- Practice
- About 22 min
- 5 practice questions
From Rutherford to Bohr: atom models and their limits
Recall the Thomson and Rutherford models, state Bohr's postulates, use rₙ = 0.529 n²/Z Å and Eₙ = −13.6 Z²/n² eV, and explain where the Bohr model fails.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Summarise how the Thomson and Rutherford models arose and why Rutherford's model could not explain a stable atom.
- State Bohr's postulates, including the quantisation of angular momentum.
- Calculate the radius and energy of an orbit in hydrogen and hydrogen-like ions.
- List the limitations of Bohr's model.
The word atom comes from a Greek word meaning 'cannot be divided'. That idea held until the discovery of electrons, protons and neutrons. Each new experiment forced a new model of the atom, and the problems left by those models led to the quantum mechanical model that this unit builds up.
Thomson and Rutherford
J. J. Thomson's cathode ray experiments showed that atoms contain negatively charged electrons. He pictured the atom as a sphere of positive charge with electrons embedded in it, like seeds in a watermelon. Rutherford tested this by firing fast α-particles at a thin gold foil.
| Observation | What it showed |
|---|---|
| Most α-particles passed straight through | Most of the atom is empty space |
| Some were deflected through small angles | There is a concentrated positive charge inside |
| Very few bounced back through 180° | That positive charge, the nucleus, is tiny and holds most of the mass |
Rutherford proposed a tiny positive nucleus with electrons moving round it at high speed. But electromagnetic theory says a moving (accelerating) charge should radiate energy continuously, so the electron should spiral into the nucleus and the atom should collapse. Atoms are stable, and the model also said nothing about how electrons are arranged or what energies they have.
Bohr's model of the hydrogen atom
Planck and Einstein had shown that the energy of radiation comes in packets of hν, where h = 6.626 × 10⁻³⁴ J s. Niels Bohr (1913) applied this quantum idea to the energy of the electron in a hydrogen atom:
- The energies of electrons in an atom are quantised: only certain values are allowed.
- The electron revolves round the nucleus in circular paths of fixed energy called stationary orbits.
- Only those orbits are allowed in which the angular momentum is a whole-number multiple of h/2π: mvr = nh/2π, n = 1, 2, 3 ....
- While in a stationary orbit the electron loses no energy. When it drops from a higher level E₂ to a lower level E₁, the difference is emitted as radiation of frequency ν = (E₂ − E₁)/h; when the right energy is absorbed it jumps up.
For a hydrogen-like species (one electron only: H, He⁺, Li²⁺ ...) with nuclear charge Z, Bohr's postulates give the radius and energy of the nth orbit. The derivation comes in Class 12 physics; here we use the results.
rₙ = 0.529 × n²/Z Å; Eₙ = −13.6 × Z²/n² eV per atom = −1312.8 × Z²/n² kJ mol⁻¹
The energy is negative because the bound electron has less energy than a free electron at rest infinitely far away, which is taken as zero. The larger n, the bigger the orbit and the less negative (less tightly bound) the energy.
Worked example 1: radius in He⁺
Find the radius of the second orbit of He⁺ (Z = 2). Working: r₂ = 0.529 × 2²/2 Å = 0.529 × 4/2 Å = 1.058 Å. In hydrogen the same orbit has r₂ = 0.529 × 4 = 2.116 Å, twice as large, because He⁺ has twice the nuclear charge pulling the electron in.
Worked example 2: energies in H and Li²⁺
Hydrogen, n = 3: E₃ = −13.6 × 1²/3² = −13.6/9 = −1.51 eV. Li²⁺ (Z = 3), n = 1: E₁ = −13.6 × 3²/1² = −122.4 eV, or −1312.8 × 9 = −11 815 kJ mol⁻¹. Nine times hydrogen's ground-state energy, so the electron is held far more tightly.
Worked example 3: the photon from n = 3 to n = 2 in hydrogen
Working: ΔE = E₃ − E₂ = −1.511 − (−3.400) = 1.889 eV, or 13.6 × (1/2² − 1/3²) = 13.6 × 5/36 = 1.889 eV. In joules: 1.889 × 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ = 3.026 × 10⁻¹⁹ J. Frequency ν = ΔE/h = 3.026 × 10⁻¹⁹ ÷ 6.626 × 10⁻³⁴ = 4.57 × 10¹⁴ Hz; wavelength λ = c/ν = 3.0 × 10⁸ ÷ 4.57 × 10¹⁴ = 6.57 × 10⁻⁷ m ≈ 657 nm, red light.
What the Bohr model can and cannot do
-
Successes
- Explains why the hydrogen atom is stable
- Gives orbit radii and energies for one-electron species
- Explains the line spectrum of hydrogen
-
Failures
- Does not work for atoms with more than one electron
- Cannot explain splitting of lines in a magnetic field (Zeeman effect) or an electric field (Stark effect)
- Gives no reason why angular momentum must be nh/2π
The last failure was answered by Louis de Broglie, whose idea of matter waves is the subject of the next lesson.
Key takeaways: Rutherford's nuclear atom could not explain stability. Bohr's stationary orbits with mvr = nh/2π give rₙ = 0.529 n²/Z Å and Eₙ = −13.6 Z²/n² eV for one-electron species, and a photon of frequency ΔE/h for each jump. The model fails for many-electron atoms and for line splitting in fields.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is the radius of the third Bohr orbit of a hydrogen atom?
- 1.587 Å
- 4.761 Å
- 0.176 Å
- 2.116 Å
Show answer
Answer: B. rₙ = 0.529 × n²/Z Å = 0.529 × 9/1 = 4.761 Å. Multiplying by n instead of n² gives the wrong value 1.587 Å.
-
2. What is the energy of the electron in the n = 2 orbit of He⁺?
- −3.4 eV
- −54.4 eV
- −13.6 eV
- −6.8 eV
Show answer
Answer: C. Eₙ = −13.6 × Z²/n² eV = −13.6 × 2²/2² = −13.6 × 4/4 = −13.6 eV, the same as hydrogen's ground state.
-
3. Which equation states Bohr's condition for an allowed orbit?
- mvr = nh/2π
- mvr = 2πnh
- mvr = nh/4π
- mv²r = nh
Show answer
Answer: A. Bohr postulated that the angular momentum mvr of the electron is a whole-number multiple of h/2π, so mvr = nh/2π with n = 1, 2, 3 ....
-
4. Which of these could Bohr's model NOT explain?
- The line spectrum of hydrogen
- The stability of the hydrogen atom
- The splitting of spectral lines in a magnetic field
- The energy levels of the He⁺ ion
Show answer
Answer: C. The splitting of lines in a magnetic field (the Zeeman effect) is one of the model's failures. It does explain hydrogen's spectrum and stability and works for one-electron ions such as He⁺.
-
5. How much energy is needed to remove the electron from the n = 2 level of a hydrogen atom?
- 13.6 eV
- 10.2 eV
- 1.51 eV
- 3.4 eV
Show answer
Answer: D. E₂ = −13.6/2² = −3.4 eV. To remove the electron it must be raised to zero energy (n = ∞), so 3.4 eV must be supplied. 10.2 eV is the energy for the jump from n = 1 to n = 2.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.