- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Modern trends in taxonomy and cladistics
Describe chemotaxonomy, biosystematics, karyotaxonomy, serotaxonomy, molecular taxonomy with its markers, and DNA barcoding; compare classical and modern taxonomy; and explain cladistics with monophyletic, paraphyletic and polyphyletic groups.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define chemotaxonomy, biosystematics, karyotaxonomy and serotaxonomy and give their aims.
- Name molecular markers and explain RFLP, AFLP and RAPD in outline.
- Explain DNA barcoding and name the plant barcode genes.
- Compare classical (alpha) and modern (omega) taxonomy.
- Explain cladistics and distinguish monophyletic, paraphyletic and polyphyletic groups.
Taxonomists now accept that external form alone is not enough. Evidence from cytology, genetics, anatomy, physiology, embryology, ecology, palynology, biochemistry and DNA adds characters that solve difficult problems. This has moved taxonomy from alpha (classical) towards omega (modern) taxonomy.
New sources of evidence
| Approach | What it uses | Notes from the textbook |
|---|---|---|
| Chemotaxonomy | Chemical constituents: proteins, amino acids, nucleic acids, peptides | Characters: easily seen (starch grains, silica), found by tests (phenolics, oils, waxes), and proteins. Aims to improve classification and knowledge of phylogeny |
| Biosystematics | Experimental, ecological and cytotaxonomy | Term by Camp and Gilly (1943). Aims to delimit natural populations, trace evolution, and recognise ecotypes, ecospecies, cenospecies and comparium |
| Karyotaxonomy (cytotaxonomy) | Chromosome number, size, shape and meiotic behaviour | Chromosomes carry genetic information |
| Serotaxonomy (immunotaxonomy) | Antigen-antibody reactions between plant proteins | Measures similarity between taxa; serology supported moving Phaseolus aureus and P. mungo to Vigna |
| Molecular taxonomy | Differences in DNA sequences | Results shown as a phylogenetic tree |
Molecular markers
Markers used include allozymes, mitochondrial DNA, microsatellites, RFLP, RAPD, AFLP, single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and microarrays. In RFLP (restriction fragment length polymorphism), DNA is cut with restriction enzymes; taxa differ in where the cutting sites lie and so in the lengths of fragments produced. AFLP (amplified fragment length polymorphism) also cuts DNA with restriction enzymes and then amplifies selected fragments; it is used mostly in population genetics and closely related species. RAPD (random amplified polymorphic DNA) uses short random primers that bind at various places; where two binding sites face each other close enough, PCR amplifies the region between. RAPD results are hard to replicate.
Molecular taxonomy shows relationships at the DNA level, reveals evolutionary history, helps identify many species through conserved sequences, supports phytogeography, genome mapping and biodiversity conservation, and allows DNA-based probes to be designed.
DNA barcoding
A supermarket scanner reads a barcode to tell one product from another. DNA barcoding, proposed by Paul Hebert in 2003, identifies species using a very short DNA sequence from a standard region of the genome, called a DNA tag or barcode. For plants the approved regions are in two chloroplast genes, matK and rbcL. An unknown sequence is compared with sequences in GenBank using the BLAST program. Barcoding helps identify and classify organisms, maps biodiversity, and can check whether whole, cut or powdered plant material is authentic. It needs a large reference database and prior knowledge of the barcode region.
Classical and modern taxonomy
-
Classical (alpha)
- Old systematics; pre-Darwinian
- Species static, the basic unit
- Mainly morphological characters
- Based on a few specimens
-
Modern (omega)
- Neosystematics or biosystematics; post-Darwinian
- Species dynamic, ever changing
- Morphology, reproduction and phylogeny
- Based on many specimens
Cladistics
Cladistics (Greek klados, branch) classifies organisms into monophyletic groups descended from a common ancestor, using shared derived (apomorphic) characters. A clade has at least one derived character present in its most recent common ancestor and absent from other groups, so its members are more closely related to one another. The characters may be morphological (leaf, flower, fruit, seed), behavioural (flowers opening at night or by day) or molecular (DNA or protein sequences). The result is a tree-shaped cladogram, the best hypothesis of relationships, now usually built from sequence data with computer software.
| Group | Definition | Status in cladistics |
|---|---|---|
| Monophyletic | An ancestor and all of its descendants | Accepted |
| Paraphyletic | An ancestor and some, but not all, of its descendants | Used only occasionally for convenience, as with the dicots |
| Polyphyletic | Members drawn from two or more different lineages | Rejected |
Clades are defined by shared DERIVED characters. Monophyletic = ancestor + ALL descendants.
Worked reasoning example 1: is the group monophyletic?
Imagine (a made-up tree) an ancestor X with three descendant lineages A, B and C, where C later gave rise to lineage D. A group containing X, A, B and C but leaving out D is proposed. Step 1: D is a descendant of X through C. Step 2: the group includes the ancestor but not all its descendants. Answer: paraphyletic. Adding D makes it monophyletic. A group of A plus an unrelated lineage from another ancestor would be polyphyletic.
Worked reasoning example 2: checking a herbal powder
A shop sells a powdered root said to come from a particular medicinal plant. With no leaves or flowers, the powder cannot be identified by morphology. Reasoning: (1) DNA survives in dried, powdered material. (2) The matK and rbcL regions can be sequenced from it. (3) The sequence is compared with reference sequences in GenBank using BLAST. (4) A close match confirms the species; a match to another plant reveals substitution. Conclusion: DNA barcoding can authenticate plant material even in powdered form, as the textbook notes.
Key takeaways: chemotaxonomy, biosystematics, karyotaxonomy, serotaxonomy and molecular taxonomy add new characters to classification. Molecular markers such as RFLP, AFLP and RAPD compare DNA. DNA barcoding identifies plants by matK and rbcL sequences. Cladistics groups organisms by shared derived characters into monophyletic clades shown in cladograms.
Check your understanding
-
1. Taxonomy based on similarities and differences among immune reactions of different taxa is
- Chemotaxonomy
- Molecular systematics
- Numerical taxonomy
- Serotaxonomy
Show answer
Answer: D. Serotaxonomy (immunotaxonomy) compares antigen-antibody reactions of plant proteins to judge how similar taxa are.
-
2. The term biosystematics was introduced by
- Camp and Gilly
- Paul Hebert
- Bentham and Hooker
- Ernst Mayr
Show answer
Answer: A. Camp and Gilly introduced the term biosystematics in 1943. Paul Hebert proposed DNA barcoding.
-
3. The gene regions approved as plant DNA barcodes are
- atpB and 18S
- rbcL and 16S
- matK and rbcL
- COI and matK
Show answer
Answer: C. Two chloroplast genes, matK and rbcL, are the approved barcode regions for plants.
-
4. A group that includes an ancestor but not all of its descendants is
- Monophyletic
- Paraphyletic
- Polyphyletic
- A clade
Show answer
Answer: B. A paraphyletic group leaves out some descendants of its ancestor; the textbook gives the dicots as an example. A clade is monophyletic.
-
5. Which statement about modern (omega) taxonomy is correct?
- It treats species as static
- It is pre-Darwinian
- It relies on a few specimens
- It uses phylogenetic relationships as well as morphology
Show answer
Answer: D. Modern taxonomy is post-Darwinian, treats species as dynamic, studies many samples and uses morphology, reproductive characters and phylogeny.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.