bacteria photosynthesise without releasing O₂, using H₂S.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In CAM plants, malic acid accumulates in the vacuole:

    1. During the day, when stomata are open
    2. Only in the bundle sheath
    3. During the night, when stomata are open
    4. Only when light is limiting
    Show answer

    Answer: C. CAM plants open their stomata at night, fix CO₂ into OAA with PEP carboxylase and store it as malic acid in the vacuole. By day, with stomata closed, malic acid releases CO₂ for the Calvin cycle.

  2. 2. In photorespiration, two molecules of glycine combine to form serine in the:

    1. Chloroplast
    2. Mitochondrion
    3. Peroxisome
    4. Vacuole
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Glycine formed in the peroxisome moves to the mitochondrion, where two glycines give one serine, releasing CO₂ and NH₃.

  3. 3. Which is TRUE of photorespiration but not of dark respiration?

    1. It produces ATP
    2. It occurs in all living cells
    3. It uses carbohydrates as substrate
    4. It produces hydrogen peroxide
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Photorespiration produces H₂O₂ in the peroxisome when glycolate is oxidised. It produces no ATP, occurs only in green cells in light, and its substrate is glycolate.

  4. 4. A plant's photosynthetic rate does not rise when CO₂ is increased, but rises when light is increased. According to Blackman, the limiting factor was:

    1. Light
    2. CO₂
    3. Temperature
    4. Water
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Raising CO₂ had no effect, so CO₂ was not limiting. Raising light increased the rate, so light was the factor in shortest supply, the limiting factor.

  5. 5. Which feature is correct for photosynthesis in sulphur bacteria?

    1. Water is the electron donor
    2. Oxygen is released
    3. Hydrogen sulphide is the electron donor and no oxygen is released
    4. Both PS I and PS II are used
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Sulphur bacteria use H₂S as the electron donor, so sulphur, not oxygen, is released. The textbook describes one photosystem with reaction centre P870.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Photosynthesis

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery