• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Systems of classification: artificial, natural and phylogenetic

Explain the need for classification and compare Linnaeus's artificial sexual system, Bentham and Hooker's natural system, and the phylogenetic systems of Engler and Prantl, Cronquist and the Angiosperm Phylogeny Group.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State why classification is needed.
  • Explain Linnaeus's sexual system and why it failed.
  • Outline Bentham and Hooker's classes, subclasses and series and their merits.
  • Describe the systems of Engler and Prantl and of Cronquist.
  • Describe the basis and outline of APG IV.

Picture a library being renovated, with every book piled on the floor: finding one story book could take hours. Once the books are back on shelves by genre, it takes minutes. Classification does the same for plants: it is the scientific basis for cataloguing and retrieving information about the huge diversity of the flora, arranging organisms into groups by similarities, differences and relationships. Ranks are hierarchical, and the scheme must be flexible enough to place newly discovered plants.

Need for classification

  • It gives insight into other fields and has practical value.
  • It shows the different taxa, their phylogenetic relationships and exact positions.
  • It trains students in the diversity of organisms and their links with other branches of biology.

Artificial system: Linnaeus

Carolus Linnaeus (1707-1778), the Father of Taxonomy, described 7,300 species in Species Plantarum (1753) and grouped them into 24 classes mainly by the number, union, length and distribution of stamens (Monandria, one stamen; Diandria, two; and so on), the 24th being Cryptogamia, the flowerless plants. Classes were divided into orders by carpel characters, so it is called the sexual system. It was simple and stayed in use for over a century, but it placed unrelated plants together and separated related ones. For example, Zingiberaceae (a monocot family) and Anacardiaceae (a dicot family) fell in Monandria because both have one stamen, and Prunus was grouped with cactus because of the same stamen number.

Natural system: Bentham and Hooker

Later botanists realised that no single character should outweigh others. The first scheme based on overall similarity was A.L. de Jussieu's (1789). The most widely used natural system was by George Bentham and Joseph Dalton Hooker in Genera Plantarum (1862-1883), describing 202 families and 97,205 species of seed plants. It was not intended to be phylogenetic.

Bentham and Hooker: seed plants

  • Class I Dicotyledonae
    • Polypetalae: Thalamiflorae (dome-shaped thalamus, superior ovary)
    • Polypetalae: Disciflorae (disc below a superior ovary)
    • Polypetalae: Calyciflorae (cup-shaped thalamus, inferior or half-inferior ovary)
    • Gamopetalae: Inferae (inferior ovary)
    • Gamopetalae: Heteromerae (superior ovary, more than two carpels)
    • Gamopetalae: Bicarpellatae (superior ovary, two carpels)
    • Monochlamydeae: perianth not differentiated or absent
  • Class II Gymnospermae
    • Gnetaceae, Coniferae, Cycadaceae
  • Class III Monocotyledonae
    • 7 series, 34 families

It remained popular because its descriptions were accurate, made from actual specimens, and it was easy to follow, so many herbaria, especially in former colonies, are arranged by it and use it as a key for identification.

Phylogenetic systems

Darwin's Origin of Species (1859) encouraged classification by evolutionary relationship. Adolph Engler and Karl Prantl, in Die Natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien (1887-1915), divided the plant kingdom into 13 divisions: 11 of thallophytes, Embryophyta Asiphonogama (embryo but no pollen tube: bryophytes and pteridophytes) and Embryophyta Siphonogama (seed plants). Arthur Cronquist (1968, The Evolution and Classification of Flowering Plants) used anatomical and phytochemical as well as other characters, dividing angiosperms into Magnoliopsida (dicots, 6 subclasses) and Liliopsida (monocots, 5 subclasses). It was not convenient for identification or for arranging herbaria.

Angiosperm Phylogeny Group (APG)

APG classifications (APG I 1998, II 2003, III 2009, IV 2016) recognise only monophyletic groups, using morphology, anatomy, embryology, palynology, karyology, phytochemistry and, above all, DNA sequences of two chloroplast genes (atpB and rbcL) and the nuclear 18S ribosomal DNA. According to the textbook, APG IV recognises 64 orders and 416 families, arranged in three groups.

