- Practice
- About 24 min
- 5 practice questions
Kossel-Lewis approach, Lewis structures and formal charge
Use the octet rule to explain bonding, draw Lewis structures step by step, choose the best structure using formal charge and recognise the three kinds of exception to the octet rule.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the Kossel-Lewis approach and state the octet rule.
- Draw Lewis dot symbols for atoms and Lewis structures for molecules and ions.
- Calculate formal charges and use them to pick the best Lewis structure.
- Give examples of electron-deficient, odd-electron and expanded-octet molecules.
Diamond is very hard but graphite, also pure carbon, is soft. CCl₄ is a liquid that does not mix with water, while NaCl is a hard, brittle solid that dissolves easily. Water is bent; CO₂ is straight. These differences come from the forces holding atoms together. The attractive forces that hold atoms or ions together in a substance are chemical bonds.
The Kossel-Lewis approach and the octet rule
In 1916 Kossel and Lewis noted that noble gases hardly react and linked this to their completely filled outer shells. Other atoms, they proposed, reach such a configuration by losing, gaining or sharing electrons. Sodium loses one electron (Na⁺) and chlorine gains it (Cl⁻), both reaching a noble gas configuration; the ions are held by electrostatic attraction, an electrovalent (ionic) bond. In molecules such as N₂ and O₂, Lewis proposed that atoms share electrons instead.
Octet rule: atoms transfer or share electrons so that each atom in the bond ends up with eight electrons in its valence shell (two, a duet, for hydrogen and helium).
In a Lewis dot symbol, valence electrons are dots around the element symbol: the first four go singly on the four sides, and from the fifth onwards they pair up. Nitrogen (1s² 2s² 2p³) has 5 valence dots, carbon 4, oxygen 6; helium shows just one pair. As a rule metals combine with non-metals to form ionic compounds, and non-metals combine with each other through covalent bonds.
Covalent bonds
Mutual sharing of one or more pairs of electrons between two atoms is a covalent bond. One shared pair is a single bond (H–H in H₂), two pairs a double bond (O=O in O₂) and three pairs a triple bond (N≡N in N₂). Unshared pairs on an atom are lone pairs. In nearly all their compounds, H and F form one bond, O two, N three and C four.
Drawing a Lewis structure
Steps for a Lewis structure
- Skeleton Less electronegative atom in the centre; H and F always at the ends.
- Count valence electrons Add one per negative charge; subtract one per positive charge.
- Single bonds Join the atoms; each bond uses two electrons.
- Lone pairs Give the rest as pairs, starting with the most electronegative atoms.
- Check octets If an atom is short, turn a neighbour's lone pair into an extra bond.
Worked example 1: HCN and NH₄⁺
HCN. Skeleton H–C–N. Valence electrons = 1 + 4 + 5 = 10. Two single bonds use 4, leaving 6, placed as three lone pairs on N. Now C has only 4 electrons, so move two lone pairs from N into bonds with C: H–C≡N, with one lone pair on N. Check: H 2, C 8 (four bonds), N 8 (three bonds plus one pair); electrons used = 4 × 2 + 2 = 10 ✓. NH₄⁺. Valence electrons = 5 + 4 × 1 − 1 = 8, exactly four N–H bonds, no lone pairs.
Formal charge
Sometimes the steps give more than one acceptable structure. For CO₂ (16 valence electrons) we can draw O=C=O, or O–C≡O with three lone pairs on the single-bonded O and one on the triple-bonded O. To decide, we compare formal charges: the difference between an atom's valence electrons when isolated and the electrons assigned to it in the structure.
Formal charge = N_v − (N_l + N_b/2), where N_v = valence electrons of the free atom, N_l = electrons in lone pairs on the atom, N_b = electrons in bonds around the atom.
- A structure with all formal charges zero is preferred to one with charges.
- Smaller formal charges are preferred to larger ones.
- A negative formal charge should sit on the most electronegative atom.
Worked example 2: formal charges in CO₂ and O₃
O=C=O: C = 4 − (0 + 8/2) = 0; each O = 6 − (4 + 4/2) = 0. O–C≡O: C = 0; single-bonded O = 6 − (6 + 2/2) = −1; triple-bonded O = 6 − (2 + 6/2) = +1. All zeros win, so O=C=O is the better structure. Ozone, O=O–O (18 electrons; central O has one lone pair): central O = 6 − (2 + 6/2) = +1; double-bonded end O = 6 − (4 + 4/2) = 0; single-bonded end O = 6 − (6 + 2/2) = −1. The charges add to 0, as they must for a neutral molecule.
Exceptions to the octet rule
Three kinds of exception
-
Electron-deficient centre
- BF₃: only 6 electrons on B
- A B=F double bond would put + charge on F, so the incomplete octet is preferred
- Also BCl₃, BeCl₂
-
Odd number of electrons
- NO (11 valence electrons)
- NO₂ (17 valence electrons)
- One atom cannot complete its octet
-
Expanded valence shell
- PCl₅: 10 electrons around P
- SF₆: 12 electrons around S
- Central atom of period 3 or later uses vacant d orbitals
Key takeaways: atoms bond to reach noble-gas configurations by transfer or sharing. Follow the five steps to draw Lewis structures, then use formal charge N_v − (N_l + N_b/2) to choose among them. The octet rule fails for electron-deficient (BF₃), odd-electron (NO) and expanded-octet (SF₆) molecules.
Check your understanding
-
1. How many valence electrons are used in the Lewis structure of the nitrite ion, NO₂⁻?
- 17
- 16
- 18
- 15
Show answer
Answer: C. N has 5 and each O has 6: 5 + 2 × 6 = 17. The single negative charge adds one more electron: 17 + 1 = 18.
-
2. In the Lewis structure of NH₄⁺, what is the formal charge on nitrogen?
- +1
- 0
- −1
- +4
Show answer
Answer: A. N has N_v = 5, no lone pairs (N_l = 0) and four bonds (N_b = 8). Formal charge = 5 − (0 + 8/2) = 5 − 4 = +1, which is the charge of the ion.
-
3. Which molecule has a central atom with an expanded octet?
- BF₃
- NH₃
- NO
- SF₆
Show answer
Answer: D. In SF₆ sulphur is surrounded by six bond pairs, 12 electrons, using vacant 3d orbitals. BF₃ is electron-deficient, NO has an odd number of electrons, and NH₃ obeys the octet rule.
-
4. Why is the structure of BF₃ with only six electrons on boron preferred to one with a B=F double bond?
- Because boron cannot form any bonds.
- Because the double-bonded structure gives fluorine, the most electronegative atom, a positive formal charge.
- Because fluorine has only six valence electrons.
- Because a double bond would give boron an expanded octet.
Show answer
Answer: B. In the B=F structure the double-bonded F has formal charge 7 − (4 + 4/2) = +1, and B has −1. Putting a positive charge on the most electronegative atom is unfavourable, so the incomplete octet is preferred.
-
5. What is the formal charge on the carbon atom in the cyanide ion, [C≡N]⁻, where C and N each carry one lone pair?
- 0
- +1
- −1
- −2
Show answer
Answer: C. C: N_v = 4, N_l = 2, N_b = 6. Formal charge = 4 − (2 + 6/2) = 4 − 5 = −1. N: 5 − (2 + 3) = 0. The total, −1, matches the ion's charge.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.