APG IV: three groups of angiosperms

  • Early angiosperms
    • ANA grade, magnoliids, Chloranthales
    • Ethereal oils present
    • Pollen monosulcate
    • Carpels usually free
  • Monocots
    • One cotyledon, short-lived primary root
    • Scattered bundles, no cambium
    • Parallel venation, parts in threes
    • Pollen monosulcate
  • Eudicots
    • Two cotyledons
    • Trilacunar nodes, anomocytic stomata
    • Parts in twos, fours or fives
    • Pollen tricolpate

APG keeps changing as new data arrive. The textbook notes that it is the currently accepted system worldwide and that major herbaria, including Kew, are rearranging their collections by it, although it has not yet fully entered the Indian botanical curriculum.

Artificial: one or few characters (Linnaeus, stamens). Natural: overall similarity (Bentham and Hooker). Phylogenetic: evolutionary relationship (Engler and Prantl, Cronquist, APG).

Worked reasoning example 1: placing a plant in Bentham and Hooker

A dicot has free petals, a cup-shaped thalamus and an inferior ovary. Step 1: dicot with two whorls of perianth and free petals puts it in Polypetalae. Step 2: within Polypetalae, a cup-shaped thalamus with an inferior or half-inferior ovary marks the series Calyciflorae (not Thalamiflorae or Disciflorae, which have superior ovaries). Answer: Class Dicotyledonae, subclass Polypetalae, series Calyciflorae.

Worked reasoning example 2: why Linnaeus's system is artificial

Ginger (a monocot) and a member of the mango family (a dicot) end up in the same Linnaean class. Reasoning: (1) The class was decided by one character, the number of stamens, which both share. (2) In almost every other respect, seed, leaf venation, vascular bundles, flower parts, they are very different. (3) A grouping based on one convenient character rather than overall similarity or descent is artificial. Conclusion: the system is easy to use but does not reflect natural relationships.

Key takeaways: classification organises plants for identification and understanding. Linnaeus's sexual system used stamens and was artificial. Bentham and Hooker's natural system, with its classes, subclasses and series, remains handy for identification. Engler and Prantl, Cronquist and APG are phylogenetic; APG uses DNA data and recognises only monophyletic groups.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Linnaeus's 24 classes were based mainly on the features of the

    1. Leaves
    2. Stamens
    3. Roots
    4. Seeds
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Linnaeus's sexual system used the number, union, length and distribution of stamens to make classes, with carpel characters for orders.

  2. 2. In Bentham and Hooker's system, flowers with a disc below a superior ovary and free petals belong to the series

    1. Thalamiflorae
    2. Calyciflorae
    3. Inferae
    4. Disciflorae
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Disciflorae have a prominent disc-shaped thalamus and superior ovary. Thalamiflorae have a dome-shaped thalamus and Calyciflorae a cup-shaped one with an inferior or half-inferior ovary; Inferae are gamopetalous.

  3. 3. Engler and Prantl placed bryophytes and pteridophytes in

    1. Embryophyta Asiphonogama
    2. Embryophyta Siphonogama
    3. Thallophyta
    4. Monochlamydeae
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Embryophyta Asiphonogama are plants with an embryo but no pollen tube: bryophytes and pteridophytes. Seed plants are Embryophyta Siphonogama.

  4. 4. Cronquist divided the angiosperms into

    1. Polypetalae and Gamopetalae
    2. Archichlamydeae and Metachlamydeae
    3. Magnoliopsida and Liliopsida
    4. Early angiosperms, monocots and eudicots
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Cronquist's two classes were Magnoliopsida (dicots) and Liliopsida (monocots). The three-group split is APG, and Archichlamydeae and Metachlamydeae belong to Engler and Prantl.

  5. 5. Which chloroplast genes were used in APG classification?

    1. matK and 18S
    2. atpB and rbcL
    3. rbcL and 16S
    4. nifH and atpB
    Show answer

    Answer: B. APG relied strongly on sequences of the chloroplast genes atpB and rbcL and the nuclear 18S ribosomal DNA.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery